ICH E2A Safety Monitoring Flashcards
Adverse Event, or Adverse Experience (AE)
Any untoward (unfavorable and unintended) laboratory or clinical abnormality associated with, not necessarily caused by, the intervention.
Adverse Drug Reaction (ADR)
Any noxious and unintended response to a pre-approval stage drug given at any doses, or to a post-marketing drug given at normal doses in human.
Side Effect
SE can be both favorable and unfavorable, and thus is no longer recommended in practice due to ambiguity.
Unexpected ADR determined by Source Documents
Any adverse reaction not included in the product information from the source documents (i.e., Investigator’s Brochure of an investigational drug, or the Safety Labeling of a post-marketing drug).
Serious AE/ADR (5+1)
Any untoward medical occurrence that at any does:
- results in death,
- is life-threatening.
- requires inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization
- results in persistent or signifaicant disability/incapacity, or
- is a congenital anomaly/birth defect.
- Other medical events that require intervention to prevent one of the other outcomes above.
Life-threatening Event Definition
An event in which the patient was at risk of death at the time of the event, but not in which the patient might have died hypothetically if it were more severe.
Medical Events that Require Intervention to Prevent a Serieous Events, Examples (3)
- Intensive teratment for allergic bronchospasm at ER/home
- Blood dyscrasias or convulsions that do not result in hospitalization
- Development of drug dependency or drug abuse
Severity vs Seriousness
Severity (leading event)
Seriousness (resulting outcome)
“Mild myocardial infarction (severity) did not affect survival or cardiac function (seriousness).”
Regulatory reporting obligations are defined by serious outcome, but not on severe event.
Expedited Reporting Obligations for Unexpected AE
Once an unexpected AE occurs, expedited reporting is required for additional occurrences of the AE, until source documents are amended (from unexpected to expected).
Unexpected AEs Criteria (2)
Either:
1. Not documented in Investigators’s Brochure or product Safety Label, or
2. Documented but lacks specificity or severity.
Example:
Acute renal failure / interstitial nephritis
Hepatitis / fulminant hepatitis
Expedited Reporting Requirements (2)
Both:
1. Serious, and
2. Unexpected
Ordinarily Inappropriate Circumstances for Expedited Reporting (4)
- Serious but not unexpected
- Expected but not serious
- Not serious, and not expected
- Serious AE but not related to the study
Expedited Report Source Information Examples (3)
Any one of the following:
- Spontaneous reports (for marketed drugs)
- Clinical/epidemiological investigations
- Others (registries or publications)
Valid ADR Causality Assessment
Reasonable suspected causal relationship judged by either:
- Reporting health care professional
- Sponsor
For marketed drugs, Spontaneous Reports on ADR also imply causality.
Description for Causality Examples (1+3)
Other than “cause”, the following also qualify:
- “Plausible relationship”
- “Suspected causality”
- “Causal relationship cannot be ruled out”
Degree of Causality (5)
Certainly, definitely, probably, possibly or likely related, or not related
Non-single-case for Expedited Reporting Scenarios (3)
Population based situations:
- Serious ADR, but unexpected for its rate of occurrence, which reaches over a significant clinical threshold.
- Lack of efficacy in treating life-threatening disease, posing a significant hazard to patient population.
- Major safety finding from newly completed animal studies, which translates to human.
Reporting Time Frames for Fatal or Life-threatening Unexpected ADRs
Very rapid reporting to regulatory agencies:
Initial report: ASAP but within no later than 7 calendar days, after case qualification acknowledgement by sponsor.
Complete report: within no later than 15 calendar days, after case qualification acknowledgement by sponsor (8 additional days).