Interdisciplinary Flashcards
Stewart - theories on dreams
Interesting as people in REM lack meta-consciousness, making it different to waking definitions
Post-Freudian thought features models that dreams uses experiences of the past to predict the future
Stewart - 1830s dreaming
1831 - 3 shepherds instructed in dream by Panagia to dig for an icon depicting her
1835 - 2 visionaries dug at Argokoili - found bones as promised in dream
1836 - Maggioros, an oneirokrite, led to finding of 3 icons, 1 more later that month
Stewart - 1830s basis of dreaming
War of Independence against the Ottomans (from 1821)
Placement of a new monarch (Otto) on the throne in 1833, his Catholicism clashing with venerable Orthodox institutions
Icon also discovered on nearby Tinos in 1823 and church erected for the Panagia
Stewart - 1930s dreaming
Katerina and Nikiphoros Legaki dreamed of St Anne telling them to remove Panagia icon from landlord’s icon stand - brought it back to mountain
Cult of dreaming arose, children organised by Evdokia and met daily
Date for finding icon of St Anne resulting in monastery and prosperity moved further and further back
No icons ever found
Stewart - 1930s basis of dreaming
Children still ruminating on historic events, ‘active historiography’ in which concern carried into sleep
Also economic issue as crucial emery mines declined - 1924 declared ‘national property’, 1929 depression
Anxious discussion of emery mines had penetrated the minds of anxious children
Stewart - church response
Bishop of Paros and Naxos at first blessed the excavation site with holy water
1830s synods curtailed excavations - dreams became incitement to break law
Authorities removed icons, failed to prosecute charismatic movement
Eventually consecrated church in 1851
Stewart - what can be learned from this case?
Children failed at predicting the future, but diagnosed the present
1930 dreams generated myth, reacting to an earlier myth
Clearly diachronic interaction between myths and dreams of lost icons stretching back through history
Relander - birth of the dreamer religion
Smowhala born around 1815, soon travelled to Solemn Hills for a vision
Awoke with new song and power - added new rituals to old religion fragments
Washat dance developed later, after the death of daughter (Anh) - wore feathers to show climbing up
Became Washani religion
Relander - promise of the dreamer religion
Promised the daw of a new day, a resurrection of Nami Piap, leading to the overthrow of the greedy ones
Each successive promise seen as promise of fulfilment of visions, strengthened faith
Relander - reason for popularity of religion
Ripe time - expeditions in 1805 and 1811 showed encroachment of white men
Fear that white men represented fulfilment of old apocalyptic prophecies of retribution - Smowhala delivered needed hope
Relander - rights wanted by Wanapums
Wanted to choose their own locations as the whites did
Soon hopelessly entangled in workings of government - neighbouring Chief Wolf of the Palouse went bankrupt pursuing justice
Relander - Moses’ story
Moved in 1879 to 2000sq mile reservation
2 men examined government given boulder
Broke showing silver and gold - they claimed outside belonged to him, and inside to them
Relander - decline of dreamer religion
Eventually crumbled under overwhelming military might and inrushing land-mad tide of immigration
Smowhala’s power slowly decline, with his once strong band of 2000 river people slowly leaving for the life of the white man
Soon lack of food forced people to farm a little, slowly evicted from lands, last time in Priest Rapids in 1942 for government damn
Relander - nature of the book
Conveyed by oral testimony in 1960s of last 4 Wannapums
Puck Hyah Toot last one who understands the religion
Uses oral sources and references them with military reports to be accurate and capture paternalistic attitude
Fascinating ethnography, detailing customs
Relander - Indian Agent oppression
From 1861, James Wilbur oppressed them
Faith dominated his life - only allowed converted Methodists to access aid