Investigations Flashcards
Identification of homicide cases
- report of a missing person
- sudden unexplained death of an infant
- unexplained death
- report of an abduction
- report of violence where no fatalities are anticipated
- crime scene without a body present
- hit and run vehicular collision
- suicide
- fatal fire
- drug related deaths.
VAWSEEPO
Victim
Identify and locate the victim(s).
Appreciation
Make an initial appreciation of the incident. Assess personal risk and then preserve the lives of others.
Witnesses
Locate and contain witnesses.
Scene
Preserve the scene (e.g. set boundaries).
Exhibits
Note evidence and preserve any that would otherwise be lost or destroyed.
Elements
Consider whether the ingredients of the alleged offence have been established.
Powers
Identify what powers are available and consider whether to execute them.
Offenders
Identify and apprehend suspect(s).
What is an appreciation
An appreciation is a proven method of problem solving. The process follows a series of set steps to ensure the optimum course of action is decided upon. It considers all appropriate factors and weighs the benefits and risks of all alternative solutions, allowing sound decisions to be taken. An appreciation is an ongoing process which involves continually thinking through each new piece of information as it is uncovered.
Benefits of an appreciation
- Informs all Police what they are expected to achieve
- Increases the chances of success, i.e. the investigative aims/objectives being met
- Establishes a sequence of activities to be carried out
- Manages risk
- Reduces uncertainty
- Eliminates duplication
- Ensures nothing is overlooked
- Effective use of resources.
Four steps of an appreciation
- Aim
An aim is a short (one line) statement which succinctly demonstrates a single objective. - Factors
A factor is any circumstance or fact that could possibly have an effect on the manner in which you will achieve your desired outcome.
Further risk to life, the location of possible suspects, resources available, evidence requiring preservation, the environment and weather conditions and history of the relevant parties are all examples of factors that may determine how actions are prioritised at the scene. - Courses open
Courses open are a list of all the possible ways the aim could be achieved, bearing in mind the factors and the deductions made from those factors. - Plan
A plan is a proposed course of action designed to put the selected course into action in order to achieve the desired aim.
Information from a complainant/informant
- identity and location of the suspect
- a first hand account of what the complainant/informant knows
- precise details of the location of the scene
- circumstances leading to the discovery
- identity of the victim
- details of anyone else at the scene
- full contact details of the complainant/informant
- demeanour of the complainant/informant
- relationship of the complainant/informant, to the victim or suspect
- details of action the complainant/informant has taken and where they have been
- details of any hazards or safety issues that may affect Police approaching the scene/victim.
First priority of attending staff
The first priority will always be to ensure the safety of the attending Police members.
Victims medical status
- Alive and uninjured
- Alive but injured
- Shows no signs of life
What should you do if victim may die
If it is anticipated the victim may die, consider recording an immediate statement, whether the victim can sign it or not. If the victim subsequently dies, their statement may be admissible in proceedings as hearsay evidence, under section 18(1) of the Evidence Act 2006. In order to be considered admissible evidence under 18(1)(a), the court must be satisfied that both the content of the statement and the person who made it, are reliable. Police taking the statement must therefore record any factors which demonstrate the reliability of the statement or its maker.
What to do if victim shows no signs of life
A fundamental responsibility of all Police employees is to preserve life. Police must never assume a person is dead unless no other conclusion is possible, i.e. a badly decomposed or mutilated corpse. Where there is the slightest possibility a person is still alive, first aid must be commenced and an ambulance requested.
The victim should not be moved any more than is necessary to establish whether the victim is alive. If the victim needs to be moved, the original position should be recorded, ideally by photograph and/or video but a sketch and description should also be completed.
What factors may influence your decision around exhibits
Some exhibits may be fragile and easily destroyed or contaminated therefore weather conditions, temperature, public activity, animals or time may influence your decisions about what initial actions are required and their priorities.
Purpose of crime scene log
- there is no unauthorised entry into the scene
- integrity of evidence or potential evidence is secured
- intelligence opportunities are maximised
- contamination issues are managed.
Initial questioning of witnesses
- What happened
- Where exactly the incident happened
- When it happened
- Who was involved
- What the witness did
- Where the witness went
- What the witness touched
- Who touched the witness
- Who else was present
- Descriptions of those present
- What did those other people present say/do.
What to do if media at the scene
If members of the media are present at the scene, keep them away from the immediate crime scene cordon and make no comment about the incident. Consult with the OC Investigation on arrival and explain what has happened, identify media members and where they are located.
O/C Investigation briefing
- What has occurred?
- What action has been taken?
- What has not been done?
- What needs to be done?
