Importance of 'X' within the Israeli context Flashcards
What is the importance of Theodor Herzl
- Father of political Zionism (Creation of a Jewish state in Palestine)
o Zionism provided an ideological, political and organisational framework for the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine
o Zionism created a political and national movement for Jewish people, unified the diaspora
o Provided a solution to antisemitism/Jewish persecution and the abnormality of Jewish diaspora - Convened First Zionist Congress in Basel which created the World Zionist Organisation
o Provided a global platform to advance the cause of Jewish statehood
Lobbied/met with politicians and diplomats too
What is the importance of David Ben Gurion
- Head of the Jewish Agency until 1948
o Facilitated mass Jewish immigration to Palestine - During British Mandate and beyond, key focus on building strong Jewish institutions and infrastructure
o Jewish Assembly, Jewish Trade Unions (protect Jewish jobs), Jewish Army, Educational systems
Palestinians Arabs had no state institutions (Jewish advantage regarding political representation, military strength, negotiations)
Jewish institutions ethnically defined, discriminated against Palestinian Arabs - First Israeli Prime Minister (Labor) from 1948-1963
o Pivotal role in drafting Israel’s Declaration of Independence (democracy/equality)
o Led Jews to victory in Independence War 1948 despite being outnumbered by Arab forces
Strong institutions = Israel prepared for war
Victory expanded territory, solidified Israel’s presence as a nascent state in Palestine
What is the importance of Zionism
- Preserved Jewish identity, culture, traditions by creating Jewish state
o Creation of a Jewish state solved problem of Jewish persecution and antisemitism
o Ended need for assimilation into European societies (to be seen as equal)
o Ended the abnormality of diaspora - Different types of Zionism, entered mainstream politics at different periods of Israel’s history
o Labor Zionism
Labor Party
Politically/Socially influential until 1977 (end of Labor’s dominance)
Secular, socialist, institution-building, New Jew/Pioneer
o Revisionist Zionism
Likud Party
Politically/Socially influential from pre-1948, from 1977
Territorial expansionism (greater Israel), hawkish security
o Religious Zionism
Religious Zionist Party, Jewish Power Party
Politically influential post-1967
Religious nationalism, messianic, ensure Israel’s sovereignty through settlement expansions, security concerned
o Reflects right-wing shifts in Israeli society - Zionism responsible for numerous social divides in Israel
o Ashkenazi-dominated Zionism othered Mizrahim
second-class citizens, systematic marginalisation, erosion of M history/identity by A
o Religious / Secular divide
Tension between types of Zionism about the role religion should play in a democratic state
o Zionist / Palestinian Arab divide
Jewish state, despite being a democracy, cannot treat non-Jewish citizens equally
What is the importance of Post-Zionism
- Ideology that challenges the dominant history/narrative/identity of Israel, as well as Jewish exceptionalism
o Israel as a democratic state / Zionism for ALL Jews
Zionism othered and oppressed Mizrahim and Palestinian Arabs
Arabs, non-Jews, non-Ashkenazim cannot be treated equally in a Jewish-majority, Zionist state
o 1948 Independence War
Arab armies less of an existential threat than emphasised
Israel’s army military superior – had more numbers - Victory wasn’t “against all odds”
IDF/Jewish terrorist organisations systematically depopulated, destroyed, and stole Palestinian villages/land - Direct orders or fear of violence
- Palestinians did not leave “voluntarily”
- Related to New Mizrahim
o Challenge Ashkenazim political/cultural/social/economic dominance
o Reclaim Mizrahim identity/culture/history/heritage
Historically been denied and erased by Ashkenazim
seen as threat to European character of Israel
o Form Mizrahim collective memory and consciousness and vision of Israeli state - Informative ideologies in finding solutions to Israel’s war on Palestine
o Mizrahim parallels between marginalisation/plight of Palestinians
o Mizrahim connection to Arab culture
Potential bridge between Israelis and Palestinian Arabs
What is the importance of the Balfour Declaration (1917)
- British Government declared Palestine a national home for Jews
o First major formal recognition of Zionist movement (By British)
o gave international legitimacy to increased Jewish immigration/settlement/statehood
o laid foundation for State of Israel - Endorsement by biggest colonial power beneficial for Jewish state building efforts
o Aided immigration to Palestine, aided purchase of lands and arms, formally recognised state institutions, engaged with elected officials
