HIST 123 Quiz 2 (modes of healing - yellow fever) Flashcards
(134 cards)
500 CE to c. 1600 CE What were the new and old diseases?
- Syphillis and typhus (linked to warfare)
- Malaria (environment change)
- peak in about 1200
- Leprosy in decline,
What was the Pain, Injuries and Ailments 500 CE to c. 1600
- Nutritional deficiencies
- Respiratory and gastrointestinal sickness
- Cancerous tumours, psychiatric illness, arthritis and rheumatism (which would have caused pain)
-> would not describe it as we do today -> ppl would say they are “suffering” or “in pain” - Childbirth
How did they commonly treat pain from 500 CE to c. 1600 CE?
Through alcohol. -> one of the first and longest standing defences against pain.
- was included in doctor and medicine kits.
What were the modes of healing in late medieval Europe?
Religion
- Saints and their relics
-> cults of saints important in medieval Christianity -> saints thought to interfere between humans and God to help out on behalf of people.
-> saints and relics had healing properties in medieval Christianity -> similar to worship of Asclepius
-> relics -> pilgrims would travel to the shrines to pray and get as close to the relic as possible.
- Confessions seen as having therapeutic value in Medieval world
Magic
- Alchemy and astrology
Empirical Healing
-> Folk medicine
-> Herbal remedies
Physicians and Surgeons
What were “Birthing Girdles”
medieval Christian talismanic item that included names of saints and apostles and assures of safe delivery.
- were loaned by monasteries to parishioners for use during childbirth
- Infused with a sense of magic but within the Christian condition
-> Hierarchy in Church opposed to superstition but local priests would bless crops for harvests and bless women for delivering babies
Magic and Neo-Platonic Beliefs in terms of Modes of Healing (17th c.)
- Growing interest in the hidden powers of nature
- That there was power in the natural world that was a source of ill health or healing
- Macrocosm → universe
- thought that things in the universe could have an impact on the human body
- eg. if Saturn and Jupiter are in the wrong place, this can have an effect on the human body.
- Microcosm → human body
- these two were seen to be related
What was Empirical Healing like (500 Ce to 1300 CE) ?
- Daily practice
- Folk medicine: mixture of religion, magic, philosophy, and tradition
- Might include bleed and purging in line with Galenic theory
- Attention to diet and herbal traditions
- Birthing girdle → found biological materials: honey, milk, broadbeans → thought to be good for childbirth → advised to follow a certain diet
- Practices of surgery and midwifery
- Reflected the local environment → plants and herbs rooted in those local places
- Plants with healing properties that were widely available → eg. marigold → used to make tinctures and ointments and washes to treat burns, bruises and cuts, as well as the minor infections the ycause.
- has been shown to help prevent dermatitis or skin inflammation
- learned these things through trial and error → if they showed good results they would use it again.
- Healing powers of folk medicine were seen as being passed down
- Women were seen as healers and an important part of modes of healing (folk medicine)
When did Formal Medicine appear?
- By late 13th c —> professionalization of medicine
- People who had qualifications from a university → could confer professional expertise
What constituted medical training in 13th c?
- Physicians could have privileges from public authority
- Eg. Town physician, royal physician
- usually also educated in uni
- Membership in a guild or college
- Education dominated by classical texts:
- Galen, Hippocrates, and Medieval Arabic texts by Ibn Sina (Avicenna) and Ibn Sarabiyum (Serapion the Elder) → esteemed physician
- being a physician usually depended on your demand as a healer
What did Canterbury Tales - Geoffrey Chaucer refer to?
referred to great medical physicians
What was the Practice of Medicine like in 13th c? (500 Ce to c 1300 CE)
- Emphasis on humours as causing sickness
- Return to balance by bleeding, purging, diet and medication
- Otherwise, physicians offered remedies that often did not differ much from folk healers
- gentler than physicians → physicians likely to use bleeding, scarification and surgery as treatments
- Physicians uncommon in villages, mostly in cities.
When did the study of anatomy appear?
- From 13th century on → the study of anatomy
- Example of continuity and change
- Not really focused on hygienic practices
- But still did surgery which required expertise in anatomy
- Galen’s works were rich in terms of their anatomical detail.
What was Mondino de Luzzi’s (1270-1326) significance on anatomy?