Responsibilities of the OC Body
•ensure death has been certified by a doctor or qualified paramedic using a Deceased Person Certificate (POL 265)
•maintain security and continuity of the body, samples and exhibits, from the scene to the commencement of the post-mortem examination
•secure and guard the body, body samples and any exhibits relating to the body, with dignity and respect
•note and record observations relating to the body
•note details of medical staff or others who have attended the victim
•record what actions have been taken by any party in respect of the body
•establish if the body has been moved or disturbed
•ensure the body is photographed ‘in situ’ and consider using video recording
•on authority of the OC Investigation, arrange transportation of the body to the mortuary
•complete sudden death procedures
•on authority of OC investigation, arrange formal identification of the body using form Pol 265A
•obtain historical medial records of victim for information of pathologist
•attend the post-mortem examination with the OC Investigation, or deputy appointed by them, and: ◦attend the briefing of the pathologist by the OC Investigation, and contribute as required
◦- ensure the Police photographer takes appropriate and sufficient photographs of the body before clothing is removed, again after the body is disrobed, and during the post-mortem examination. The pathologist will direct the photographer.
◦preserve evidence from the body
◦record, label and secure all samples and exhibits associated with the body
◦arrange for fingerprints and palm prints to be taken, if required
- attend the debrief of the pathologist and record the findings, on direction of the OC and/or pathologist
- ensure all cultural responsibilities have been addressed.
Crime scene attendance by Crown and pathologist
The OC Investigation will determine whether the pathologist and/or Crown Solicitor will attend the scene to view the body ‘in situ’, to gain an understanding and interpretation of the injuries.
Key areas of consideration for experts
- photographs and/or video recordings taken at the scene
- actions of the first responders
- identity of the body
- history of the body- including medical history, drugs found at the scene, action taken or developments since the discovery of the body
- timeframes relating to the finding of the body, the last sighting and other significant times that may impact upon time of death
- scope and priorities of the investigation
- any special evidential expectations and requirements
- environmental factors at the scene, i.e. weather conditions, ambient/historical temperature, nearby heating appliances, pollen influences
- any other additional information received from other experts, as appropriate.
Appreciation prior to body removal
- Notification to and response from, the Coroner
- Views of the pathologist, ESR forensic scientist and Crown Solicitor attendingthe crime scene
- Consultation with other relevant experts
- Requirement for any examination or action needed before removal, based on known facts of the case
- Best method and route for the body removal, to minimise contamination of the scene or the body, for example by using sterile stepping plates
- Supervision of the body removal
- Chain of custody of the body from the scene to the mortuary
- Safe custody of exhibits
- Family and/or cultural considerations
- The appreciation should record the Standing Operating Procedures (SOP) for what and how items of protective clothing (e.g. paper suits, gloves and masks) must be used in relation to the scene and the body. Unless a specific reason exists to retain them, items of protective clothing should be placed in a bag and destroyed. The SOP for protective clothing used at a scene should be recorded once and thereafter scene staff may refer to the SOP, rather than recording every use or change of protective clothing.
If body has been moved
- Do not attempt to restore the scene to its original unchanged condition.
- Make enquiries to enable the original unchanged scene to be subsequently reconstructed and photographed, if required.
Samples at the scene
- larvae and insects
- potential fingerprint evidence from the skin on the body of the victim and/or items of clothing worn by the body, e.g. fine woven fabrics
- DNA swabs
- extraneous items such as loose hairs, fibres, glass, paint or other fragments
- firearm residue samples.
Details of the body
- Position of the limbs.
- Appearance of the body.
- Wounds and clothing.
- Direction of any trails of blood present on the body.
- Lividity, if present (coloration of skin due to gravitational movement of blood).
- Extent of any rigor mortis present.
Responsible for body removal
OC Investigation
Appreciation prior to post-mortem
- Identification of the body at the mortuary
- Authority from the Coroner to conduct post-mortem
- Consultation with the pathologist
- Safe custody of exhibits
- Identifying who should attend the post-mortem
- Requirement for any specific need for examination or sampling based on the known facts of the case
- Appropriate resources at the post-mortem, for packaging exhibits and taking photographs
- Family and/or cultural considerations arising from the post-mortem
- Any likely requirement for a second or subsequent post-mortem.
Post-mortem examination O/C Body responsibilities
The primary role of the OC Body during a post-mortem is to observe, document and deal with exhibits associated with the body, in a structured, methodical manner.
Purpose of a post-mortem
The primary reason for conducting a post-mortem examination is to establish the cause of death.
•determing where possible, the mode and time of death
•establishing how injuries and/or events at the scene may have contributed toward the death of the victim
•determining the nature and size of any weapon(s) used
•determining the approximate height and stature of the suspect
•providing areas of interest for subsequent interviews of witnesses and/or suspects
•negating possible defences
•identifying the victim, if identity has not been established.
Attendance at post-mortem
- the pathologist
- the Coroner
- any other pathologist assisting (if authorised by the Coroner)
- a doctor who treated the deceased
- a doctor, nurse or funeral director representing the deceased (if authorised by the Coroner)
- a doctor representing the interests of a suspect who has or may be charged in relation to the death (if authorised by the Coroner)
- any other doctor or trainee doctor (if authorised by the Coroner)
- Police
- any other person authorised by a Coroner.
