II. The Lawyer-Client Relationship - general points Flashcards
what defines the relationship b/t lawyer and client
a contract
what roles does a lawyer play in his relationship to the client?
agent and fiduciary
does a lawyer have to take every case that is presented to him?
no
what are the 3 instances when a lawyer-client relattionships arises?
- a person manifests an intent that the lawyer provide legal services and the lawyer agrees
- a person manifests an intent to have the L represent him, the L fails to make clear that he does not want to undertake the representation, and the lawyer knows or should know that the prospective client is reasonably relying on the lawyer to provide the services OR
- a tribunal appoints an L to represent a client
whether a client has reasonably relied on a lawyer to provide services is a question of (law or fact?)
fact
Examples:
- unreasonable for client to expect a L’s representation by mailing a letter and getting no response
- Secretary asking for all papers and failing to tell C that L would decide whether or not to represent only after reviewing papers would be reasonable reliance
what are the 3 instances where a L would have good cause to avoid a case for an indigent client or a client w/ an unpopular cause?
- violation of law or disciplinary rule (ex. L represented Q as PD then later in private practice, court assigned him to represent D, who killed Q. –> not OK b/c of confidential info L learned while representing Q)
- unreasonable financial burden would be imposed on L
- personal inability to represent client effectively (L finds the cause so repugnant that it would effect L/C relationship)
when must a lawyer reject certain cases?
- client’s motive is harassment (misconduct to represent when purpose is to embarrass, delay, or burden a 3P)
- unsupportable factual or legal position (can’t be frivolous, is not frivolous when L can make good faith arg; criminal defense may defend to the extend it’s constitutional even if it violates this rule)
- lawyer not competent (too busy or no experience)
- strong personal feelings
- impaired mental or physical condition
when C consults L but not C/L relationship arises, what duties does the L have to C? (i.e. duties owed to a prospective C)
- protect prospective C’s confidential info
- protect prospective C’s property that has been given to L
- use reasonable care when giving prospective C legal advice
do lawyer’s have an ethical obligation to accept unpopular cases?
yes and can fulfill by accepting a fair share of unpopular matters
who gets the benefit of the doubt if attorney’s fees are in dispute?
the client
what is the rule regarding attorney’s fees when the lawyer has not regularly represented the client?
the fees must be:
- communicated to the client (preferably in writing)
- before or within a reasonable time after commencing the representation
Model rule 1.5(b)
when will a court not enforce a contract for attorney’s fees?
- when the fees are unreasonably high OR
2. there is an unreasonably high amount for expenses
what are the factors that are evaluated when establishing whether attorney’s fees are reasonable?
- time and labor required
- novelty and difficulty involved
- skill needed to perform properly
- the likelihood, if apparent to the C, that the work for this client will preclude the L from doing fee-paying work for others
- fee customarily charged
- amount at stake and the results obtained
- time limitations
- nature and length of the relationship
- experience, reputation, and ability of L
- whether the fee is fixed or contingent (contingent usually high b/c L has to gamble)
can a L charge a client for ordinary overhead expenses like rent?
no
can the lawyer charge the client for the actual cost to the attorney for special services like photocopying, long distance phone calls, computer research, special deliveries etc
yes
can a L double bill for their time
no
can a lawyer request to be paid in advance?
yes, but L must refund the client if L is fired or withdraws
how is a true retainer fee different from a pay in advance?
true retainer = money paid only to ensure availability of L; is generally not refunded
pay in advance = is refunded if L withdraws or is fired
can L accept property for payment?
yes so long as the property does not involve a proprietary interest in the cause of action or subject of litigation (watch for COI; cannot be a business transaction b/t L and C)
can a lawyer make a fee agreement that could curtail services in the middle of the relationship and put the client at a bargaining disadvantage?
no