ICTP Flashcards
Trigger mechanisms
-state party referral
-UNSC referral
-Prosecutor initiates proprio motu
Standard for preliminary investigations
reasonable basis to proceed
Phase 1 (prelim investigation)
only necessary for proprio motu investigations; initial assessment as to whether to proceed
Phase 2 (prelim investigations)
formal commencement stage of preliminary investigations, analyze whether preconditions for jurisdiction exist
Phase 3 (prelim investigations)
preliminary investigations stage analyzing admissibility (i.e complementarity and gravity)
Phase 4 (prelim investigations)
Preliminary investigations stage analyzing interests of justice
Preconditions for jurisdiction
Subject-matter (core crimes); territorial (state party); personal (whoever committed an int crime); temporal (after ratification)
Complementarity
ICC admissibility criteria: foregoing international prosecution in favor of a domestic prosecution. “Positive” version of this (encouraging domestic prosecution) currently OTP strategy at ICC
Same conduct test
test for complementarity: domestic prosecutions must cover “same individual and substantially the ____”
Kenya situation
case which established the principle at ICC that complementarity is not satisfied by a state simply giving assurances that they will prosecute
Primacy
Ad hocs: int. tribunal takes priority over domestic courts
Standard for complementarity
ICC can take a case even if a domestic court is prosecuting it if state is “unwilling or unable” to prosecute
Factors for assessing gravity
-Scale of crimes
-nature of crimes
-manner of commission
-impact
Case selection criteria
-strategic (one case is more important than the other considering resources)
-operational (one case has better evidence)
Art. 99(4) RS
ICC article outlining exceptions for need for state cooperation in on site evidence gathering
Art. 57(3)(d) RS
ICC article for failed state scenario (PTC authorizes on site evidence gathering w/o state consent)
Judicial investigative powers under IRMCT
Issuance of orders, warrants, summonses, subpoenas necessary for investigations, or required for preparation or conduct of the trial at request of the prosecutor in the context of indictment review (art. 17(2), IRMCT St.); at request of either party or proprio motu (R55, IRMCT RPE)
Judicial investigative powers at ICC
-TC: may require attendance/testimony/docs/other evidence through state assistance, order production of additional evidence (either party), provide for protection of accused/witnesses/victims
-PTC: arts. 56 and 57, Functions to facilitate investigations, no evidentiary power; Exception for unique investigative opportunity
IRMCT Standard for arrest warrants
Prima facie standard
Exceptional circumstances standard
At ad hocs, old rule that provisional detention was the norm