IBT Final Flashcards
Choice of Law
Can determine outcomes and likelihood of winning.
Contract: A choice of law provision is often included in a contract and respected by nations. Otherwise rules tend to determine the nation most closely connected to the transaction or at least having a significant relationship to the transaction. International sales of goods rules have been partly harmonized by CISG.
Tort: Often there are no contracts in these cases and so no choice of law provision. Law of the place where the injury occurred usually seen as proper choice. Where injury occurs in one country but can be attributable to actions in another country (ex. defective toys made in China and sold in US) the decision is important because damages under US law are likely to be much higher.
Choice of Forum
This is a choice of where a case would be tried regardless of what law applies. Typically choice of law and choice of forum are the same, but there can be a case where they differ. For instance, a New york court can be the forum, but could decide that German Law applies.
Personal Jurisdiction
Court’s jurisdiction over the parties to a lawsuit. If a court does not have personal jurisdiction over a party, its rulings cannot be enforced upon that party (except by comity)
Subject Matter Jurisdiction
Whether the facts of the case can be judged by that particular court (territoriality, nationality, international law)
Permanent Establishment
Referred to in the OECD Tax Treaty. Determines whether a person/entity should be taxed and where.
Force Majuere
Clause in contracts that frees parties from liability when an extraordinary event beyond the control of the parties (war, strike, riot, crime, natural disaster) prevents one or both parties from fulfilling their obligations under the contract. In most cases, does not usually excuse total non-performances, but suspends it for duration.
Letter of credit
A promise by the buyer’s bank that it will pay amount in contract to seller if seller produces documents required by contract to produce evidence of shipment/delivery of goods
Parallel imports
Synonymous with grey market goods
Grey market goods
Goods lawfully abiding by IP which originate abroad and compete without permission in domestic markets.
Piracy
Illegal sale, distribution and/or trading of IP protected goods
Concession
Right to exploit a resource in a particular geographic space for a particular period of time, in exchange for a royalty.
Think about what the government wants, and the risk it is taking on. To mitigate risk, gov might want a minimum obligation from foreign company.
Expropriation
Act of nationalizing a foreign investment or industry for a public good. Must not be discriminatory and must pay just compensation for it to be legal.
Sovereign immunity
Notion that a state cannot be sued if the issue takes place in that host state. Sovereignty must be respected y other sovereigns and generally means there is no personal jurisdiction.
Project finance
Non-recourse financing for a specific project rather than an entire company
Service of process
The formal delivery of documents that is legally sufficient to charge the defendant with notice of a pending action. Must conform to laws of both countries involved and give adequate notice. Some countries do not allow service by mail.
Forum non conveniens
A court’s discretionary power to decline to exercise its jurisdiction where another court may more conveniently hear a case. Considers residence of parties, location of evidence and witnesses, public policy, relative burden of court systems, plaintiff’s choice of forum, effect of changing forum.
Comity
Willingness of s foreign court to comply with another court
Recognition
Issue(s) decided do not need to be relitigated, gives domestic effect to judgement
Enforcement
Courts grant party some of all of judgement decreed by foreign court
Branch
No independent juridical status, parent has absolute control and administrative convenience, subjects the parent to all of the branch’s obligations
Subsidiary
Distinct legal personalities separate from parent
Business purpose test
Initially interpreted as allowing payments as long as payments were not directly related to a current or future business deal; eventually narrowed to prohibit payments to create a favorable business environment (eg reduced taxes). Determines the intended impact of the payment on business deals.
Implicit warranties
UCC 2-314(a): a contract implies merchantability
UCC 2-315(a): a contract implies merchantability for a particular purpose if the seller is aware of the particular purpose
UCC 2-316: exclusion and modification of implicit warranties through particular language
CISG
Convention on the International Sale of Goods: Germany and US have ratified the treaty, UK has not. Self-executing.
Applies by default if seller is in CISG signatory state. Once applicability is recognized, both parties have to agree to opt out of all or part in contract. If parties don’t agree on alternate choice, CISG applies. Harmonizing reduces ambiguity.
CISG Article 3 (Rome 1)
“Contract shall be governed by the law chosen by the parties”
When no law has been chose, the law of the country where the seller/service provider has his habitual residence
Last shot rule
An acceptance that is not in conformity with the terms of the offer is rejection of the offer and usually treated as counteroffer. Can be expressed explicitly by words of acceptance or implicitly by conduct. If a party fails to reject and performs or partially performs, it is considered accepted.
More present in CISG (UCC is first shot)
Mirror Image Rule
Acceptance with different terms of additional terms is NOT an acceptance by instead a rejection and a counteroffer.
Article 19 of CISG
Knock-out rule
Accepting the agreement of the parties based on the essential terms, different or additional terms are replaced by UCC gap-filling provisions.
CISG Article 19
An offer containing addition, limitation or other modifications is a rejection of the offer and constitutes a counter-offer. If the additional terms do not materially alter the offer, a valid contract is formed and the additional terms enter the contract unless the receiving party promptly objects to their inclusion
Restatement, Conflicts of Law (2nd 1971)
- Where there is specific juridical directive, courts will follow statutory directives of their own state on choice of law
- When no directive, depends on needs of interstate and int’l system, relevant policies of the forum, policies in particular field of law, certainty, predictability and uniformity of result, ease in determination and application of law to be applied
- Paragraph 188 - law governing in absence of effective choice: determined by local law of state which has most significance to transaction and parties, considers place of contract, place of negotiation, place of performance, location of subject matter, domicile, residence, nationality, place of incorporation and business of parties.
Battle of the forms
When two businesses are negotiating the terms of a contract and each party wants to contract on the basis of its own terms
F.O.B.
Free on board, a delivery term.
FOB [destination] means seller must at his own expense and risk transport goods to that place and tender delivery
Incoterms
Express reference supersedes UCC provision. Designed to bridge conflicts that arise across legal systems. Should be explicitly included
Perfect tender rule
UCC - buyer is entitled to reject tender of delivery under a one-delivery contract of sale that fails in any respect to conform to the contract