Grad Caps Flashcards
Reflective practitioner
Recognises the influence of contextual, social, political and cultural factors on situations and takes these into account when acting and justifying actions.
- 15 year old boy with hepatic encephalopathy
- clearly a type of status that came with being a doctor that made it socially acceptable, if not normal, for the doctors to be so paternalistic
- I could imagine that after years of dealing with that level of suffering I too might become detached as a means of coping
- This lead me to reflect on the fact that his actions were not intrinsically right or wrong
- In Australia, we value patient autonomy and beneficence
- therefore, the same actions in this context would appear immoral
- But in Zambia, that is not necessarily so
- Over there, the ethics were much more utilitarian – trying to make the little resources that they have go as far as possible
- As a result, the individual was less important
- Clearly, it is the changing context, with its cultural and social factors bubbling through, that make our actions right or wrong, not the actions themselves
Self-directed learning
Learning projects
- Negotiated capability for med, emergency and childrens health.
- Negotiated assignment for childrens health.
DEA
- Campus representative
- Organisation focuses on the health impacts of climate change
- My involvement isn’t due to environmentalist reasons
- There is no greater threat to health and I see it as part of a doctors responsibility to promote health
- Goal was to research and initiate efforts to make port base greener
- Side tracked by covid
- Focus became on learning as much about climate health as possible
- Wrote negotiated assignment on the ethical obligation that a doctor has to protect against the effects of climate change
- Hoping to publish it with the head of paediatrics, somewhere informally
Using basic and clinical sciences
Anticipates possible complications and their patho physiological basis, as well as measures for prevention and treatment (i.e. work out other courses that the disease process could have taken, and other management options).
- Cirrhosis in zambia
- Obviously irreversible so management focuses on anticipating and preventing complications
- Many fatal complications of cirrhosis such as hepatocellular carcinoma
- In an effort to avoid costly investigations, there was an emphasis on empirical prophylaxis against complications that were fatal in the short term
- Without ready access to gastroscopy, every patient was placed on a beta blocker, assuming that they had varices
- Patients were diuresed as this has been shown to decrease the incidence of SBP
- Patients were given albumin to protect against hepatorenal syndrome
Using basic and clinical sciences
Predicts likely outcomes of disease and prioritises approaches to individuals with multiple diseases or multi-system diseases, based upon principles of basic/medical science.
- 3 year old with urticarial rash, vomiting, syncope, febrile (Childrens health term)
- Multi system presentation involving skin, GI, cardiovascular
- When I heard this patients hand over on the ward round I was convinced that it was anaphylaxis as it fit the criteria used in America
- Clearly, determining if it was or was not anaphylaxis was not important for her current management
- She had presented the night before and was comfortably playing in the room by the time we did that ward round the next morning
- But I knew that if it was anaphylaxis, she would need follow up with an allergen-immunologist to confirm the diagnosis and determine the trigger
- she would also need education around allergen avoidance
- most importantly, she needed to be discharged with a script for two epi pens because of the risk of recurrence
- I raised my concern with the consultant who said that it couldn’t be anaphylaxis because there was no respiratory involvement
- I knew that this was not part of the criteria, so this made me worry more that they were missing a vital diagnosis
- Fortunately, when I reviewed the patients notes it was clear from the time course that it couldn’t be anaphylaxis. It was most likely a viral urticaria
- This encounter inspired me to research the validity of the criteria used for diagnosing anaphylaxis by different groups
- I developed an appreciate for the difficulty in diagnosing this undifferentiated multi system diseases without a gold standard investigation to refer to
- My concern was a typical example of how the criteria that are used to counter this lack of an objective marker are always more sensitive than they are specific, which inevitably leads to over diagnosing
Using basic and clinical sciences
Plans and justifies a series of rational and appropriate investigations and / or screening test options, using EBM skills to take cost-effectiveness, benefit and test accuracy into consideration.
*
- Saw many cases of exacerbations of heart failure during my medicine term
- While preparing for biomed, I learnt the possible work up with everything from troponins to BNPs on the list
- It wasn’t until I listened to a podcast on heart failure this year that things were finally simplified
- The guest said that if they were on a desert island and could only order three tests it would be the Cr, K and Na
- These were not the investigations that came to mind when I thought of heart failure
- But her whole point was that there was no point in ordering something if it doesn’t change her management
- BNP levels rising or falling did not alter her management
- But knowing the Cr told her how aggressively she could diurese the patient
- The Na was an indicator of severity, fluid overload and decreased renal perfusion
- The K was a key baseline for the major complication of treatment, hypokalaemia
- This guided not only my approach to ordering investigations, but also the history
- It either needs to confirm the diagnosis or influence management (AF with CHADSVASC and HASBLED score)
Teamwork
COVID clinic
- The students saw themselves as part of the hospital community
- Our goal was to lessen the burden on the over worked ED
- Triaging patients with algorithm to follow
- Deciding who needed to go to red ED, green ED, or get tested and go home
- The key issue was not becoming too tunnel visioned on covid. People were still coming to ED for all the other important reasons that they usually do.
