Insurance Law (TB) Flashcards
Why do alternative method to insurance not offer adequate protection? (3)
- Preventative measures cannot always be taken
- A fund may not always be sufficient
- Damages incurred by 1 legal subject could be too high (cannot bear it)
Was formal insurance recognised in Roman Law?
No.
In modern day, what are insurers generally?
A trade practiced by certain institutions who, for profit, are prepared to bear the risks for and obo individuals, who then in exchange pay the insurer a monetary premium
Name 4 points related to the history of insurance
- Hammurabi proclaimed that all caravan merchants had to contribute towards payment of damages caused by theft of property
- Greek & Roman law had insurance in their maritime law of contract
- The precursors of modern day insurance were the guilds and associations that appeared in Europe and England during Middle Ages
- Life insurance developed at a much later stage, and was only entrenched during 19th C.
Discuss the sources of insurance law (8)
- Both Roman-Dutch and English law were, until recently, deemed to be the primary sources
- In 1985, Appellate Div. decided that only Roman-Dutch law was to be applied
- Due to international nature of insurance, comparative legal studies play a major role in solving insurance problems
- Statutory regulation falls under Financial Services Board
- Short Term and Long Term Insurance acts (1998)
- PEPUDA regulates the prevention of discrimination in the insurance industry
- PPR
- Code of Conduct
Does the CPA apply to insurances?
No, it is exempted by the Financial Services Laws Amendment At 2013
Where are consumer protection measures found for the insurance industry?
In the Policyholder Protection Rules (both short- and long-term)
There are also Codes of Conduct for insurance intermediaries
Define an insurance contract (7)
A reciprocal contract
between an insurer and an insured
ito which the insurer undertakes to pay the insured an amount of money or its equivalent,
in exchange for payment of a price or premium,
should the risk, borne by the insurer obo the insured,
materialise by the happening of a specified uncertain event
in which the insured has an interest.
Name the two main types of insurances
- Indemnity (aka short-term insurance)
2. Non-indemnity (aka long-term insurance)
What is the main difference between indemnity and non-indemnity insurance?
With indemnity insurance the amount of damages claimed is directly proportional to the patrimonial loss or damage suffered, or the amount of the insurance where it is less than the loss suffered.
The nature of the interest insured is patrimonial.
The amount which the insured can receive from the insurer cannot exceed the amount of actual loss or damage incurred.
In the case of non-indemnity insurance (aka as capital insurance), the loss suffered and the amount paid by the insurer are not necessarily proportionate.
The nature of the interest insured is non-patrimonial.
What are 3 practical differences between indemnity and non-indemnity insurance?
- With indemnity insurance the insurable interest has to exist at the time of loss or damage, but with non-indemnity it must already exist at the time of conclusion of the insurance contract;
- The rules of proportionate contribution and subrogation apply to indemnity insurance, and not to -non-indemnity;
- The insurer’s liability in case of indemnity insurance is limited to the amount of damages actually incurred, while this is not true for non-indemnity insurance.
What is a Long-Term Insurance policy?
Ito sec 1 of LTIA it is ‘an assistance policy, a disability policy, fund policy, health policy, life policy or sinking fund policy, or a contract comprising a combination of these policies; and includes a contract whereby any such contract is varied’.
These long-term contracts provide policy benefits for defined longer time periods - usually exceeding 1 year.
What does the LTIA cover?
It is of a regulatory nature, and so prescribes rules for -
- Registration of insurers, business and admin practices;
- Financial arrangements;
- Judicial management;
- Final winding-up of insurers.
The Act also creates punishable offences and prescribes penalties for misconduct or non-compliance
What are the Policyholder Protection Rules (PPR)?
These rules deal with obligatory and standardised disclosures, consequences of failure to pay premiums and non-compliance, cancellation of policies, cooling-off periods, the prescribed contents of insurance agreements, etc.
What is a Short-term Insurance policy?
Ito sec1 of STIA it is ‘an engineering policy, guarantee policy, liability policy, miscellaneous policy, motor policy, accident and health policy, property policy or transportation policy or a contract comprising a combination of these policies; and includes a policy whereby any such contract is varied’
These policies provide benefits for only a defined short term, usually for 1 year or less, and are usually renewable.
What does the STIA cover?
- Registration of short-term insurers
- The control of certain activities of s-t insurers and intermediaries
- Business and admin practices
- Financial arrangements
- Judicial management
- Winding-up of insurers
- Prescribes specific fee structures
What is Property Insurance?
