Intentional Torts Flashcards
What is a voluntary act?
An action that is conscious or willed (≠ purely reflexive)
What elements of an intentional tort?
- Voluntary Act
- Intentional Act
- Causation
- Harm
What establishes intent for intentional torts?
- ∆ desires that his act will cause a harmful result
Or
- ∆ knows that it is substantially certain that such a result/harm will occur.
What satisfies the causation element in intentional torts?
The defendant’s act must be the cause of the plaintiff’s injury
What is the impact of proximate cause on intentional torts?
Proximate cause does not factor in because of the extended consequences rule.
What is the extended consequences rule?
A defendant is responsible for all consequences flowing from an intentional tort: whether foreseeable or not.
Are children liable for their intentional torts?
Yes, when they have the intent (knowledge) required for the tort.
Are parents liable for their children’s intentional tort?
No, parents are not directly liable unless directed by statute.
A battery occurs when a defendant does what?
Intentionally causes a harmful or offensive contact with the plaintiff or something closely connected to the plaintiff
More Info: Battery
What are the elements of battery?
- Defendant has the intent to cause a
- Harmful or offensive contact
- With the plaintiff or something physically connected to the plaintiff
What satisfies the intent element of battery?
- Defendant desired/goal to bring about the contact
Or
- Defendant knows such contact was substantially certain to result from his actions.
What is transferred Intent?
If a defendant acts with the necessary intent to inflict an intentional tort but defendant causes injury to a different victim than intended, then defendant’s intent is transferred to the actual victim.
More Info: Transferred Intent
Transferred intent applies to which torts?
- Assault
- Battery
- False Imprisonment
- Trespass to Land
- Trespass to Chattels
How does mental incompetency impact an intent requirement?
The fact that a defendant is mentally incompetent, or is a minor, does not preclude a finding that he possessed the intent to commit an intentional tort, but incompetency may affect whether such intent actually existed.
When is the harmful or offensive contact element of battery satisfied?
- The contact inflicts any physical discomfort to plaintiff
or
- Contact is offensive to a reasonable person; unless defendant know’s of plaintiff’s particular susceptibility
What can a battery’s harmful or offensive contact be made to?
- Plaintiff’s body
- Something that has a close physical connection to plaintiff’s body (something they eat or are holding)
* More Info:* Battery - Contact
In a battery, does the π need to be aware of the contact?
No
In an assault, does the plaintiff need to be aware of the contact?
Yes
Does a plaintiff have to prove harm in a battery?
No, plaintiff must only prove that it would be offensive to a reasonable person & defendant had the intent to cause the contact.
What is a the most common defense to a battery?
Consent
An assault arises when a defendant does what?
Intentionally causes the plaintiff to experience reasonable apprehension of an imminent battery.
More Info: Assault
What are the elements of an assault?
- Intent
- Reasonable apprehension
And
- Imminent battery
When a defendant intends to commit one tort but commits another, what happens?
Transferred intent applies and transfers the intent of the intended crime to the other crime.
What is the merger doctrine in intentional torts?
There is no merger doctrine, the defendant can be sued for each cause of action in which the elements are met.
What must be shown to prove the reasonable apprehension element of assault?
A reasonable person in the plaintiff’s position would have suffered apprehension; unless the defendant knows of the plaintiff’s particular susceptibility.
What happens to an assault action if the defendant lacked the ability to cause a battery?
If plaintiff’s apprehension is reasonable, the fact that the defendant lacked the actual ability to cause the battery does not defeat liability.
What must be shown in an assault action to prove imminent battery?
The battery has to be able to be carried out instantaneously.
When does false imprisonment occur?
When defendant confines a plaintiff in a bounded area against the plaintiff’s will and the plaintiff knows of the confinement or is injured by the confinement.
More Info: False Imprisonment
What are the elements of false imprisonment?
- Defendant intends to
- Confine plaintiff in a bounded area
- Against the plaintiff’s will
- Plaintiff knows of the confinement or is injured by the confinement
When does a defendant have the requisite intent for false imprisonment?
- Defendant desires to confine the plaintiff
Or
- Defendant knows that confinement is substantially certain to occur
How can a defendant confine a plaintiff?
- Use of physical barriers
- Failing to release the plaintiff when the defendant is legally obligated to do so
Or
- By the invalid assertion of legal authority to contain
* More Info:* Confinement
What is the duration requirement for false imprisonment?
There is no duration required, the duration only goes to damages.
When can threats result in a confinement?
Force or threats of force against the:
- π
- π’s close relatives
Or
- valuable personal property( ≠ threats of reputational harm)
What is the impact of a plaintiff knowing of a reasonable means of escape on a false imprisonment claim?
There is no false imprisonment if the plaintiff knows how to escape
When is there never a reasonable means of escape for false imprisonment claims?
If there is any risk of harm to the plaintiff, including the risk of embarrassment.
What is the validity of a false imprisonment claim if the plaintiff agrees to be confined?
There is no false imprisonment if there is consent.
What is the validity of a false imprisonment claim if the plaintiff was not aware that the plaintiff was being confined?
If the plaintiff is unaware, the plaintiff can only get damages if they are harmed by the confinement.