Georgia Evidence Flashcards
Subsequent Remedial Measure
In Georgia, Subsequent Remedial Measures is admissible in strict liability cases to prove that the defendant admitted that the product was unsafe and could be made safer.
Statement by Health Care Providers in malpractice cases.
In civil actions, statement or conduct expressing sympathy, mistake, error or a general sense of benevolence made by a health care provider to a patient, her representative, or a relative are inadmissible and do not constitute an admission of liability.
Involuntary Confessions
Involuntary confessions are inadmissible even if they are not barred by the hearsay rule. A confession may be considered involuntary if law enforcement/prosecution induced it by giving the accused even the slightest hope of a benefit.
Wiretapping, Eavesdropping and Surveillance
Any evidence obtained in violation of Georgia’s wiretapping and surveillance statutes is inadmissible except for the purpose of proving a violation of the statute.
Judicial Notice of Law-Mandatory or Permissive?
- (1) The existence and territorial extent of the states, their forms of government and symbols of nationality
- (2) The laws of nations
- (3) All laws and resolutions of the general assembly of Georgia
- (4) The laws of the United States and of Several States
- (5) General Customs of Merchants
- (6) Admiralty and maritime courts of the world
- (7) The political constitution and history of Georgia’s government as well as the local divisions of Georgia
- (8) All similar matters of legislative fact
Particular Types of Real Proof–Jury View of the Scene
- A scene view of the scene is not evidence and can only be used by the jury to better understand the evidence.
- A evidentiary view is evidence. An evidentiary view is a view that permits the jury to view evidence introduced in the case. This is allowed when evidence is so large or affixed that it cannot be brought into the courtroom.
Polygraph Test
- Polygraph results are admissible only pursuant to stipulation by the defense and state.
- Authentication-Photographs
- A photograph, motion picture, videotape or audio recording is admissible over an authentication objection despite the fact that the authenticating witness is unavailable if the court determines that such an item tends to reliably show the facts for which it is offered.
Authentication-
Unattended Camera Or Recording Device
- A photograph, film, videotape or audio recording from an unattended camera or recoding devide will be admitted if
- (1) The court determines that it tends to show reliably the facts for which it is offered and
- (2) The date and time have been recorded on the item contemporaneously with the events depicted.
- Any discrepancy in the date/time goes to the weight to be given the evidence. It does not preclude admissibility.
Authentication-Medical Bills
- In a civil case involving disease or injury, medical bills may be authenticated by testimony of the patient or the patient’s caregiver that the bills were received and that they relate to the patient’s injuries. It is not necessary for an expert witness to testify that the bills were reasonable or necessary.
- Self-Authenticating Documents-Georgia Public Records
- Georgia state, county and municipal records are admissible in Georgia courts with a written certification; no seal is required.
Competency-
- Infancy:
- In all cases involving a dependent child (one without proper parental care) and in any criminal case in which a child was a victim or a witness, the child is competent to testify even if he does not understand the obligation of the oath. However, child is still subject to a competency challenge.
Competency
- Dead Man Act:
- Georgia does NOT have a Dead Man Act. Therefore, an interested party or person is competent to testify to personal transactions or communications with the deceased.
Competency
Lay Witness Value of Property
- : In Georgia, a witness MAY** give her opinion on the value of property even if she is not an expert or dealer in the article in question, if it is shown that the witness had an opportunity to form a **reasoned opinion
- Expert Opinion
- (a) Subject Matter must be appropriate for expert testimony
- In Georgia Criminal cases, expert opinion will be admissible on any question of science, skill, trade or like question. Trial court will decide if the procedure/technique reached a scientific stage of verifiable certainty In Georgia Civil cases, Georgia applies the federal standards for admissibility of expert testimony.
Expert Opinion
- (2) The witness must be qualified as an expert
- In all : An expert testifying as to the standard of care must be licensed to practice in the state in which she was practicing or teaching at the time of the alleged act or omission.
- Medical Malpractice: In addition to the stated requirements above, the witness must also have actively participated or taught for at least 3 of the last 5 years with sufficient frequency to establish an appropriate level of knowledge relative to the procedure, diagnosis, or treatment alleged to have been performed negligently.
- The witness must be a member of the same profession as the defendant. However, a physician with sufficient experience and knowledge may testify as to the standard of care for nurses and other specified health providers.
- Medical Malpractice: In addition to the stated requirements above, the witness must also have actively participated or taught for at least 3 of the last 5 years with sufficient frequency to establish an appropriate level of knowledge relative to the procedure, diagnosis, or treatment alleged to have been performed negligently.
Georgia Statement of Hearsay Rule
- Statement of the rule: In Georgia, the out of court statement of a testifying witness is NOT hearsay. Regardless, the prior statements are generally inadmissible as cumulative and/or improper bolstering of the witness’s testimony. Thus, in Georgia, an out-of-court statement by a testifying witness is admissible if
- (1) It is a prior inconsistent statement
- (2) It is a prior inconsistent statement that logically rebuts an attack on the witness’s credibility or
- (3) It falls within some hearsay exception.
Hearsay
- Statements that are Non-Hearsay
- Admission by Party-Opponent
- The other party has the right to have the whole admission and all conversation connected with in admitted into evidence.
Hearsay
- Statements that are Non-Hearsay
- Vicarious Admissions
- Statements of government agents are NOT admissions of the state in a criminal case.
Hearsay
- Vicarious Admissions Co-Conspirators
- Statements made by a con-conspirator during the concealment phase may be admissible against co-conspirators if made in furtherance of the conspiracy
- This rule may apply even if the persons involved has not been charged with conspiracy.
- Hearsay Exceptions Declarants Availability Immaterial
- Present State of Mind
- Limits the statements to ONLY the intent of the declarant’s own intent NOT to the intent of third persons.
- “I plan to go to Japan with Greg”
- With greg will be excluded.
- “I plan to go to Japan with Greg”