Intentional Torts + other Flashcards
What kind of defenses are unavailable in intentional torts?
There are no incapacity defenses in torts. Anyone who commits elements should be held liable, even if they have capacity defect
If a child commits an intentional tort can he be held liable?
Yes. There are no incapacity defenses in torts
What is transferred intent?
If the tortfeasor intended to produce an illegal consequence and a different consequence results and/or it happens to different person, intent transfers
When does a defendant act intentionally?
A defendant acts intentionally if he desires to produce a legally forbidden consequence.
What are the elements of a battery?
- D must intentionally commit a harmful or offensive contact AND
- with a plaintiff’s person.
What is required for contact to be considered offensive?
the contanct would be unpermitted by reasonable/normal person
What does a plaintiff’s person include?
Anything that the person is holding carrying or touching.
What are the elements of assault?
- Defendant intentionally
- places plaintiff in reasonable apprehension
- of an immediate battery
What must the plaintiff be aware of in order to be in reasonable apprehension
The threat.
If someone threatens you with a gun and you don’t know there are bullets in it or not will you be considered to have been put in reasonable apprehension? Why
Yes, you can reasonably believe you are threatened.
If someone threatens you with a gun and you know there are no bullets in the gun will you be considered to have been put in reasonable apprehension? Why?
No, you know there isn’t a threat
What are the elements of false imprisonment?
- D must intentionally
- commit an act of restraint which
- confines P to a bounded area.
What are considered to be a sufficient act of restraint?
Threats are a sufficient act of restraint.
What is the most common example of a threat that is considered an act of restraint?
“if you leave, we will call the cops”.
Under what circumstances can an omission be an act of restraint?
If D owes P a duty to assist in movement an omission to assist them can be an act of restraint.
Phil a gimp (no he can’t get an erection either) needs to fly to NYC for a power bottom’s convention, flight attendants get Phil to NYC but leave his power bottom self on the plane without helping him off. Can this be considered an act of restraint? Why it why not?
This omission would be considered an act of restraint.
For an act of restraint to have occurred what must P show?
P must must show they were aware of the confinement, or suffered harm from it.
When is an area not considered bounded?
Area is not bounded if there is a reasonable means of escape that the P can reasonably discover.
When would it be considered an unreasonable means of escape?
If the way out is dangerous or disgusting or humiliating or hidden it is NOT REASONABLE means of escape.
What are the elements of Intentional Infliction of Mental Distress?
- D intentionally or recklessly commits 2. Outrageous conduct which causes 3. P to suffer severe distress
What conduct is not considered outrageous?
- Insults, Cursing, making fun of you.
- Exercise of first amendment rights. May be outrageous conduct, but not actionable because it is protected by the constitution. (Think Westboro Baptist case)
What are the hallmark of outrageous conduct?
- The conduct is continuous or repetitive
- Defendant is a common carrier or an innkeeper. Law thinks these businesses owe a duty of courtesy, if they act in a negative way with intent to produce distress law quick to get them for intentional infliction of emotional distress
- Case where the P is a member of a fragile class.
- Always outrageous for a D to target a D’s emotional weakness. Going for emotional Achilles’ heel.
What are the fragile classes?
a. Children- Don’t pick on children, insults could be outrageous conduct. Outrageous to target a child.
b. Elderly person- outrageous to target an old person.
c. Pregnant women- D needs to know the women is preggers.
Does P need to suffer physical symptoms to recover in intentional infliction of metal distress?
No, but its good for evidence.
If you are mildly annoyed do you satisfy the element of P suffering severe distress?
No, you need to suffer severe distress.
What is Trespass to Land?
An 1) intentional 2) act of physical invasion by D which 3) interferes with P’s exclusive possession of land intent
What are the two ways of trespass to chattels and conversion?
- intentionally damaging property
2. intentionally taking possession of property
What is the difference between trespass to chattels and conversion?
Difference between the 2 torts is the amount of interference, if the trespass is slight use trespass to chattels, if it is significant use conversion.
What remedy is available in trespass to chattel?
Cost or repairs or cost for time lost (or they have to give back chattel)/
What is the remedy for conversion?
they recover the full market value of the property, not the cost of repair. Conversion operates as a forced sale.
Is mistake a defense to either trespass to chattel or conversion?
No.
What are the possible defenses to intentional torts?
- Consent
- Protective privileges (self-defense, defense of others, defense of property)
- Necessity defenses`
What must you have to give consent?
Must have legal capacity to give consent.