Interaction and Identity Flashcards
Index (basic definition)
a linguistic form that depends on the interactional context for its meaning, such as the first-person pronoun I
Index (general definition)
the concept of indexicality involves the creation of semiotic links between linguistic forms and social meanings
The positionality principle
Identities encompass (a) macro-level demographic categories; (b) local, ethnographically specific cultural positions; and (c) temporary and interactionally specific stances and participant roles.
The emergence principle
Identity is best viewed as the emergent product rather than the pre-existing source of linguistic and other semiotic practices and therefore as fundamentally a social and cultural phenomenon.
Narrative inquiry
It records the experiences of an individual or small group, revealing the lived experience or particular perspective of that individual, usually primarily through interview which is then recorded and ordered into a chronological ___.
sociocultural linguistics
An interdisciplinary field that is concerned with the interplay of language, culture, and society.
The interactional level of identity…
…is what bestows identity with social meaning
Identity is emergent through interaction
it is fluid rather than fixed, and constructed in social interaction, linguistic and semiotic practices forms it, not the other way around
Identity is positional
it is formed according to the temporary positions of the given interaction (e.g. evaluator, engaged listener) simultaneously with macro and micro levels of identity
Identity is indexical
it is signaled by language (linguistic strategies) indexing membership of a social group
Identity is relational
it is relational and emerge through interaction with other individuals
Identity is partial
it is partial and incomplete, always informed by the specific contexts of the social interaction through which they are constructed
The traditional, narrow approach to identity #1
Identity is stationary within the mind of an individual → the only observable relationship between language and identity is language reflecting the mental state of the individual
this view fails to consider the social ground in which identity is constructed and maintained.
Widely circulated approach to identity #2
Identity is simply a collection of broad social categories.
Macro identity categories (qualitative social sciences)
age, gender, and social class
Micro identity (linguistic ethnography)
Formed momentarily in a social interaction
Indexicality
the mechanism whereby identity is constituted, fundamental to how linguistic forms are used to construct identity positions
Adequation
relies on the suppression of social differences that might disrupt a seamless representation of similarity
Stance
both a subjective and an intersubjective phenomenon; social action in the following terms: ‘I evaluate something, and thereby position myself, and align with you
can accumulate into more durable structures of identity, or large identity categories
Distinction
focuses on the identity relation of differentiation, on the suppression of similarities that might undermine the construction of difference.
The indexicality princple
Identity relations emerge in interaction through several related indexical processes, including:
1) overt mention of identity categories and labels;
2) implicatures and presuppositions regarding one’s own or others’ identity position;
3) displayed evaluative and epistemic orientations to ongoing talk, as well as interactional footings and participant roles; and
4) the use of linguistic structures and systems that are ideologically associated with specific personas and groups.
–> Always multiple levels apparent at the same time
The importance of the relationality principle
Identities are never autonomous or independent but always gain social meaning in relation to other available identity positions and other social actors
questions the popular yet oversimplified view: identity relations as revolving around a single axis: sameness and difference – the range of relations are much wider than that
The relationality principle
Identities are interactively constructed through several, often overlapping, complementary relations, including similarity/difference, genuineness/artifice, and authority/delegitimacy.
Authentication – Denaturalization
the processes by which speakers make claims to realness and artifice, respectively.
– associated with authenticity
Authentication
Focuses on how identities are discursively verified
a social process that is similar to the act of authenticating a piece of art (traditionalisation
Denaturalization
Focuses on how assumptions of the seamlessness of identity can be disrupted
Authorization - Illegitimation
Consider the structural and institutional aspects of identity formation
Authorization
Involves the affirmation or imposition of an identity through structures of institutionalized power and ideology, local or translocal
Illegitimation
Addresses the ways identities are dismissed, censored, or ignored by structures of authority/legitimacy
The importance of the partialness principle
There are a multitude of ways in which identites exceed the individual.
Identity is relational –> it will always be partial, produced through contextually situated and ideologically informed configurations of self and other
always reliant on the interactional and ideological constraints for their articulation
Postmodern theorizing of identity
Fractured and discountinous, constituted by context and are themselves asserted as partial accounts’
The partialness principle
Any given construct of identity may be partly intentional, partly habitual, thus often less than fully conscious, partly an outcome of interactional negotiation and contestation, partly the outcome of the perception of other, and partly the effect of large ideological processes and material structures.
Therefore, it is constantly shifting as interactions unfold, and also across discourse contexts
Agency
Understood as a dynamic and context-dependent process – as individuals are not passive recipients of the social categories attributed to them
Instead: they possess the ability to actively negotiate, resist and reframe these identities through interaction with others
may be the result of individual action, but it may also be distributed among several social actors and hence intersubjective.