Gender Flashcards
Sex
Biological and assigned at birth
Gender
The psychological distinction between masculine and feminine behaviours
Sex Role Stereotypes
The expectations of male and female behaviours shared by a culture
Androgyny
Having high levels of both masculine and feminine traits
What did the BSRI do
Undergraduate ppts completed a questionnaire with 60 traits in which they ranked themselves from 1-7.
20 masc traits
20 fem traits
20 neutral traits
What did Bem argue about androgyny
Androgynous people are the most psychologically healthy
What did the BSRI show
Most males showed masc traits and most females showed fem traits, showing that the traits are distinct.
What did Bem originally not include
She didn’t include a category for people with both low masc and fem traits, but she later added the ‘undifferentiated’ category for people like that.
Contradicting research for Bem - Adams and Sherer
- Gave 101 undergrad students the BSRI to complete
- Found that both masculine men and masculine women were better adjusted in terms of assertiveness, which contradicts Bem’s theory that androgynous people are the best adjusted/most psychologically healthy.
However… (Adams and Sherer)
This could be explained by the fact that we live in a male dominated society, and traits like assertiveness are prioritised.
- perhaps in an equal society, androgynous people would truly be the most psychologically healthy.
Strengths of the BSRI
- high test-retest reliability
- quantitative data (can do a statistical analysis and created nomothetic laws)
Weaknesses of the BSRI
- low temporal validity (outdated traits for women like childlike/gullible)
- reductionist (simplifies something complex like gender to an objective questionnaire)
- low population validity (only Western undergraduate students - low generalisability)
- social desirability bias (self-report questionnaire)
- the adjectives used on the BSRI are socially desirable, so someone who is very confident would end up scoring highly on both masculine and feminine traits
- therefore, the BSRI could rather be considered a measure of self-confidence rather than one of gender
Supporting research for Sex Role Stereotypes - Smith and Lloyd
- recorded 32 new mothers playing with a strangers 6 month old baby
- a selection of fem, masc, and neutral toys for the mother to select
- they dressed the baby in either masc or fem clothes
- when the baby was dressed in masculine clothes, it was offered a toy hammer and encouraged to play more physcially.
- this shows that adults have sex role stereotypes ingrained into them
Contradicting research for Sex Role Stereotypes - Mead
- She examined three different tribes and found the Arapesh men and women to be gentle, responsive and cooperative; the Mundugumor men and women were violent and aggressive, seeking power and position; and the Tchambuli showed the opposite gender-role behaviours to those seen in most cultures, as the women were dominant, impersonal and managerial and the men were more emotionally dependent
- this shows that cultural forces are responsible for gender stereotypes, and that gender behaviour is learned through socialisation rather than being innate
Supporting research for BSRI - Burchardt and Serbin (psychiatric impatients)
- compared the BSRI results of 190 male and female undergrads to 96 male and female psychiatric inpatients
- found that the androgynous females scored significantly lower for depression and social introversion than the feminine females
Chromosomes, genotypes, and phenotypes
- typically, we have 46 chromsomes (23 pairs)
- chromosomes carry the genetic information (genotype) that codes for the physical manifestation (phenotype)
Chromosomes role in sex
- sex is determined by the 23rd chromosome pair
- XX female
- XY male
Atypical sex chromosome patterns - Klinefelter syndrome
- 47 chromosomes, XXY
- leads to tall stature, narrow shoulders, breast tissue, small testes, and infertility in men
- occurs between 1 in 500 and 1 in 1000 males
- their testes produce insufficient amounts of testosterone before birth and during puberty
- psychologically, it leads to shyness, being emotional, low libido, and problems with executive function (memory, problems solving)
Klinefelter’s syndrome as evidence for chromosomes influence on gender (strength)
- klinefelter’s syndrome serves as evidence that chromosomes play an important role in gender development
- typical female characteristics are shown in biological males (breast tissue, wide hips)
- studying atypical chromosomal patterns helps psychologists make inferences about chromosomes and their role in the development in gender
Limitation of Klinefelter’s syndrome as support for chromosomes role in gender development
- this biological explanation is reductionist as it ignores other factors that could impact the development of gender identity, like their culture/social interactions
Atypical sex chromosome patterns - Turners Syndrome
- occurs when women only have 1 X chromosome (XO combination)
- affects 1 in 2000 females
- non-functioning ovaries that lead to a lack of oestrogen
- physcially, leads to brown spots on the body, short stature, and a short, webbed neck
- otherwise leads to a higher-than-average reading ability, social immaturity, and poor performance on spatial, visual memory, and maths ability
Weakness of studying people with atypical sex chromosome patterns
- there is a large variation between traits of people with turners/klinefelters syndrome.
- not all people w/ the syndrome have the same psychological/physiological traits
- this means that general laws are difficult to establish as they do not account for individual differences.
- however, in some cases there is only a small sample to establish laws
- even though there may be differences between people with the syndrome, in comparison to the typical person they are very different
- therefore comparisons can be made and we can make establishments about atypical sex chromosomes.