- While we didn’t want people coming in and crowding the ED unnecessarily, our worst fear was sending someone home when they needed to be admitted
Teamwork
Recognises the significant features of a team, including roles, responsibilities, personalities and power relations.
*
- Many key components of teamwork
- Leadership, backup behaviour, mutual performance monitoring, adaptability
- Supported by a shared mental model, trust, and communication
- I think communication is the most pivotal. No other aspect can function effectively without it
- This was highlighted to me by a video that I watched on emergencypaedia
- Recounts the death of a young lady after a routine operation
- Something had gone wrong and they were the dreaded position of cant intubate can ventilate
- There were three consultants in the room
- The author describes there being a loss of awareness. Specifically, awareness of what was happening was not shared by each of the consultants
- In other words, the team had lost their shared mental model, no one could lead and they couldn’t adapt to the new situation because no information was flowing between the team members
- In the inquest, the nurses stated that they knew exactly what needed to happen but didn’t know how to communicate it
- A nurse fetched a tracheostomy kit and announced it was available. There was no response
- There are many barriers to good communication in medicine
- The strong hierarchy undoubtedly played a role as well as a fear of being wrong, not trusting the other members of the team to receive the information in good faith
- A solution is graded assertiveness
- CUSS concern, unsure, safety, stop
Teamwork
Analyses and solves problems collaboratively.·
· Neonatal intubation for persistent pulmonary hypertension
· during a time out before the procedure the neonatologist prescribed each person a role and outlined each step of the procedure
· he was ensuring that everyone had a shared goal and an understanding of their own role and everyone else’s in achieving it
· this allowed for mutual performance monitoring and backup behaviour
· during the intubation, the baby’s saturations began to fall steeply
· each member called out that there were no issues
· after a short while, the neonatologist realised that the oxygen was on at the wall but not the baby’s ventilator machine
· their saturations corrected quickly and they were transferred to a tertiary center in a stable condition
· at the mortality and morbidity meeting, I learnt that this was actually a relatively minor complication in the scheme of things
· by communicating effectively, the team had adapted flexibly to the new condition, the neonatologist was able to lead effectively, and a more serious outcome was avoided
Teamwork
Understands events in a team from others’ viewpoints, including identifying their goals and recognising their feelings.·
· Small class during rotations in port Macquarie
· We only had three
· We had an ongoing issue where one of the students in the group was absent at a lot of classes
· Very noticeable when a third of the class is missing
· We kept finding ourselves in the position of having to apologise for this student or make excuses
· The other student became very frustrated and sent me a copy of the message that she planned to send him
· It was incredibly indirect and made it sound like she was just frustrated in general at people not attending classes
· I told her not to send the message
· I said that the other student probably had no idea that he was putting us in an awkward situation. He may be missing class for any number of personal reasons.
· We should give him the opportunity to change his behaviour and to do that he needs proper feedback, saying specifically what we are upset about and what we would like to change moving forward
· She sent a new message that did just that and sure enough he wrote back saying that he had no idea, that he was happy to take over some extra ward rounds from us to pick up the slack, and it was never an issue again moving forward
· This was an important lesson to me to not assume that you understand the viewpoint of another person in the team
· Communicate and pass information freely between members and then everyone can make informed decisions that are oriented towards the teams shared goal
Teamwork
Behaves pro-actively, taking action and responsibility when necessary.
*
- Simulation of being in remote ED when child comes in with status epilepticus
- I was assigned airway doctor
- I secured the airway with a jaw thrust and chin lift
- There were no other airway or breathing issues
- I knew the status pathway and was aware that one of the final steps is with ongoing deterioration is making the decision to intubate
- This was not a skill that I was comfortable with, and so I became fixated and worried that I was going to need to do it
- Then the child stopped breathing spontaneously and I made the first steps towards intubating
- The teacher asked if maybe I should trial a less invasive intervention first like a bag mask valve
- Flustered, I first attached the adult sized mask and then attached the hose to air instead of oxygen at the wall, wasting crucial seconds
- In the debrief after I reflected that I had cognitively offloaded to the treatment algorithm and had become passive in my role
- When the airway was secure I should have been planning my next steps for if and when it deteriorated
- I have had several simulation sessions since, and have focused on taking any moment of respite in my role to actively plan and anticipate my next steps, as well as consider whether I need to assist a team mate in their tasks
Effective communication
Communicates effectively across a clinical team including accurate and pertinent documentation.