Concerns itself with the assets or positive elements of a person’s patrimony (i.e. car or house contents)
What is Liability Insurance?
Concerns itself with the negative elements of a person’s patrimony, namely his duties or liabilities, and is in its nature indemnity insurance (i.e. professional liability insurance)
What is Personal Insurance?
Concerns itself with aspects relating to the body and the mind of the insured or another 3rd person (i.e. life insurance)
What is the difference between valued and unvalued policies?
Valued policies specify the value of the interest that is insured, whereas unvalued policies contain no such allocated value and the insured must prove the extent of his loss.
The purpose of a valued policy is to avoid the practical difficulty of proving the extent of the loss suffered - but the insured must still prove that he suffered the loss.
What is SA’s position on Mutual Insurance?
It is not recognised in SA any longer.
All insurance are premium insurance.
What is profit insurance?
Aimed at generating a profit for the insurer that is distributed between its shareholders
What is the difference between private and social insurance?
Private insurance deals with the interests if the individual, whereas social insurance is mandatory insurance implemented by the government (i.e. UIF)
Discuss re-insurance
When an insurer takes out insurance with another insurer to make good the claims which the former had to pay out to his insureds.
It is liability insurance because the insurer reinsures his liabilities towards his clients with another insurance company.
No legal tie or obligation exists between an original insured and a reinsurer.
[ABC is insurer for X, but takes out insurance with XYZ for ABC’s liabilities]
What is captive insurance?
An insurer is established (e.g. a company is floated) by an enterprise or a group of enterprises solely for the insurance of the interests of the enterprise or members of the group of enterprises.
There is pure captives (where only the interests of the group are insured) and broad captives (which extends its business to the extent that insurance cover can also be obtained by non-members).
What is pool insurance?
A number of participating insurers pool their interests and share the results.
The insurers merely conclude a co-operation agreement and do not merge their various companies.
This is direct insurance and not re-insurance.
Discuss Lloyd’s of London (4)
- A type of insurance market or exchange, where supply and demand meet
- The insurers, who back the policies written by Lloyds, consolidate in syndicates on an ad hoc basis
- These syndicates take up the risks, and every member remains liable for specific share of the risk
- The STIA contains specific provisions that regulate Lloyd’s underwriting and representatives in SA.
What are the requirements for the conclusion of a valid insurance contract?
- Requirements for contract (i.e. consensus, capacity, certainty, legality, possibility, and formality)
- Consensus through a process of offer and acceptance must be reached on the required essentialia
How is consensus reached? (6)
- Insurers mostly issue invitations in the form of advertising to potential insureds
- The offer for insurance is usually made by the insured, who completes a standard application form in hard copy or electronically
- The parties can make counteroffers
- Who the offeror is and who the offeree is will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case
- The contract between them only exists once they have reached consensus on the terms and conditions of their agreement
- Direct marketing is relevant here - Rule 11 and 4 of PPR
Is there a cooling-off period for LTI?
No longer relevant, Rule 4 of LTPPR applies.
Discuss the renewal of a contract
Each renewal or reinstatement of a contract is a new contract of insurance.
If the insurer sends a renewal notice to the insured, this usually constitutes a new offer for insurance.
Should the insurer accept this renewal offer, a new insurance contract comes into existence as soon as the term of the previous contract comes to an end.
Acceptance can be orally or through conduct.
The terms of the new contract are by implication the same as those of the previous one.
It is nit ab extension of the previous contract, but a totally new one which immediately supervenes the previous contract.
When does reinstatement occur?
When the insured lapses in paying premiums and he elects to continue with the insurance
Discuss contractual capacity
The parties must possess the required contractual capacity to be able to conclude a valid contract of insurance.
Persons married inCOP require their spouse’s consent.
Discuss legality (as a contractual requirement)
The insurance contract must be legal.
The conclusion, purpose as well as the performance due may not be contrary to statute, good morals or public policy.
Legality is usually determined at the time of conclusion of the contract.
Where provision is unlawful and severable, will be deemed pro non scripto.
Ito PEPUDA an insurance contract may not unfairly discriminate against a person by -
- Unfairly refusing on one or more of the prohibited grounds to provide an insurance policy to any person;
- Unfairly discriminating in the provision of benefits, facilities and related insurance services; and
- Unfairly disadvantaging a person or persons including refusing to grant insurance and related services to persons on the basis of their HIV/Aids status