o Put Jewish population at significant advantage over Palestinian Arabs - Deepened tensions with Arab populations
o British betrayal of Arabs (McMahon-Hussein agreement – promised Arab independence in exchange for revolt against Turks/Ottomans)
What is the importance of the Proclamation of Independence (1948)
- Establishment of the first Jewish State (Israel)
o Realisation of Zionist Vision
Internationally recognised as a valid and legitimate cause
o Ended 2,000 years of Jewish diaspora and exile (unification)
o Safety from persecution and antisemitism (Holocaust) - Established Israel as a democracy
o Framework for democratic institutions e.g., Knesset, Elections - Independence War 1948 as a response to POI
o Invasion of Israel by neighbouring Arab states
o Israel triumphs in the war, solidifies its place as a nascent state in the Middle East
o Expanded territory of original UN Partition Plan (won in self-defence)
What is the importance of the Law of Return (1950)
- Jews have the right to return to the land, settle on the land, and acquire Israeli citizenship
o Defined Israel’s identity/character as a Jewish state
o Biblically significant (return to sacred sights) - Ensured to safety of Jews across globe
o Shelter from persecution / antisemitism (Holocaust) - Key driver of Aliyah (Jewish immigration to Israel)
o Population growth important
Economically (bigger workforce) - Brain Gain (skilled workers to Israel)
Building of state institutions
Counter to Palestinian/Arab populations - Relations with Palestinians
o Return is key for both Palestinian and Israeli/Jewish nationalism
Return to Zion/Holy Land
Return to home/land pre-1948 Nakba
o Israeli denies Palestinian Right of Return
Physically: stealing/destructing land/homes of Palestinians (cannot return)
Diplomatically/Legally
What is the importance of the Status Quo (1947)
- Preserve the Jewish character of public sphere in Israel through rules/laws
o Shabbat (day of rest), Kashrut (Kosher laws in official places), Educational autonomy (no secular subjects), Rabbinical courts have monopoly on family law, exemption from military service
o Status Quo important to get religious Jews to support Zionist movement - Status Quo has become a contested topic in Israeli society
o Family law
Men have more control than women over divorce process - Men can have children without divorce (man’s children are not stigmatised)
- Men need less grounds for divorce
- Men can refuse divorce from wives
Issue for intermarriage between religions
Issue for secular/civic marriage
FULL EQUALITY for women made impossible
o Military Service
Fear that military service will result in ultra-orthodox sons adopting modern ideas and abandoning their faith
Military service is a rite of passage in Israeli life (mandatory 3 years)
o Education
Don’t study secular subjects (Maths, English, Science, History)
Terrible for Israeli economy as they’re largely unemployable - Live in poverty as a result (drain to society)
- Tension between democratic character and religious character
o Disproportionate power to ultra-orthodox
o Promote gender inequality
o Religious imposition on secular populations (shabbat, marriage laws)
o No Religious pluralism
o Discrimination against non-Jewish populations
What is the importance of Ashkenazi Jews
- Historical/Foundation role in Israel’s establishment
o Theodor Herzl – Father of Zionism, Lobbied for Jewish state
o David Ben Gurion – Shaped Yishuv community
Labor Zionism – New Jew / Pioneer, Kibbutzim
Head of Jewish Agency until 1948 – Immigration to Palestine
State building efforts – Jewish Assembly, Histadrut (Unions), Haganah (Army), Education system - Social, Economic, Political, cultural dominance in Israel
o Institutions inherited by Israel = ethnically defined as created by Ashkenazim
Mizrahim and Palestinian Israelis othered = second/third-class citizens to Ashkenazim - Gap in educational facilities, recourses, access
- Disproportionately lower-income families
- Cultural division of labour
o Erasure of other identities in pursuit of Israel as a Western, European democracy, distinct from the rest of Middle East
Revival movements of Mizrahi/Palestinian – post-Zionism, New Mizrahim, New Historians
What is the importance of Mizrahi Jews
- Jews from Middle East and North Africa
o Immigrated to Israel in 1960s/70s
o Bolster Jewish populations against Palestinian Arab populations - Second-class citizens to Ashkenazim (European Jews)
o Mizrahim were genetically inferior, primitive (uneducated/unskilled), mentally deranged, aggressive, criminals… - Economic/Social/Political Marginalisation by Ashkenazim
o Fulfilled need for cheap labour as Arab populations couldn’t be employed
o Lived in squalid tent cities upon immigrating to Israel, lived in city peripheries
o Mizrahim children kidnapped for childless Holocaust survivors