Taking exhibits to the mortuary
Items found at the scene which are relevant to the post-mortem examination may need to be taken to the mortuary or to the pathologist for inspection. The exhibit must be properly packaged to avoid contamination, but also be clearly visible.
To avoid any potential contamination, weapons must not be taken to the mortuary until after the post-mortem examination has been conducted. The OC Body must maintain the continuity of any exhibit used in this way.
On arrival at the mortuary
On arrival at the mortuary, the OC Body must:
- Ensure mortuary staff do not wash the body.
- Ensure the body is labelled and secured in the secure mortuary fridge.
- Retain any key used to secure the body, until it is required for the post-mortem.
- Ensure the body remains in its present condition until the commencement of the post-mortem.
- Arrange formal identification of the body.
Formal identification
The OC Body is responsible for arranging formal identification of the body and for obtaining a statement of formal identification.
Methods of identification
- fingerprints
- DNA profiling (identification results take 3-4 weeks or 48 hours for urgent analysis)
- dental records, available through the Region Forensic Dentistry Advisor
- eye examination records
- medical examination records, including scars, birth marks, implants or prosthetics, x-rays, surgical wounds, amputations and tattoos
- personal effects
- facial reconstruction.
Information through skeletal remains
a pathologist, with the assistance of a forensic anthropologist, can usually provide information such as:
•Whether the remains are actually bones.
•Whether the bones are human.
•The age, gender, height and race of the person.
Briefing the pathologist
The pathologist must be supplied with relevant information and material, i.e.
•Copy of the Notification to the Coroner (Pol 47).
•Medical Examination (MEK) kit.
•Toxicology kit.
•Medical records of the deceased, where available.
•Comprehensive photographs and/or video recordings taken at the scene. These should include photographs of exhibits, weapons and the body ‘in situ’, which will benefit the briefing for the post-mortem, as well as the subsequent examination.
Stripping the body
The OC Body is responsible for securing all exhibits taken from the body, including the clothing, samples and all items of property associated with the body.
Stripping of the body will take place immediately before the post-mortem examination commences, but must only be undertaken on the specific direction of the OC Investigation, generally after a visual examination and collection of evidence from the clothed body has been completed.
Photographing the body
- the body, before it is stripped
- the body, after it is stripped
- close up photographs of any wounds, marks, internal injuries and unusual features. These photographs must include a measuring scale placed in proximity to the feature being photographed, to make a permanent record of the dimensions of the feature.
Exhibits during post-mortem
The OC Body is responsible for recording, labelling, packaging, sealing and securing all physical exhibits relating to the body, including samples taken during the post-mortem. All exhibits must be packaged and sealed before leaving the mortuary, without exception and will be recorded in a Scene Exhibits Schedule.
Action after the post-mortem
Any wet or damp exhibits must be unsealed and dried in a controlled environment such as at a Police drying room, with due regard for the integrity of the exhibit. Once dry, they can be re-packaged and re-sealed.
The OC Body must hand all exhibits to the OC Exhibits, in order to maintain an unbroken chain of exhibit continuity and security. They should also provide the OC Exhibits with:
•the post-mortem Scene Exhibit Schedule
•copy of the OC Body’s notebook entries
•formal statement.
Preparing the sudden death file
- statement relating to the victim’s formal identification
- copy of the Police form 47 (report for the coroner) or, in the case of a child under the age of 2 years, a Police form 47A (Sudden Unexpected Death in Infancy)
- copy of Deceased Person Certificate (Police form 265)
- copy of Deceased Person Identification (Police form 265A).
Second post-mortem
- the pathologist is unable to determine cause of death in the initial post-mortem
- a suspect’s lawyer seeks approval from the Coroner to conduct an independent post-mortem
- the Solicitor General orders a further post-mortem, after an application to the High Court.
Role of the Family Liaison Officer (FLO)
The role of the Family Liaison Officer (FLO) involves the day-to-day management of the partnership between the family of the deceased and the Police investigation.
The FLO should normally report to the OC Investigation to ensure continuity of supervision.
Family Liaison Plan
- selection of the FLO and criteria employed for the selection
- exit plan for the FLO
- objectives of the family liaison
- assessing the most appropriate methods of conducting interviews with family members, including the use of specialist interviewers, where appropriate
- information to be released to and withheld from, the family
- requests made by the family which have not been agreed to, and the reasons for this
- complaints made by the family and the OC Investigation’s action to progress and resolve the issues raised
- any member of the family who could be considered a suspect, to enable the OC Investigation to determine whether or not this is the case
- liaison with Victim Support and other support services.
FLO welfare
The OC is responsible for regularly monitoring and supporting the health and welfare of the FLO and should be particularly aware of the dangers of working under high stress.
Exit plan
An exit plan must be developed before the FLO is deployed, and be communicated to the family at the commencement of the deployment. The exit plan will be determined and executed at the discretion of the OC Investigation, and should include plans for reactivation.