ICA Case Law

Question 0

Carlil vs carbolic smoke ball ltd

Answer 0

Carlil purchased the product of carbolic Ltd and used as per instructions

She claimed for compensation and won

Question 1

Lalman shucklaw vs Gowry Dutt

Answer 1

Offer must be communicated

Master lost his daughter and sent his servant to find

Meanwhile he gave add in newspapers 10000 for who found his daughter

Servant claimed but master refused

Master won the case

Question 2

Ramsgate Victoria vs Montifoire

Answer 2

Allotment of shares after 6 months from the date of application is not a valid acceptance because acceptance is not communicated with in reasonable time. …

Here reasonable time is 3-4 months

Question 3

Chinnaya vs Rammaya

Answer 3

Old lady transfers her property to her daughter and made a contract to pay her brother 10000 per month

But after few years daughter refused to pay stating that she receives no consideration

But consideration can be made by stranger to the contract

Question 4

Khwaja Mohd vs Huseini Begum

Answer 4

Exemptions to doctrine of privity of contract

a. Beneficiary of trust
B family settlement and marriage expenses
C.assignment to contract (BOE)
D. Acknowledgement of debts

Question 5

Mohiri Bibi vs Dharmadas Ghose

Answer 5

Agreement with minor is void ab initio

Question 6

Ram Swaroop vs Bansi Mandar

Answer 6

Unlawful consideration

Gave loan to servant

Should return loan with interest and no salary will be paid until loan is repaid

Conclusion
Working without salary amounts to slavery and it involves injury to the person