o Forced secularisation, adoption of Zionism, erasure of Mizrahim history/identity/culture - Political Influence
o Rebellion and Opposition
Wadi Salib uprising 1959 (response to police brutality against Miz)
Tent Movement 1976 (awareness about Jerusalem housing crisis)
New Mizrahim/ New Historians (critique
o Facilitated the rise of Likud in 1977
Ended Labor’s dominance in Israeli politics
Economic/Political/Social marginalisation of Mizrahim under Labor
o Shas Party
Party of Religious Mizrahim
Kingmaker role in coalition governments -> Mizrahim veto power - Ideological Influence / Alternative to Labor Zionism
o New Mizrahim/Historians (post-Zionism) – re-examines Israel/Zionism’s history/identity/narratives (pro-Ashkenazim, Eurocentric, ethnocentric)
o Religious Zionism of Religious Mizrahim – protect the Jewish tradition, culture, and character of Israel in the face of secularisation
What is the importance of Labor Party
- Party of Labor Zionism (Zionism, secular, socialist)
o New, pioneer Jew (strength, self-sufficient, connected to Land)
o Kibbutzim – collective farming (Jews hadn’t been allowed to own land in Christian Europe)
Co-opted by religious Zionists regarding settlement movement post-1967 - Labor leadership pre-statehood
o Prioritised building of state-institutions
o Jewish Assembly, Hisradut (Jewish Trade Unions), Jewish army, Educational systems
o Instrumental in giving Israel advantage in Independence war 1948 - Dominant party pre-Israel until 1977
o Guided Israel’s development from a nascent to powerful state
Critical challenges overcome: 1948 and 1967 war
o Continued building institutions and infrastructure
o The party that has spearheaded peace negotiations with Palestinians
In particular, RABIN at Oslo - 1977, Labor decline / Likud rise
o Labor discrimination of Mizrahim – voted for Likud
o Labor-led defeat of Yum Kippur war 1973 – time for political change
o How to deal with occupied territories post-1967 (settlements)
What is the importance of Likud Party
- Founded by Menachem Begin (former Irgun member, revisionist ideology)
o Revisionist Zionism ideology of Likud
Greater Israel, pro-settlement expansion, hawkish stance on security and military, oppose a Palestinian state and Israeli withdrawal for occupied territories, pro-annexation - Rise of Likud marked end of Labor’s dominance (since 1977)
o Reflected a right-wing shift in Israeli society
Labor failure in Yom Kippur war = Likud hawkish appeal
Rise of Mizrahi vote -> discriminated under Labor, voted Likud - Primarily responsible for rapid expansion of settlements post-1967
o Support of Gush Emunim (extra-parliamentary movement aimed at securing Israeli sovereignty over “Judea and Samaria” through Jewish settlements)
o Funding for infrastructure, legal recognition and authorisation of land, Religious Zionists appointed to government
o Led to normalisation of settlements
o Occupant government mentality under Likud - Likud exposes how deeply divided Israeli society is…
o Judicial reform
Protests: Likud undermining independence of courts and democracy
Public fear illiberal theocracy in Israel
o Role in Israel’s war on Gaza
Likud/Religious Zionists prioritising land expansion and absolute destruction of Hamas over the return of Israeli hostages and ceasefire/peace
o Settlement expansions
Settlements inhibit peace with Palestinians/Arabs, and the realisation of two-state-solution
Settler do not represent mainstream Israeli values (isolated group)
o Netanyahu’s ICC arrest warrants and corruption trial
Likud/Netanyahu ratings declining
What is the importance of Shas Party
- Party of Religious/Haredi Mizrahim (Jews from Middle East and North Africa)
o Religious focus excluded secular Mizrahim
o Limits appeal to broader Mizrahim base - Prominent role in addressing the social, political, and economic marginalisation of Mizrahim by Ashkenazi Jews
o 1999 – 17 Seats in the Knesset
Expanding political representation of religious Mizrahim
Transition from Mizrahim success at local level politics to national level
o Play a Kingmaker role in Labor/Likud Governments
Influential: Veto power safeguards interest of religious Mizrahim
o Welfare advocacy for low-income Mizrahim
Economic support: child allowances, support for large families, housing subsidies, creating religiously-oriented jobs
Education: independent educational system, religious schools, daycare subsidies
Social services: rehabilitating delinquents and drug addicts - Prominent role in maintaining the religious character of the Israeli state and public life
o Protecting religious status quo
o Support of Chief Rabbinate (authority over Kosher laws, Family law)
What is the importance of Israel Defense Forces (IDF)
- Historical role in defending Israel against external (Arab) threats
o 1948 Independence War
o 1967 Six-Day War
o 1973 Yom Kippur War
o First and Second Intifadas (1987-1993/2000-2005)