*
- Received consistently good marks and feedback for communication with patients
- But provided summarys of patient presentations or brief handovers to colleagues has been a skill that I have always found challenging
- Emergency feedback to continue practicing and developing this skill
- There was a surgical tutorial that really changed my approach to this common scenario
- We were split into two groups to work up a patient and then hand it over to the other team as though we were finishing our shift
- My patient had presented with chronic limb ischaemia requiring revascularisation
- I made a passable handover using the ISBAR format
- I stated that the patient had chronic limb ischaemia, was previously on warfarin after a previous episode and had increased her dose prior to administration thinking that it would reduce the pain. Her INR was above 5 on admission
- The current goal of management was to bridge her back into a therapeutic range with her current INR being just above 1
- The consultant point out to me that I made several important omissions
- I needed to describe that the patient had gangrene on her fifth and first toe
- That I couldn’t feel any pulses but that the foot was warm
- This would prevent a colleague from wondering if the gangrene and lack of pulses was a new complication
- I should have also communicated that the reason she was on warfarin was because of a previous reaction to a DOAC
- This would prevent a colleague from adjusting her medications in light of her poor INR control
- This experience taught me that the key was to put myself in my colleagues shoes
- Try to determine what information they needed to in order to take on the care of the patient
- Shown significant improvement in this area
- Received P+ in final terms OnG and selective for effective communication
- Comment from OnG supervisor that I was a good communicator
Effective communication
Communicates bad news sensitively.
- 81 year old man with hepatocellular carcinoma in zambia
- Without access to a CT scanner a raised AFP was often used to confirm the diagnosis of HCC in a patient with decompensated cirrhosis
- On this occasion there were 20 students crowded around the patients bed as the consultant received the investigation results
- He then spoke openly to the class about the diagnosis and questioned several students about its pathophysiology
- Finally he turned to the patients daughter and the first thing he said was “so this is palliative”
- Without discussing the diagnosis or prognosis, he immediately began to argue with her about how he could not remain in hospital as there was nothing they would do and he was using up a bed
- We have been taught many times that bad news should be broken in a quiet private place, there should be appropriate education given to the patient about management options and the likely progression and ample time for questions and concerns
- I always took these points for granted
- It was not until I saw how horrible it is when they are not followed that I knew how important they are
- We left that patient and his daughter in tears, confused, scared and hopeless
- Even if there was nothing that could be done for that man medically, we could have done a lot more to relieve his mental suffering and to make his death as comfortable as possible
Effective communication
Explains the likely progress of a disease to a patient.
*
- Appendicitis during port elective
- Repeated admissions
- Frustrated by being bumped on emergency list
- Wanted to cancel surgery and go to Sydney to see her friends
- Advised her to raise concerns with surgeon
- My understanding that she would likely develop another episode
- High failure rate with antibiotics alone
- Risk of complications, more pain, another period away from work and in hospital
- She then asked about her appendix, what caused it to be inflamed, what happened in surgery
- Resulted in her deciding to stay
- Felt like I contributed to team
Effective communication
Finds common ground with the patient in identifying the problem list, negotiating an evidence-based management plan and agreeing roles and responsibilities.
- Vaccination discussion in childrens health
- Paediatrician had organised a separate 1 hr appointment to discuss parents concerns
- His approach was based on a useful RACGP article organising parents along a spectrum
- Unquestioning acceptor to refuser with this mum being closer to the middle, vaccination hesitant
- This approach highlighted that where you sat on that spectrum was a function of your level of concern
- An unquestioning acceptor has done little to no research and has no concerns
- A refuser has also done little to no research but has major concerns
- The vaccination hesitant has done lots of research and this has made them concerned
- At each point along the spectrum, the parent is trying to do what they think is best for the child
- This point was raised early by the paediatrician, stating that he too wanted to do what was best
- That was not their point of disagreement. They only disagreed on what was in fact best
- The mum responded well to this point. I think people against vaccinations are often vilified and there is a kind of us vs them dynamic between doctors and anti-vaxers
- Finding the common ground that they both wanted what was best for the child diffused this tension and allowed the mum to trust the doctor enough to engage in a productive conversation about her specific concerns, which he could then address one by one
- From this I learnt to try to assume the best intentions from the patient as it will often be more productive
- Don’t just assume that the patient isn’t taking their statin because they’re lazy
- Assume that there is a very valid and understandable barrier to their compliance which needs to be overcome together, like intolerable side effects
Social and cultural determinants of health
Plans health care with patients’ lifestyle, culture and resources in mind.
- 1 year old with epilepsy
- Presented after seizure
- Live about 1hr inland from Kempsey
- Mum had decided to drive son in instead of calling ambulance
- Reportedly drove well over 150kph because she thought her son was dying
- Because of the families remote location the decision was made to prescribe buccal midazolam in addition to usual first aid education
- The treating team hoped that this would allow the mum to be comfortable enough to call the ambulance and wait safely at home rather than endangering herself, her son, and other drivers by speeding on isolated country roads
- This was one of most influential cases that taught me the importance of considering the environment that you are discharging the patient back to
- Clearly, it would not have been appropriate to have proceeded with the standard care, with patient education on recovery positions and removing hazards etc
- The patient’s remoteness alone led to an additional prescription