Identifications through Trial Flashcards
3 types of pre-trial IDs?
- line-ups
- show-ups: one-on-one confrontation with W and suspect
- photo arrays
2 substantive challenges to pre-trial ID
- denial of right to counsel under 6th Am = right to counsel at line-ups and show-ups AFTER formal charging, also IN NEW YORK before formal charges filed if you request it
- due process violated when ID process is so UNNECESSARILY SUGGESTIVE to create irreparable likelihood of mis-ID
remedy for successful substantive pre-trial ID challenge? when remedy overruled?
remedy = exclusion of W’s in-court ID. Overruled and allowed anyway if P can show it’s based on W’s observation of D besides unconstitutional lineup, showup, or photo array –> P shows 1. W’s opportunity to show D at crime scene;
- W’s certainty
- W’s specificity of description
What do grand juries do?
issue indictments
Are grand jury proceedings public?
No
Do states have to use them as part of the charnging process? Does NY?
Not mandatory, and most states skip it. NY uses grand juries.
Before the grand jury in NY, indictments must establish _______ and provide reasonable cause to believe the accused ________ the offense
all elements; committed
justify pre-trial detention if you’ve got probable cause, which can be determined in 1 of 2 ways
- grand jury issues indictment
2. magistrate issues arrest warrant
first appearance: what happens?
magistrate advises him of rights, set bail, appoint counsel (if nec).
Brady rule def
P must disclose to criminal D ALL MATERIAL, EXCULPATORY evidence - i.e., prejudice would result w/o disclosure
Ds are entitled to unbiased judge, which reqs 2 things:
- no $ stake in outcome
2. no actual malice toward D
all criminal Ds get ___ and ___ juries
fair and impartial
right to jury trial kicks in when max. sentence exceeds ___?
6 months
min number of jurors for crim trial by const? what about in NY?
6 by fed const. 12 reqd in NY (though D can waive and go down to 11).
crim jury verdicts require what % agreement?
unanimity
pool of jury draw = _____-sectional
cross-sectional ==> representative pool
peremptory challenges can exclude for any reasons except?
race and gender
face-to-face confrontation with W guaranteed under 6th Am, except?
public policy -> child abuse victims
right to effective assistance of counsel - 2 prong test (must have both for D to win appeal)
- deficiency req: lawyer made errors so serious as to not function as counsel; AND
- prejudice req: but for attorney’s deficiency, outcome of trial would’ve been different