(GREEN) Delegated Legislation Flashcards

You may prefer our related Brainscape-certified flashcards:
1
Q

What allows a secondary body to create laws?

A

An Enabling Act or Parent Act. (same thing)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

How many Acts does Parliament pass a year?

A

25-40

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Who makes Orders in Council?

A

The Queen and Privy Council. The Privy Council includes senior government ministers, senior judges, bishops and senior members of the royal family.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

When are Orders in Council used?

A

Can be used in times or emergency or when Parliament is not sitting.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What are Orders in Council used for?

A

To amend or update laws, transfer responsibility between government departments or to make law in times of emergency.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What did the Misuse of Drugs Amendment Order 2008 do and what type of delegated legislation was it?

A

It was an Order in Council and it amended the Misuse of Drugs Act to reclassify cannabis as a class B drug when it was previously a class C.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Who makes by-laws and where do they apply?

A

Local authorities and large public bodies authorised to do so. The legislation only applies to the areas over which that council or public body has control.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Give some examples of issues dealt with by by-laws and an example of an actual by-law.

A

Traffic regulations, parking, dog fouling in parks, public order (like alcohol ban zones).
Smoking ban on the London Underground.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Who makes Statutory Instruments and what can they make Statutory Instruments about?

A

Government departments (civil servants) and ministers. They can only make Statutory Instruments for their area of responsibility.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

How many Statutory instruments are made a year?

A

Around 3000

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What is an example of a Statutory Instrument and the relevant Enabling Act?

A

The Police Codes of Practice which can be made by the Minister of Justice. This is enabled by the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What are the reasons for delegated legislation?

A
  • Time
  • Expertise
  • Local knowledge
  • Easily make and change laws
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Why is time a reason for delegated legislation?

A

Parliament doesn’t have the time to make all the legislation needed by the country and specific regions as the Parliamentary law making process is very long and time consuming. It takes a long time to go from Green Paper to White Paper and through the various stages in both Houses and finally gaining Royal Assent. Technical and detailed laws can be made quickly by others. Parliament makes around 25 laws a year compared to 3000 Statutory Instruments made a year.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Why is expertise a reason for delegated legislation?

A

Rules need subject knowledge and Parliament doesn’t know everything and may not have specialists in that area of law. Parliament will debate the principles and leave the details to the experts. For example PACE Act 1984 sets out general principles but the Police Code of Practice has all the fine detail. Usually the civil servants in departments have the specialist knowledge and so come up with the details.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Why is local knowledge a reason for delegated legislation?

A

Parliament won’t know every area of the country thoroughly. Local authorities will be aware of what is needed. For example, dog fouling in parks and no smoking on the London Underground.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Why is the ability to easily make and change laws a reason for delegated legislation?

A

Statutory Instruments and Orders in Council can be made and changed quickly. They can deal with emergencies and can respond to changing circumstances. For example shutting airports during the 9/11 attack as well as Covid rules and dealing with the foot and mouth disease outbreak in cattle and banning the materials used in the Grenfell fire.

17
Q

What is the only Parliamentary control that applies to Orders in Council and By-laws (it also applies to Statutory Instruments)?

A

The Enabling Act. Parliament chooses what powers to delegate in the Enabling Act and can decided which Government ministers to give powers to. It can specify who they need to consult or how they make delegated law. It also specifies where the delegated legislation applies. Parliament can repeal the Enabling Act at any time which instantly removes the power of the delegated body to make law. For example the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.

18
Q

What must all Statutory Instruments go through?

A

Either negative or affirmative resolutions.

19
Q

What happens in the negative resolution procedure?

A

It is the most common procedure where the Statutory Instrument is proposed and will become law unless rejected by Parliament within 40 days. There is no debate on the issue.

20
Q

What happens in the affirmative resolution procedure?

A

A debate will follow the introduction and both Houses of Parliament must expressly approve the Statutory Instrument before it can be enacted. However Parliament can’t amend the SI, only approve or withdraw/annul it. For example changes to the the police code must be approved before they come into force.

21
Q

What does the questioning of government ministers entail?

A

The minister introducing the instrument can be questioned on it. They can be questioned on current as well as proposed instruments.

22
Q

What does the Scrutiny Committee review?

A

All Statutory Instruments.

23
Q

What can the Scrutiny Committee do?

A

Draw the attention of both Houses of Parliament to any SIs which need further consideration. However they can’t alter any SI, only refer the problem to Parliament.

24
Q

Why might the Scrutiny Committee refer a Statutory Instrument back to Parliament?

A
  • SI imposes a charge or levy (SIs can’t do this)
  • SI applies retrospectively (always banned in Enabling Acts)
  • SI exceeds powers given in the Enabling Act
  • SI makes unexpected or unusual use of power
  • SI is unclear or defective in some way
25
Q

Why can’t an Enabling Act be challenged in judicial review?

A

Because it was made by Parliament and Parliament is supreme.

26
Q

Who can challenge delegated legislation?

A

Someone with standing or interest in the case- they have ‘locus standi’.

27
Q

What are the 3 situations in which the court (it will be the Queen’s Bench Division that hears these cases) can declare that the delegated legalisation is ‘ultra vires’ (meaning void)?

A
  • Substantive ultra vires- the DL goes beyond the powers given in the Enabling Act
  • Procedural ultra vires- the DL didn’t follow the correct procedure when being made
  • Wednesbury unreasonableness- a decision made under DL is unreasonable
28
Q

Which case is an example of substantive ultra vires?

