History and Use of Dental Amalgam Flashcards
Year silver amalgam was introduced:
1819, Charles Bell, 1836 to U.S.
Amalgam was first marketed as:
Bell’s putty
Who brought amalgam to U.S.
Crawcour brothers ‘Royal Mineral Succedaneum’ silver (coins) and mercury expanded, post op pain, fracture, elevated occl contact
Amalgam War started:
1841-1850
First amalgam placers were called:
Quick Silver Quaks
Year amalgam use would be malpractive:
1843 (american society of dental surgeons)
Amalgam Pledge:
1845-no one in dentistry could use, must sign pledge, rescinded in 1850’s, research began
G.V. Black created:
Classical amalgam cavity design, classification system, formula for “conventional amalgam”
Formula for “conventional” amal circa 1896:
72.5% silver and 27.5% tin-mercury
Yrs of 2nd amal war:
1926-1930
Dr. that started 2nd amal war:
Dr. Alfred Stock, opinion based publication, claimed vapor from amalgam fillings can be significantly damaging to health conditions. Renouned his own claim in 1940
Most pop pos tooth restorative material in 2nd half of 1900’s and today
amalgam
Pos outcome of Stocks allegations that led to the 2nd amal war:
Scientists conducted studies that demonstrated safety of amal
Can mercury be released from filings?
no, it is chemically reacted and tied up in the body of the restoration
This man recommended use of 1:1 ratio of mercury to alloy:
Wilmer Ballou Eames (others were using 8:5 ratio)
Yr spherical amalgam alloy was introduced:
1962
High copper amalgam was invented by who, when?
Innes and Yudelis, 1963, copper added to amalgam alloy
Reasons for decline in use of amal:
esthetics, caries decline, conservation of tooth structure, mercury
Who challenged the Scott study with their own research regarding Hg vapor?
Souder and Sweeney (check)
Hoover study:
Urinary industrial mercury level, different bw pt w and wo dental amal in mouth, found no diff in urinary mercury level, amal restos do NOT contribute to body burden
Frykolm:
Hg is excreted w/in a few days: multiple amal restos, radioactively labelled Hg, urinary analysis/time, levels rose and dropped back down to zero after 8 days (small, measurable amt of mercury vapor exposure, but is excreted quickly)
TF? Hg vapor is released from amalgam when pts chew gum.
T, enough heat is created when masticating, then absorbed into blood, debate about actual amt released and whether this poses a risk to the pt., minute
Cardinal rule of toxicology:
only the dose makes a poison
Amal TLV:
Amal Threshold Limit Value, amt of Hg vapor that can safely be in air where a worker works for 40hr/wk
Amal TLV for OSHA and WHO:
OSHA: 50ug/mm3, WHO: 25ug/mm3
How would the highest dose possible a pt could receive from 10-12 amal restorations compare with the TLV levels
1/100th of the “current” (didn’t specify OSHA or WHO)
Amal level in normal diet/ day:
10-20 ug
Highest level suggested by research of Hg exposure to pt from amal restos:
10 ug/day, measures inside mouth and not environment so this number should be much lower
How does the amt of Hg exposure a pt would experience to amal compare to that exposure from their every day diet?
1/10 - 1/20 of dietary levels
For the most sensitive pt to demonstrate the most minor symptoms:
450 to 500 amalgams would have to be places
How does Dental Amal and nickel alloys affect the circulating T-lympho levels/ wbc levels?
it doesn’t
What type of toxin is Hg?
neurotoxin
First time Amal was used in dentistry
1826 o.t.
Why use silver amal?
Strong, inexpensive
Detector of mercury content in air:
Selenium sulfide mercury detector, souder and sweeney testing release from fillings, acid solutions, no vapor, no dissolution of mercury
Amount of mercury in human vs sheep, etc
12-20 times less
Health organizations that support the continued use of amalgam:
FDI World Dental Federation, WHO, Alzheimer’s association, FDA, U.S. Health Service, Lupus Foundation, National MS Society,Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, CDC, National Counsel Against Health Fraud, NIH/ NIDR Consensus Development Conference, USPHS, Consumer Reports, Swedish Medical Counsel
Effect of unecessary amal removal:
Preparation enlarged, chance of pulpal trauma, cost, longevity
How to determine bw composite and tooth structure for composite removal:
air dry, composite appears chaulky