Globalizing World - theories

Question 1

What do different theories disagree on?

Answer 1

The different theories disagree on…
… who the actors are
… what drives action
… whether cooperation is possible

Question 2

Why do realists call themselves like that?

Answer 2

Because they claim to look at the world as it is rather than as it should be

Question 3

What are the main concepts of realism?

Answer 3

💥 Anarchy
🚩 Statism
💪 Power
💅 Self-help
👤 Human nature

Question 4

Explain anarchy

Answer 4

Lack of international government => states have to accumulate power to guarantee their survival

Question 5

Explain statism

Answer 5

1) The states are the main actors
2) International institutions are of secondary importance because their powers are framed by the states

Question 6

Explain self-help

Answer 6

1) The states cannot trust each other
2) Have to rely exclusively on themselves to guarantee their survival

Question 7

What are the three types of realism? Explain.

Answer 7

Classical realism (Morgenthal)
Reason why states seek power related to human nature

Neo-realism/structural realism (Waltz)
States’ actions must be explained by anarchy (“structure of international scene) rather than human nature
NR can be subdivided into 2 currents (see other card)

Neo-classical realism
Takes into account both human nature & structure
Takes into account what happens within the states

Question 8

What are two subdivisions of structural realism? Explain.

Answer 8

Defensive realism
Balance of powers
Increase in power aims for balance

Offensive realism (Mearsheimer)
Increase power beyond what is needed to guarantee security

Question 9

What are the two types of balance of power?

Answer 9

External balancing
Creating alliance in order to balance out powerful countries
Risk: other countries cannot be trusted

Internal balancing
Increasing defense power

Question 10

Explain the security dilemma

Answer 10

1) You arm to increase your power
2) Other countries don’t want you to become to powerful so they arm as well

Consequence: more security = less security (congrats, you fucked up ✨)

Question 11

Explain human nature

Answer 11

Humans have a constant power-seeking behaviour

Question 12

What are the main concepts of liberalism?

Answer 12

🗳️ Democracy
📈 Trade
🌍 International institutions

Question 13

What do Liberalism & Realism have in common

Answer 13

• believe in anarchy
• states pursue their own interests

Question 14

What are the main claims of Liberalism?

Answer 14

1) Change is possible
2) Cooperation is possible
3) More actors are relevant
4) More power sources are relevant
5) Globalisation = increased interdependence

Question 15

Who are relevant actors according to Liberalism?

Answer 15

🚩 States
🕯️NGOs
🌍 IGOs
🪧 Popular movements
💰 Companies

Question 16

What alternatives does Liberalism see to hard power?

Answer 16

Soft power
Persuasion (through culture/diplomacy)

Bargaining power
Also gives smaller states a chance to prevail

Question 17

How are state preferences shaped (Liberalism)?

Answer 17

Who?
Civil society orgs
Public opinion
Lobby groups

Why?
If state doesn’t respect those preferences, will lose votes

Further info
The more democratic, the more these preferences are taken into account

Question 18

How do state preferences shape the international scene? (lib.)

Answer 18

Preferences converge
Increases likelihood of cooperation & peaceful coexistence

Preferences diverge
Increases likelihood of conflict

Question 19

What is the idea behind the “two level game”?

Answer 19

State preferences are shaped by:
1) Domestic politics
2) International scene

Question 20

Why do states collaborate? (lib.)

Answer 20

Positive-sum game
N’en déplaise aux réalistes

Shadow of the future
You might need them lateron

International institutions
Overcome costs of collaboration

Question 21

What are barriers to cooperation?

Answer 21

ℹ️ Lack of info abt state pref
🫠 Fear of defections by other states
⚖️ Asymetrical interdependence
🐀 Free-riders pbm
💸 High costs of cooperation

Question 22

What are some critiques of liberal institutionalism?

Answer 22

Overemphasis on international orgs
Inefficient dispute-setting mechanisms, Trump withdrawing…

Neo-Marxist critique
Western values - oppress Global South, perpetuate inequalities

Post-colonial critiques
Paternalistic (impose values), meddle in other countries’ affairs (“democracy-promotion”)

Question 23

Define
1) International institutions
2) International regimes
3) International organisations

Answer 23

1) International institutions
Overarching framework for interactions among states & other actors

2) International regimes
Norms/rules within an issue area

3) International organisations
Formal entities that facilitate cooperation

Question 24

Explain the tragedy of the commons (lib.)

Answer 24

Countries are best off if they can unilaterally defect BUT if both defect then there is no agreement

Question 25

Why is **democracy** an essential peace-keeping tool? (lib.)

Answer 25

- Tradition of peaceful conflict-solving - Have same values - Checks & balances: leaders held accountable

Question 26

Why is **trade** an essential peace-keeping tool? (lib.)

Answer 26

- Interdependence - Cultural exchange = better mutual understanding

Question 27

Why are **international institutions** an essential peace-keeping tool? (lib.)

Answer 27

Different ways of promoting peace, including: - Norms - Mediation - Information Reduce costs of collaboration by providing a framework

Question 28

How does the likelihood of a conflict evolve according to the type of rule?

