General Deck Flashcards
Impact on Potential Market (FU - 4)
Spectrum
- Harm to work or derivative work that (c) owner seeks to market
- Market plaintiff likely to develop
- Traditional, reasonable markets
- Markets plaintiff would generally develop of license
- Identified alternative markets
- Any market Plaintiff would have licensed
- Any group of people who would pay for acces
- Value of work even if no market
Amount (FU - 3)
- Quantitative
- Qualitative
- Denominator: each copyrighted work
- Degree of targeting / degree of harm
Nature of Plaintiff’s work (FU - 2)
- Published/Unpublished
- Creative/Factual
- Computer software: need for greater latitude in copying to reveal unprotected functional features
Purpose and Character of D’s Activity
- Commercial
- Transformative
- Parody [most favored]
- Critical of P’s work [favored]
- Physical Modification
- Socially Valuable
- Different purpose [favored]
- Shady (good faith and fair dealing)
- Customary: Implied consent to customary uses
Fair Use - 107
Preferred uses: Criticism, comment, news, reporting, teaching, scholarship, research
1) Purpose and Character of D’s use
2) Nature of P’s Work
3) Amount of copying
4) Impact on Potential Market
VARA (106a)
1990 - May be waived, not transferred - FOR LIFE
1) Right a) to claim authorship and b) to prevent use of his/her name as author of work he/she did not create
2) Right to prevent attribution to work in event of distortion / mutilation / modification which would prejudice reputation
3) Right to a) prevent intentional distortion / mutilation / modification that would be prejudicial and b) prevent destruction of a work of RECOGNIZED STATURE
Exceptions to VARA
- Modification due to passage of time not covered
- Modification due to conservation, presentation not covered
- VARA does not apply to reproductions / derivative works
Definition of visual art for VARA
1) Painting / drawing / print / sculpture in limited edition of 200 copies or fewer signed and consecutively numbered
2) Still photo produced for exhibition in limited edition of 200 copies or fewer signed and consecutively numbered
Lanham Act 43(a)
- Prevents passing of a TM or (c) of one’s own
- Dastar = once work falls into public domain, anyone may do anything they want /w it
Moral Rights
-Integrity
-Attribution
-Disclosure (author determines if his work is complete)
-Withdrawal (recall work)
-Droit de suite (fee for resale)
(Right against excessive criticism)
Exceptions to Public Performance and Display
FWRD / RNCH
1) Classroom: Face to face nonprofit teaching
2) Distance Learning: Produced primarily for distance learning / nonprofit
3) Religion: in the course of services @ religious establishment
4) Nonprofit: not transmitted to public, not for pay
5) Homestyle: E.G. Personal Radio (private home device)
6) FMLA: bars, restaurants, retailers, (very complicated)
7) Webcasts
8) Real-space displays: Owner of particular copy may display that copy publicly
Public (Display or Performance)
1) To perform / display at place open to public or at place where # persons > normal circle of family / friends is gathered
2) To transmit / communicate to place described in (1) or to public by means of any device/process whether public receives in same place or different place and at same time or different time
Perform
Recite, render, play, dance, act directly, or through device or process or to show sequentially scenes of motion picture of make sounds available
Display
Show a copy either directly or through film, slide, television image, or device or process or in case of motion picture to show nonsequential individual images
Performance and Display
106(4), 106(5), 106(6)
106(4): Right to perform work publicly (literary, musical, dramatic, choreographic/pantomimes, motion pictures, AV works)
106(5): Right to display work publicly (literary, musical, dramatic, choreographic/pantomimes, pictorial / graphic / sculptural, individaul images of motion picture
106(6): Right to perform work publicly through digital audio transmission (sound recordings)
Kirtsaeng
- International Exhaustion
- Limits 602(a) using interpretation of 109(a); 109 taken to mean lawfully made under this title (if it hypothetically applied in the manufacturing country)
Exhaustion
1) Round-trip parallel importation: 602(a) limited by 109 [can’t block importation] Quality King
(US - India - US)
2) One-way parallel importation
- Omega: (c) owner may prevent resales of US products produced abroad
- Kirtsaeng: Overturns Omega
First Sale Doctrine
Nimmer Says:
a) Physical product lawfully manufactured /w (c) owner authorization
b) copy was transferred under (c) owner’s authority
c) D qualifies as lawful owner of that copy
d) D thereupon disposed of THAT copy
602(a)
Importation / exportation w/o authority of owner of (c) UNDER THIS TITLE of copies/phonorecords is an infringement of 106(3) right
Does not apply to: government importation, importation of 1 copy for personal use, scholarly/educational/religious importation for archival purposes (5 copies)
Distribution - 106(3)
Exclusive right to sell, give away, rent, lend, trasmit copies (import, and export) - 602(a)
17 USC 109
- Notwithstanding 106(3), owner of particular copy has authority to dispose of possession of that copy
- However, cannot rent/lease/lend particular copies of phonorecords or computer programs (does not apply to nonprofits/libraries; does not apply to computer program embedded in machine)
Circumstances in which difference in scope between 106(1) and 106(2) matter
Note: Derivative work requires modicum of creativity
1) Alteration of a lawfully obtained copy of a (c) work
- Framing - Not 106(1) violation, split on 106(2)
- Expurgation - 106(2) but not 106(1)
2) Absence of Fixation
- Derivative work may be an infringement even if never fixed
3) Statutory provisions may treat derivative works more favorably
- 104(a)(d)(3): reliance party may continue to exploit derivative work + royalty
Reproduction - 106(1)
Plaintiff Must Show:
1) Copying
Proof:
1. Direct Evidence 2. Access + Similarity 3. Striking Similarity 4. Common Errors
What counts as copying:
1) Mechanical Reproduction 2) Conscious or subconscious copying 3) Replicating work in different medium
2) What D created was a “copy”
1) Tangibility 2) Fixation 3) Intelligible
3) Improper appropriation
1) Comprehensive Copying 2) Fragmented literal similarity (of expression) 3) Comprehensive nonliteral similarity
Derivative work
17 USC 101
- Work based on one or more preexisting works such as translation / dramatization / movie version / art reproduction or ay other form in which a work may be a) recast b) transformed or c) adapted
- Editorial revisions / annotations / elaborations: derivative work
Exceptions to 106(1)
- Essential First Step
- Fair use
Comprehensive Nonliteral Similarity
Methods
- Totality Analysis - More discerning Observer - Filtration
Formulations
- Same aesthetic appeal - Apparent Appropriation (avg layperson) - Total concept and feel - Extrinsic / Intrinsic test (objective / subjective)