Individual Rights Flashcards
Procedural due process
Whether the gov’t has followed adequate procedures when it takes away a person’s life, liberty, or property.
(e.g. what kind of notice, hrg provided?)
Substantive due process
Whether the gov’t has an adequate reason for taking away a person’s life liberty, or property
(depends on level of scrutiny used)
Equal protection
Whether there’s an adequate justification for the government’s differences in the treatment of people
(depends on level of scrutiny used)
How to tell if a problem is procedural due process, substantive due process, or equal protection
- Ask:
- What’s the relief requested?
- What’s the nature of the claim?
- If the plaintiff wants better procedures, it’s procedural due process
- If the plaintiff wants the gov’t acts invalid due to lack of justification, it’s substantive due process
- If the plaintiff is saying they were treated differently than those similarly situated, it’s equal protection
When a deprivation of liberty occurs
Occurs when there is a loss of a significant freedom provided by the Constitution or a statute
Examples of loss of liberty
- Unless there’s an emergency, must have a notice and hearing to commit an adult,
- for a parent admitting a kid, only a screening by a neutral factfinder;
- harm to reputation by itself is not a loss of liberty;
- prisoners rarely have liberties.
A deprivation of property occurs when
occurs when there is an entitlement and that entitlement is not fulfilled
Rights and privileges distinction for the purpose of due process analysis
Discarded by the S. Ct. in the 1960s (often a trick q in the MBE. If this is an answer choice, it’s wrong)
When entitlement exists
exists when there is a reasonable expectation to continue receipt of a benefit
Examples of deprivation of property
Person fired w/o due process although they were promised the job for a year…
Government negligence and due process
- Government negligence is not sufficient for a deprivation of due process
- There must be an intentional government act or at least reckless action
- However, in emergency situations, the government isliable under due process only if its conduct “shocks theconscience.”
- Generally, the government’s failure to protect people from privately inflicted harm does not deny due process
- Government has duty to provide protection only if it literally creates the danger, or when the person is in government custody
Procedural Due Process Test
Balance:
- the importance of the interest to the individual 2)
- ability of additional procedures to increase the accuracy of fact-finding, and
- the government’s interests (efficiency)
Types of benefits that require a notice and hearing before they can be terminated
- welfare benefits
- permanent termination of custory
Benefit that requires only a post-termination hearing for it to be terminated
social security disability benefits
Student’s right to procedural DP in school
- Before a school can discipline a student there must be notice of the charges and an opportunity to explain
- Exception: Corporal punishment in schools does not require any due process hearing
Procedural Due Process requirement for proper punitive damages
- Punitiva damage awards require instructions to the jury and judicial review to ensure reasonableness
- excess punitive damage awards are unconstitutional.
Procedural Due Process for enemy combatants
An American citizen detained as an enemy combatant must be accorded due process
Government Seizure of Assets
- Prejudgment attachment or government seizure of assets require notice and a hearing
- Exception- Exigent Circumstances
- if there’s reason to believe the person would get rid of the property if notice came before the hearing, seizure may occur immediately after the notice
- Exception- Illegal Activties
- Government may seize assets used in illegal activity, even if the property has an innocent owner
Level of scrutiny used for economic liberties
- Only a rational basis test is used for laws affecting economic rights
- Constitution provides only minimal protection for economic liberties
Examples of laws affecting economic liberties
(RB review)
due process challenge to:
- a minimum wage law,
- state laws that regulate people practicing in certain trades or professions
- consumer protection laws
The takings clause
The government may take private property for public use if it provides just compensation
Possessory taking
Government confiscation of physical occupation of property
Regulatory taking
government regulation that leaves no reasonable economically viable use of the property
Government regulation of property development
Government conditions on development of property must be justified by a benefit that is roughly proportionate to the burden imposed
Subsequent property owner’s takings challenge
A property owner may bring a takings challenge to regulations that existed at the time the property was acquired
Takings for temporary denial of owner’s use of property
Temporarily denying an owner use of property is not a taking so long as the government’s action is reasonable