Answer 28

_Democracy-democracy_ Least likely to have a conflict _Autocracy-autocracy_ More likely to have a conflict _Democracy-autocracy_ Most likely to have a conflict

Question 29

What are the two conceptions regarding peace & democracy?

Answer 29

_Monadic_ *"Democracies are more peaceful"* No evidence _Dyadic_ *"Democracies don't go to war with each other"* More evidence, since powerful democracies (aka les US) try to "spread democracy" (mdr)

Question 30

What are the main differences between Realism & Liberalism?

Answer 30

_Anarchy_ **R:** national interests always prevail **L:** cooperation is possible _Actors_ **R:** states **L:** states, companies, citizens _Drivers_ **R:** survival **L:** personal advantage (sought through peace => dem, trade, IGOs) _Main claim_ **R:** describe world as it is, don't seek to fix it **L:** describe how the world should be, seek to mitigate it _States_ **R:** all states work the same way, regardless of their gov **L:** autocratic regimes more aggressive than democratic ones

Question 31

What are the key assumptions of social constructivism?

Answer 31

1) World is not only shaped by brute force, but also by **ideas** (change the way in which you interpret information) 2) Actors do not only behave in accordance with cost-benefit calculations, but also according to **norms**

Question 32

What is the social constructivist vision of **power**?

Answer 32

Not only **material** but also **normative** (power to impose ideas and values)

Question 33

What are the main concepts of social constructivism (& their explanation)?

Answer 33

_Idealism_ Ideas also shape the world (not only brute force) _Holism_ It is not possible to divide the world into actors (like other theories do) since every action is the result of countless interactions

Question 34

What does social constructivism say regarding: actors, drivers & collaboration?

Answer 34

_Actors_ Society (norms shaped through interaction) _Drivers_ Unlike realism/liberalism: there is no common driver for all actors _Collaboration_ Whether or not collaboration is possible depends on how the other is perceived according to your norms

Question 35

What do the different theories say as to **what shapes decision-making**?

Answer 35

_Logic of consequence_ *(Materialist rationality)* Cost-benefit calculation shape action (more realist/liberal view) _Logic of appropriateness_ *(Ideational rationality)* Actors also take what is seen as right/wrong into account (more social constructivist view)

Question 36

What are the two types of norms?

Answer 36

_Constitutive norms_ Create a certain behaviour (eg. rules of chess) _Regulative norms_ Regulate a behaviour that would exist even without those rules (eg. arriving to classes on time)

Question 37

What are the three steps that lead to the acceptance of a norm?

Answer 37

_Norm emergence_ Normative entrepreneur (not necessarily a person) calls for attention on a specific issue _Norm cascade_ Norm spreads from the entrepreneur to other ppl _Norm internalisation_ Norm is no longer a matter of debate

Question 38

Do all norms go through all 3 stages?

Answer 38

No, some don't (eg. post Cold-War democratisation of Russia: norm has not be internalised) + being internalised does not prevent a norm from being challenged again

Question 39

What irrational guidelines shape behaviour according to social constructivism?

Answer 39

_Social facts_ Ideas that are taken for granted even though their existence depends on whether or not they are accepted (eg. money, sovereignty) *(≠ brute facts) _Practices_ Socially meaningful patterns of action (shows you know "how things should be done")

Question 40

Does social constructivism consider the world's structure as something permanent?

Answer 40

NO What is could not have been and could not be in the future (on dirait du sun tzu lol) ≠ other theories

Question 41

What are some criticisms of social constructivism?

Answer 41

1) Difficult to make predictions & empirical observations 2) Everything can be explained according to the theory, depending on how you twist it (diminishes its value)

Question 42

Is **post-colonialism** a theory? If not, why?

Answer 42

No, its scholars only criticise existing theories Theories ask questions abt the world, post-colonialism asks questions abt the theories

Question 43

What are the main criticisms of post-colonialism?

Answer 43

Theories are not objective & not neutral (created *by* the West *for* the West) **Because...** ... they are Western-centric & irrelevant for global south ... still repeat patterns that are colonial (see next card) ... leaves GS perspective out (Cold War: what abt Vietnam, Korea, etc???)

Question 44

Give examples in which theories repeat colonial patterns

Answer 44

🎭 Developed/developing 🚩 Nation-state = default unit 🗳️ Everybody strives for same values ⚖️ Democracies = more peaceful

Question 45

What do post-colonialists criticize about **realism**?

Answer 45

_Anarchy_ Justifies colonialism: stronger states dominate weaker ones _Values_ No space for morality: just "the world as it is" _Power-focused_ Only take big states into account; GS only seen as source of problems

Question 46

What do post-colonialists criticise about **liberalism**?

Answer 46

_Paternalism_ GS states seen as "catching up with the West" _International institutions_ Heavily dominated by the West _Democracies_ Seen as only valid system Not necessarily more peaceful (see post-colonial Africa)

Question 47

What do post-colonialists criticise about **social constructivism**?

Answer 47

_Norms_ Focus on how they were created, but do not challenge them