Individual Liberties Flashcards
Define procedural due process.
the procedures the government must take to deprive a person of life, liberty, or property.
Define deprivation of liberty.
A loss of significant freedom provided by the constitution or a statute.
Define deprivation of property.
when a person is entitled to a benefit and that entitlement is not fulfilled.
(entitlement = reasonable expectation to the continued receipt of a benefit)
Does negligence by the government resulting in a deprivation of liberty or property give rise to liability?
No - the government is only liable for reckless or intentional deprivation.
What is the government’s duty re: protecting individuals from privately inflicted harms?
No duty, so no due process when the government fails to protect.
If there has been a deprivation of life, liberty, or property, what are the required procedures?
It depends on the outcome of a 3-part balancing test.
- the significance of the interest to the individual
- the ability of additional procedures to reduce an erroneous deprivation of liberty (increase the accuracy of fact-finding)
- the government’s interest (usually efficiency and saving govt $).
What procedures are required to meet DP in a welfare case?
Both notice and hearing
What procedures are required to meet DP to deprive a parent of custody?
Both notice and hearing
What procedures are required to meet DP to institutionalize an adult?
Both notice and hearing (unless it’s an emergency)
What procedures are required to meet DP to deny a person Social Security disability benefits?
Only a post-termination hearing.
What procedures are required to meet DP to do harm to a person’s reputation.
None - this alone is not a loss of liberty.
What procedures are required to meet DP if a prisoner asserts a loss of liberty claim?
Prisoners almost always lose.
What procedures are required to meet DP to claim punitive damages?
jury instructions to guide discretion, and judicial review to ensure award is reasonable.
Define substantive due process.
protection of (1) economic liberties and (2) safeguarding property
What standard of review is used to evaluate deprivation of economic liberties?
Rational basis
How does the 5th Amendment takings clause work (in basic terms)?
For the government to take private property, it must be for public use, and the govt must provide just compensation.
Define possessory taking.
The government confiscates or physically occupies property (no matter how small the area).
Define regulatory taking.
The government makes a law that leaves the private property owner with no reasonable, economically viable use of the property.
A mere reduction in property’s value is not a taking.
What result if the government makes conditions on development of property?
It is not a taking if the benefit is roughly proportionate to the burden imposed.
Can a person bring a takings claim if the government regulation existed before they acquired the property?
Yes
What result if the government temporarily denies a person the use of their private property?
It is not a taking unless the government’s action is unreasonable.
How do you know when the taking is for public use?
If the government acts out of a reasonable belief that the taking will benefit the public.
Even if a private individual is benefited as a result, as long as the government’s purpose is public, that counts.