o 2023 Israel’s war on Gaza
1948/1967 Expanding land of Israel
1948 Expulsion, dispossession, and displacement of Palestinian Arabs - Part of Israel’s National Identity
o Mandatory military service, rite of passage as an Israeli
Fosters a sense of duty, patriotism, collective identity
melting pot – diversity of Israel - Ultra-orthodox (Haredi) exemption from military service
o Huge tension in Israeli society between secular/religious Jews
o 13,000 people avoid military service
Social tension exacerbated due to ongoing war on Gaza…
What is the importance of the Knesset
- Coalition governments have become the norm
o Small/medium parties become Kingmakers
o Veto power gives disproportionate representation to their interests
o E.g., United Torah Judaism / Religious Zionists in Netanyahu’s government - Overrepresentation
o Ultra-orthodox /Haredi Jews
o Settler communities
o Ashkenazi elites
o Men - Limited accountability of MKs through public voting
o Voters choose parties, not individuals
o Members are appointed to the Knesset by their party
Voters cannot recall their vote to prevent an MK getting re-elected - Weak legislature oversight
o As members are appointed by their party, not directly elected, Knesset becomes an extension of government Cabinet
Not an effective check on government power
o Supreme Court = only effective check on the government
Netanyahu’s reform of Supreme Court – democracy / judicial independence under attack
What is the importance of the Basic Laws of Israel
- Israel’s constitution 1
o dealt with the structure of government
o powers/role of the Knesset
o powers/role of the executive
o powers/role of the judiciary
o role of the President; the Prime Minister
o civil rights
o democratic state
o Jewish state - Israel’s constitution 2
o Not entrenched -> changed by a simple parliamentary majority
o Do have higher status than normal legislation
Judicial Review: Supreme Court strikes down conflicting legislation - 1990s Constitutional revolution
o Basic Law: Human Dignity and Freedom
o Basic Law: Freedom of Occupation
First time Knesset limited its power
Power of Judicial Review introduced
Increased judicial activism of courts
o Strengthened Israel’s democratic character
What is the importance of Mizrahi Feminism
- Inspired by post-colonial/radical feminism, response to Israeli racism
o Mainstream Israeli feminism (Mainly Ashkenazi, middle-class women) othered Mizrahim women and Palestinian women - Emphasise how intersection of ethnic/national, gender, and class identity creates distinct experiences of oppression (double marginalisation)
o Jew of Middle Eastern, North African descent AND woman
o Oppressed by Ashkenazi men and women, and Mizrahi men
o Awareness about types of intersectional oppression
Economically: disproportionately in low-income jobs, limited access to high-paying jobs, wage gaps
Politically: underrepresented in local/national government, Tokenism in mainstream feminist circles
Educationally: unequal access to education, underrepresented in academia/research
Culturally: Mizrahim identity/culture/history/heritage erased by Ashkenazi Jews - Role of grassroots organisations improving Mizrahi women’s lives
o HILA, founded by Tikva Levi
o Improving Mizrahim access to education (better life chances)
o 1994 – first Mizrahi feminist conference
Now has equal representation of Palestinian, lesbian, Mizrahi, and Ashkenazi
What is the importance of Golda Meir
- Helped to found/establish Israel
o Worked alongside David-Ben Gurion
o Key Labor Zionist
Raised millions of dollars (from America) to help establish Israel
o Signed Declaration of Independence 1948 - Israel’s first female Prime Minster (1969-1974), Labor Party
o First in the Middle East
o Hugely significant development for Ashkenazi women
Underscored power disparities for Mizrahi/non-Jewish women
Female Mizrahi Prime Minister inconceivable - Hostile and Xenophobic to Palestinians
o Palestinian people / state never existed - Leadership marked by Yom Kippur War 1973
o Surprise attack on Israel by Egypt and Syria, response to territory lost in 1967
o Yum Kippur = religious holiday
o Handling of war resulted in loss of public trust
Final straw for Labor Party, led to Likud election in 1977
What is the importance of Hatikva
- National anthem of Israel
o symbol of Jewish collective identity
o symbolises the success of Zionism
was first a song related to the Zionist movement, now it is Israel’s national anthem
success of Zionism in establishing a Jewish state - Lyrics
o Expresses core of Zionist ideology
Self-determination and freedom
Longing to return to the Jewish homeland - Modelled from Poland’s national anthem
o Reflects the influence of European culture/arts on Jewish culture
o European character of Israel due to diaspora of Jews
What is the importance of Yesh Atid Party