- Followed Galen’s authority
- used to compose his texts: if Galen said the liver consisted of 5 lobes, so did Mondino de Luzzi
- obedience to authority even if it was wrong
- constraints to dissection → Physician/teacher sat in a chair and read from a book to guide the dissection and someone else (the student) performed the dissection → Luzzi could not notice discrepancies from this.
- Dissection resumed (wasn’t really done until now), but faced practical constraints
- body didn’t last long
- hasty dissection of corpses
- Also: no agreed-upon terminology
- No accurate reproductions of illustrations
What was Islamic Medicine and Anatomy like in 13th c?
- Some references to dissection although practice no more common than in Europe.
- Abd al-Latif al-Baghdadi’s (d. 1231 CE) description of bones in the lower jaw and sacrum
- Used skeletons of ppl who died of famine in Egypt for his study
Why did there need to be changes in Anatomic knowledge (in 13th c) and what were the changes?
- Major barriers:
- Lack of agreed-upon terminology
- different professors would have different names for the smaller organs
- return to classical texts led to more agreed-upon terminology
- Lack of accurate reproductions of illustrations
- emphasis that what you’re drawing is actually what you are saying
- woodcuts, engravings and etching
- Lack of agreed-upon terminology
Who was Andreas Vesalius (1514-1564)?
- Realized the potential woodcuts had for anatomical representation
- Published De humani corporis fabrica [On the fabrin of the human body]
- Become essential to the fabric of realistic human anatomical representations
- But also had Galenic povs
What was the Galenic tradition of medicine?
- Three interconnected systems in the body
- The brain and nerves
- The heart and arteries
- The liver and veins
What was Vesalius’ Contributions to the Galenic tradition of medicine?
- Still firmly in Galenic tradition
- But willing to find Galen’s mistakes
- Innovation: thoroughness, accuracy, precise, anatomical illustrations
- Vivisection - dissecting live animal bodies
- Practice revived in 16th c.
- Had many followers who continued to find and point out Galen’s errors
- Became key to revolution of human body and its understanding
What is Charles’ Rosenberg and Janet Golden’s views on disease (from a historian pov)?
- In some ways, disease does not exist until we agree that it does, by perceiving, naming and responding to it. - Charles Rosenberg and Janet Golden (historians of medicine)
- cultural part of the disease is really what makes it
- being able to identify a causative agent is only one part of the disease
- new disease have significant but not apocolpytic impacts (as opposed to the first and second plague pandemic)
When and how did Syphilis appear?
- Beginning of 1490s a new disease arose in Italy from war
- Armies big part of spread of disease → not disciplined, ill-practiced in hygiene, from all parts of the country, dirty → after war they were scattered back to where they came from
- siege with tropps from Germany, Italy, Spain, and France → many fell sick → when they returned home, they dispersed it into their countries
- Within 5 years of arriving in Europe, the disease was epidemic
- Portugeuse carried it on ships to India in 1498, then China
- European settlers carried POTs everywhere except Africa
What was Jospeh Grunback (1473-1532)’s account of syphilis?
- “Horrible sickness”
- “from the western shores of Gaul” from France
- “a disease which is so cruel, so distressing, so appalling that until now nothing so horrifying, nothing more terrible or disgusting, has ever been known on this earth.”
Where did Syphilis come from?
Columbian
vs.
Multi-regional
Columbian Origin
- Christopher Columbus reach Bahamas, Cuba, Hispaniols in October-December 1492, returned to Spain in March 1493.
- Crew of 44 men, as well as Indigenous people brough from the Americas
What were the characteristics of 16th century Syphilis?
- Initially an acute disease
- Genital ulcers, rash
- Destroyed organs in the mouth, pain in muscles and death
- Bone inflammation and hard pustules
- By mid-16th c. symptoms moderated and lethality (likelihood of imminent death) declined
- Due to pathogen involved changing and becoming less virulent
- and/or people gaining some immunity
What are the characteristics of present-day syphilis?
- Sexually transmitted infection
- Primarily spread through sexual contact
- Can be spread through non-sexual means (contact with blood)
- Or transmitted to infants during pregnancy and childbirth
- Congenital syphilis: miscarriage, stillbirth, severe anemia, blondness, enlarged liver or spleen