GOVT 1817 Flashcards
- Why We Fight Over Foreign Policy
Nau
What?
Why?
How?
What- simplifying IP is easier
Why- IP is confusing
How- labels and models can be easily explained (paradigm wars)
- Reductionist and Systemic Theories
Waltz
What?
Why?
How?
Defensive Realism
What- to be secure, states must achieve a stable balance of power
Why- there is such a thing as “too much power,” and states with too much will get ganged up on (security dilemma)
How- whole leads to parts, anarchy effects states (parts) differently
- Great Power Politics
Mearsheimer
What?
Why?
How?
Offensive Realism
What- every state has to maximize power to guarantee safety
Why- power is zero-sum, no trust or stability in IS (alliances are only possible when polar, cold war)
How- take over or get taken over (anarchy)
- The Tragedy of Offensive Realism
Kirshner
What?
Why?
How?
Classical Realism
What- states are not the only relevant actors, must look at leaders
Why- two leaders in the same position might not make the same decision (biases, ideas, etc)
How- containing power can lead to war, hegemony has a bad track record
- Liberalism and Democratic Peace
Owen
What?
Why?
How?
Republican Liberalism
What- democratic peace theory (states perceived as democratic are unlikely to go to war)
Why- structures of democracy prevent war
How- leaders can be voted out, separation of power democratically
- Trading State
Rosecrance
What?
Why?
How?
Commercial Liberalism
What- international trade increases the cost of going to war
Why- benefits of trade are positive sum even if territory is zero sum
How- no more territory to conquer for resources, but can trade for resources. Warring countries don’t trade with each other.
- Economic Limits to Modern Politics
Keohane
What?
Why?
How?
Institutional Liberalism
What- institutions shape our perceptions of the world (specifically other states/actors)
Why- if DPT true, states must be presented as non-democratic in order to justify military action
How- political messaging, language
- Political Economy of International Relations
Gilpin
What?
Why?
How?
Marxism
What- (1) change due to class struggle, (2) materialist approach to history, (3) capitalist mode of production and destiny governed by set of economic laws of motion and modern society, (4) normative commitment to socialism
Why-
How-
- Beyond IR Theory
Cox
What?
Why?
How?
Marxism
What- marxism is dialectic, not causal
Why- material capabilities, institutions, and ideas are influenced and influential
How- dialectic explores tension and contradictions, causal functions as one event leading to the other
- Theoretical Reprise
Wallerstein
What?
Why?
How?
Marxism
What- core nations exploit periphery nations for resources under capitalism, creating tension
Why- inequality is necessary for this exploitation for core nations to profit
How- not all countries like or benefit from this system, leading to unrest (leading to coups, revolutions, etc)
13, 14, 15. Postcolonialism
Ba, Mampilly, Buzas
What?
Why?
How?
Postcolonialism
What- international security structures enable racism and (neo) colonialism (ba)
Why- reformists and traditionalists run international relations, language around race changes
How- eurocentrism
- Sex & Death
Cohn
What?
Why?
How?
Feminism
What- the language of politics shapes reality
Why- military is dominated by patriarchal language
How- imagery, sexism, “clean language”
- Women and Children First
Carpenter
What?
Why?
How?
Feminism
What- gendered norms are pervasive everywhere including war
Why- the patriarchy paints women and children as non-military threats, whereas men are inherently a military threat
How- aid organizations language focused around “women and children,” patriarchy harms men too
- Women and the Evolution of World Politics
Fukuyama
What?
Why?
How?
Feminism
What- biological basis for patriarchy
Why- animals behave in patriarchal structures sometimes
How- feminization of security dilemmas, young and male violence
- Constructing International Politics
Wendt
What?
Why?
How?
Constructivism
What- socially constructed ideas can be just as, if not more important than material structures
Why- ideas shape social constructions leading us to some view on reality and behavior
How- differences in perspective (North Korea’s (small) nuclear stockpile is a threat whereas the US’s (large) nuclear stockpile is not).
- Clash of Civilizations?
Huntington
What?
Why?
How?
Constructivism
What- conflicts in the modern era are based on cultural lines
Why- political ideologies are weak because they’re too flexible, cultural lines/identities are more concrete
How- conflicts will occur based on these identities???
- Good Muslim, Bad Muslim
Mamdani
What?
Why?
How?
Constructivism
What- religious identities are constructed, good/bad (prescriptive) labels are inaccurate
Why- good/bad labels are an expression of imperialism
How- oversimplifies situations, leads to justification of problematic policies
- The Jacksonian Tradition
Mead
What?
Why?
How?
Domestic Politics
What- domestic public opinion influences the US’s tendency to wage war
Why- jacksonian tradition (small gov., individualism, state-oriented) has shaped how US politics functions
How- slow to commit to foreign policy issues, but vicious/militant in war
- Same War- Different Views
Katzenstein
What?
Why?
How?
Domestic Politics
What- countries respond differently to crises
Why- no systemic prediction can be made for all states’ behavior
How- different historical contexts, path dependency (what happened in the past matters, repeated cycles are due to resistance to change)
- WW1
Yoder
What?
Why?
How?
WW1
What- war occurred due to inept leadership (individuals and governments)
Why- ineptitude comes from an inability to communicate
How- confusion and delays leads to mistakes (failed assassination attempts of Archduke Ferdinand, driver going the wrong way leading to his death)
- A Conflict that Shaped the Modern World
Erlanger
What?
Why?
How?
WW1
What- world war 1 created desire for international institutions to avoid further conflict
Why- rising tensions and anxieties in the weakening of the ottoman empire, austro-hungaria, general unrest
How- if not the assassination of archduke Ferdinand, something else would have set off wwi
- Civil-Military Relations and the Cult of the Offensive
Snyder
What?
Why?
How?
WW1
What- civil-military relations shape conflict due to divide in beliefs
Why- military prefers offensive tactics, public prefers defensive
How- the military wants to enhance prestige by winning wars, means before ends
- Commercial Liberalism Under Fire
Ripsman & Blanchard
What?
Why?
How?
WW1
What- commercial liberalism isn’t always enough to prevent war
Why- economic interdependence requires policymakers to be aware of that interdependence
How- to promote peace, more than economic interdependence and trade has to be present