- Centrist political party representing secular, urban, middle-class Israelis
- Influential in politics
o Second-largest Party in Knesset e.g., 2022 won 24 seats
Main opposition to Netanyahu’s governmnent
o Formed a coalition government in 2021-2022
Included right, left, Arabs - Greater separation between religion and state
o Serve as a counter to religious right influence
o Addressing the secular-religious divide in Israeli society
End Ultra-orthodox monopoly on Personal Status Laws
End Ultra-orthodox military exemption
Equalise education (secular subjects to be taught to Ultra-orthodox)
Public transport on Shabbat - Strengthening democracy
o Opposes Netanyahu’s judicial reforms
o Expand LGBTQIA+ rights (marriage, adoption, surrogacy, gender affirming treatments)
o Protect rights of Arab minority in Israel
o Religious pluralism and equality of all Jewish denominations
What is the importance of United Torah Judaism Party
- Coalition of Agudat Yisrael and Degel Torah
o Maximise representation of Ashkenazi Haredim (ultra-orthodox Jews)
Popular with Haredi in West Bank settlements - Core Values - Guided by Rabbinic leadership
o Preserve Jewish religious life and Torah values / resist secularisation / oppose separation of religion and state
Ensure Military Exemption
Maintain Rabbinate’s monopoly on Personal Status Laws
Observance of Shabbat
Enforcement of Kashrut (Kosher Laws)
Uphold Haredi schools and Torah study
o Socially traditional, anti-modernisation (anti-LGBTQIA+, no women in politics, cultural modesty)
o Welfare payments to support large Haredi families - Policies of UTJ escalate the religious-secular divide in Israeli society
o Shabbat = religious values imposed on secular public life
o Haredim schools = no secular subjects -> unemployable -> economic burden for taxpayers / state
o Disproportionate welfare for Haredim = do not contribute to economy through employment/taxes (low-income, low workforce, impoverished)
o Haredim military exemptions = unfair treatment – esp. after October 7th - Key Coalition Partner in Netanyahu’s government
o Kingmaker role -> Haredim politically overrepresented as a result
What is the importance of Electoral Threshold in Israel
- 2014 Reform: Electoral threshold is set at 3.25%
o Feature of Proportional Representation Electoral system
o Intended to strengthen stable government outcomes by reducing the number of small parties that can enter the Knesset
o Intended to encourage smaller parties to merge based on ideology - Results…
- Underrepresentation of certain minorities in Knesset
o Non-Jewish, Palestinian Arab
o Joint Arab List 2015 – ensures representation BUT dilutes specific needs - Radicalisation of politics
o Small parties have come to decide the fate of elections and of national politics
o Result = catering to needs of radical parties to ensure survival of coalition
Overrepresentation of certain minorities
Religious far-right
E.g., Netanyahu’s coalition - United Torah Judaism
- Government moved further towards far-right religious spectrum
o Result = Hardening partisanship and entrenching polarisation
What is the importance of Benjamin Netanjahu
- Longest serving Prime Minister
- Eroding Israeli democracy
o Corruption charges (bribery, fraud)
o ICC arrest warrant: War Crimes and Crimes Against Humanity
o Judicial Reforms
Gov control of SC appointments, ability to override SC, limit SC review power
Weaken the strongest check on gov power
o Basic Law Jewish Nation-State Law
undermined rights / equality of Arab Israelis
accusations of apartheid
o Polarising influence on Israeli society
War strategy incited anti-war protests to bring hostages home, ceasefire deal
Judicial reforms sparked protests about erosion of democracy
Jewish Nation-State law worsening Jewish-Arab divide in Israel
Platforming of religious nationalists (Smotrich, Ben Gvir) worsening secular-religious divides
o Opposition to peace between Israelis and Palestinians
Overseeing the expansion of settlement activity in West Bank
Slowed down peace process despite time Oslo’s time pressures
What is the importance of Kibbutz
- Stronghold of Labor Party/ the Left
- Collective agricultural communities
o SIGNIFICANT: Jews had not been permitted land ownership in Christian Europe - Associated with Labor Zionism (socialism, secular)
Associated with New Jew (revitalisation of Jewish identity and self-image) - Strong, self-sufficient pioneers of Israel
- Land owning
Opposite to Diaspora Jew - Exile, disempowered, victimised, traditional
David Ben Gurion - “make the desert bloom” - Ignorant assumption that Palestine was primitive
- Jews were bringing civilisation
- Pioneer spirit co-opted by settlement movement/religious Zionists/religious nationalists
o E.g., Gush Emunim
o Extra-parliamentary movement aimed at securing Israeli sovereignty over the West Bank (Judea and Samaria) through Jewish settlements