A

R v Home Secretary ex parte Fire Brigades Union. Under the Criminal Justice Act 1988, the Home Secretary was allowed to decide the date to introduce the Criminal Injury Compensation Scheme. He actually changed the scheme by reducing the amount of compensation owed as well as deciding the date to introduce it. The court decided that he had gone beyond the powers given to him in the Enabling Act and so his changes to the scheme didn’t apply.

29
Q

Which case is an example of procedural ultra vires?

A

Agricultural training board v Aylesbury Mushrooms. The Minister of Labour tried to introduce new regulations for the training of mushroom growers and was required to consult ‘any group representative of substantial employees engaging in the activity concerned’. He didn’t consult the Mushroom Growers Association which represented 85% of all mushroom growers in the UK so the court decided he didn’t follow the correct procedure and so his regulations were void.

30
Q

Which case is an example of Wednesbury unreasonableness?

A

R (Rogers) v Swindon NHS Trust. Miss Rogers had breast cancer and needed the drug Herceptin. It was not yet approved and her NHS trust said that women with breast cancer could only get funding for this drug in exceptional circumstances, and her case was not exceptional. The court said it was unreasonable to draw a distinction between women with breast cancer if their medical needs were the same and so this rule became void.

31
Q

How effective is the Enabling Act as a Parliamentary control of delegated legalisation?

A

Effective because Parliament chooses who to give power to and any rules they have to follow when making DL. They can also repeal the Enabling Act at any time.
Not effective because DL sometimes goes beyond the powers given in the Enabling Act and so judicial controls are needed too.

32
Q

How effective are negative resolutions as a Parliamentary control of delegated legalisation?

A

Effective because it is a very simple process that doesn’t waste anyone’s time due to the law automatically passing if nothing happens for 40 days.
Not effective because so many SIs are made a year (3000) that a bad piece of law could slip through the gap without Parliament noticing it for 40 days.

33
Q

How effective are affirmative resolutions as a Parliamentary control of delegated legalisation?

A

Effective because DL has to be specifically approved by Parliament and so bad laws should be picked up on.
Not effective because it takes up Parliament’s time which defeats the point of delegating and Parliament can’t amend the DL, only approve or reject it.

34
Q

How effective is the Scrutiny Committee as a Parliamentary control of delegated legalisation?

A

Effective because they can try to catch bad bits of law that Parliament would miss due to the large volume of DL created.
Not effective because they can only refer the law to Parliament, not do anything about it themselves. They may not have specialist knowledge so may not know if the law is problematic anyway.

35
Q

How effective are judicial controls (judicial review) of delegated legalisation?

A

Effective because there are numerous ways to prove that DL is ultra vires and the court can hear from expert witnesses to testify about any specialist matters to work out if the law should be void.
Not effective because only someone with standing is able to bring the case so not just anyone can sue. This person may be going up against a public body who will have more resources and money so the odds of winning the case are low. The court can’t change the DL, only make it void.

36
Q

What are the advantages of DL?

A
  • Saves Parliament’s time as it takes an average of 1 to 2 years to pass an Act in Parliament so delegating allows them to spend time on more important issues like financial budgets and Brexit.
  • Specialist knowledge as complicated laws can be made more effectively by government ministers and civil servants who have expert knowledge.
  • Local knowledge which local councils have but Parliament often doesn’t meaning the law can be made by people who know the local area and know what it needed.
  • Numerous controls like the Scrutiny Committee and judicial review which means the law works in the way that Parliament intended.
37
Q

Which cases are good examples for the advantages of DL?

A

Time- Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 allowed the Minister of Work and Pensions to make regulations for all types of work like the Mining Regulations 2014.
Specialist knowledge- PACE 1984 allows the Minister of Justice to set the Police Codes of Practice.
Local knowledge- setting up alcohol free zones in areas with excessive drinking or crime.
Numerous controls- correct procedure not being followed in ATB v Aylesbury Mushrooms so the law was declared ultra vires.

38
Q

What are the disadvantages of DL?

A
  • Undemocratic as Privy Council contains non-elected judges and bishops and SIs are often made by civil servants. This means important laws may not represent what the public wants.
  • Large volume of DL as over 3000 SIs and several thousand by-laws are made each year often with little publicity so it is impossible for the average person to be aware of all these laws.
  • DL can be long and complex and often require judges to interpret the wording to fully understand them so it is hard for the public to understand how the law applies.
  • Controls aren’t always effective as the Scrutiny Committee can only refer problems to Parliament and hope they change them and few judicial reviews are successful. This means there is still bad law that isn’t being resolved properly.
39
Q

Which cases are good examples for the disadvantages of DL?

A

Undemocratic- SI passed in 2012 by Minister of Justice that restricted the rights of immigrants to get legal aid which was found ultra vires in court and not representative of public opinion.
Large volume- British Airports Authority passed a by-law banning passengers taking tennis racquets on flights and a man was fined for doing this even though he was unaware he was doing anything wrong.
Complex- R (Rogers) v Swindon NHS Trust where the case involved technical rules and specific drugs and the court had to decide what was ‘exceptional’ in relation to medical needs.
Ineffective controls- in 2008, nearly 3600 judicial reviews were requested but only 184 cases went ahead and the government lost 40% of these.