General Flashcards
What is the typical content of a lease?
- Address
- Term length
- Rent charged and how it will be paid
- Permitted use
- Who is responsible for services and insurance, and any charged
- Alienation
- Yielding up
What elements of a lease impact value?
- Protection under the 1954 Act
- Lease length
- Repair and obligations
- Rent reviews
- Break options
- Alienation provisions
- User clause
What did you learn in the session on the treatment of rent free at renewal?
HPUT Trustee No.1 Limited and HPUT Trustee No.2 Limited v Boots UK Limited 2022
- County courts have ruled both ways about whether there should be a RF period for fit out at renewal
- This case ruled in favour of the reality that Boots did not need a fitting out period
Key case law for your area of practice?
- Calderbank v Calderbank 1976 - Established Calderbank officer
- O’May v City of London Real Property Co 1983 - s35 - new terms should be based on current terms at LR
- S Frances v Cavendish Hotel 2018 - Must have genuine intention to use ground f
What did Calderbank v Calderbank 1975 establish?
Established the Calderbank offer - Court of appeal held that Mr Calderbank should pay costs as he had prolonged legal proceedings by not accepting Mrs Calderbanks earlier offer.
What did O’May v City of London Real Property Co 1983 establish?
Guidance on s35-
- New terms should be based on previous terms
- The party proposing new terms is to justify them
- They must be reasonable
What did S Franses Ltd v The Cavendish Hotel (London) Ltd [2018] establish?
Ground f can’t be used just to get the tenant out, as this would undermine security of tenure, must genuinely have intention to undertake works.
What are typical assumptions and disregards at rent review?
Assumptions
- Willing LL & T in an open market transaction
- Vacant possession
- The premises are fit out and ready for occupation
- The premises can be used for the use stated in the lease
Disregards
- Tenants occupation
- Goodwill
- Licensed tenants improvement works
What does case law suggest if no hypothetical term is stated in the review clause?
Basingstoke & Deane Borough Council v Host Group 1977 suggests if no term is stated, assume the residual
What should a calderbank offer be marked with?
Without prejudice save as to costs
What must a calderbank offer not be marked with?
Without prejudice /subject to contract
How long is a calderbank normally open for?
21 days
How much to apply to RICS ADR?
£425
Key differences between an independent expert and arbitrator?
- Evidence - Arbitrator acts only on evidence and can order disclosure, IE makes own investigations and uses their own expertise but can’t order disclosure
- Appeal - Arbitrator can be appealed on a point of law or jurisdiction and can’t be sued for negligence, IE can’t be appealed but can be sued
- Governance - Arbitrator governed by the 1996 Arbitration Act, IE governed by the terms of the lease
- Outcome - Arbitrator award, IE determination
- Costs - Arbitrator has power over all costs, IE only has power over their own costs
How can a rent review be documented?
RRM, acceptance of a Calderbank or open letter, IE determination, arbitrators award
What does a RRM need to include?
- Name and address of the landlord and tenant
- The property
- Date of the lease and the rent review
- New rent
- Signature and date of both parties
What are 3rd party proceedings for LR?
County Court or PACT
What governs county court proceedings?
Civil Procedure Rules 1998
When would you use county court v PACT?
PACT for unopposed renewals, court otherwise
What is a part 36 offer?
Calderbank equivalent for LRs, open for 21 days after which it can be accepted or withdrawn
What is PACT?
Professional Arbitration Under Court Terms - alternative dispute resolution
When was PACT introduced?
1997
What are the advantages of PACT?
- Faster
- Avoids a full court hearing
- Greater flexibility and control
- Less expensive
- Decision by surveyor not a judge
What are the possible fee bases for L&T work?
% of new rent
% of saving from quoting rent
Fixed
Hourly
Incentive
What are the key differences between a lease and a licence?
- Lease is an interest in land, license is permission to make an act lawful
- Lease can be assigned, license is personal
- A lease can’t usually be revoked until break or expiry, licenses can usually be revoked at any time
Lease = exclusive occupation, fixed term of duration, consideration
What are the 4 requirements for a lease?
- Exclusive occupation
- Payment of rent
- Duration of a specified term
- If more than 3 years, needs to be in writing and as a deed
What was the key case in lease v licence and what was the outcome?
Street v Mountford 1985
What is a tenancy at will?
Form of licence, allows occupation for an unspecified period of time during which landlord can evict at any time
Used for allowing a tenant early entry to fit out or whilst agreeing a new contracted out tenancy.
What is wayleave?
Temporary right receiving annual payment
Personal, can’t be automatically transferred
Not compulsorily registered
When might you use a tenancy at will?
Used for allowing a tenant early entry to fit out or whilst agreeing a new contracted out tenancy.