Gender Flashcards
Sex
The biological differences between males and females including chromosomes, hormones and anatomy - Innate and cannot be assigned
Gender
The psychological, social and cultural differences between men/boys and women/girls including attitudes, behaviours and social roles - Partly nurture , assigned so can be fluid (open to masculinity/ femininity
Gender dysphoria
People who do not have correspondence between sex and gender identity
Sex role stereotype
A set of beliefs and preconceived ideas about what is expected or appropriate for men and women in a given society or social group.
- Reinforced by peers, parents, media or school
-Can lead to sexist assumptions
Androgyny
Displaying a balance of masculine and feminine characteristics in one’s personality. High A = High psychological well being
Bem Sex role Inventory
The first systematic attempt to measure androgyny using a rating scale of 60 traits (20 M, 20 F, 20 A)
Rated 1-7
Bem Sex role inventory Strength 1
Measured quantitatively, useful for research purposes when it is necessary e.g to quantify a dependent variable
Bem Sex role inventory Strength 1 Counter
Spence argues qualitative data is better to analyse gender, and to rather combine different scales e.g Personal attribute questionnaire.
This suggests both qualitative and quantitative approaches are useful to study different aspects of androgyny
BSRI Strength 2
Valid and Reliable
Scale developed by asking 50 male and 50 female judges to scale 200 traits on their masculinity/ femininity
- 20 Highest traits became part of the scale
- BSRI then piloted with 1000 people and results corresponded with their own gender identity (validity)
- Follow up study of smaller sample of same people produced similar scores a month later - Test - retest reliability
Valid and reliability
BSRI Strength 2 counter
- 40 Years old , outdated notions of gender, Devised all from U.S.
Lacks temporal validity, and generalisation, not suitable measure of gender identity today
BSRI Limitation
- People may not have insight into their degree of masculinity, femininity or androgyny
- Questionnaire relies on understanding
- Gender is a social construct , open to interpretation, subjective
- Thus, not objective or scientific way to measure gender
Bem’s assumption on androgyny
They are more psychologically healthy as they are best placed in situations to deal with situations that demand a masculine, feminine or androgynous response. - But Some researcher’s argue masculine is more better adjusted as it is highly valued in Western culture
The role of chromosomes
Found in the nucleus of living cells and carrying information in the form of genes. The 23rd pair of chromosomes determine biological sex
The role of hormones
A biochemical substance that circulates in the blood but only affects target organs . Act upon brain development, and and cause development of reproductive organs. Male development = Androgen e.g Testosterone
Testosterone
Produced mainly in male testes and lightly in female ovaries. Associated with aggressiveness.
Oestrogen
Primary female hormone that produces female sexual characteristics and mensuration. PMS = Irritability and medical category
Oxytocin
Women produce more, especially after giving birth. Stimulates lactation (breastmilk), Reduces stress hormone of cortisol and makes mother connect with baby. Men producing less induces stereotype that men are less interested in intimacy even though studies find the same amount during amorous activities
Strength for hormones
Evidence for testosterone
- Wang gave 227 hypogonadal men testosterone therapy for 180 days.
- Improved sexual function, libido, mood and muscle growth observed
- Shows a direct influence testosterone has on male sexual arousal, aswell as physical development in adulthood
Counter for hormones (Testosterone)
O’Connor conducted a double blind study and increased testosterone in healthy young men.
- No increases in the interactional or non interactional components of sexual behaviour in participants
- No change in anger or aggression
- This suggests that additional testosterone may not have any effects on sexual or aggressive behaviour
Weakness for biological accounts ( Chromosomes and hormones)
Social factors ignored
- Hofstede claims gender roles are a consequence of social norms than biology
- Based on whether cultures are individualist or collectivist
- Individualist - more masculine e.g capitalist societies e.g US & UK
- Thus, masculine traits are more valued
- This challenges biological explanations of gender behaviour and suggests social factors are more important in shaping gender behaviour and attitudes
Weakness of biological accounts (Chromosones & Hormones) 2
Reductionist
- Do not account for alternative explanations
- E.g Cognitive approach for schema
-E.g Psychodynamic approach for importance of childhood experiences such as interactions within the family
-This suggests that gender is more complex than biological factors alone
The role of chromosomes and hormones Apply it
The case of David Reimer - Bruce! and Brian. Enforced by John Money
Examples of Atypical sex chromosome patterns
Klinefelter’s syndrome & Turner’s syndrome
Physical characteristics of Klinefelter’s syndrome
- XXY
- Reduced body hair, breast development (gynaecomastia) , softening/ rounding of the body,
- Long gangly limbs, small infertile testes, problems with coordination and clumsiness
Psychological characteristics of Klinefelter’s syndrome
- Poorly developed language skills and reading ability
- Passive, shy and lack interest in sexual activity
- May not respond well to stressful situations and struggle with memory and problem solving
Physical characteristics of Turner’s syndrome
- XO
- Only 45 chromosomes
-Do not have a menstrual cycle (amenorrhoe) - Ovaries fail to develop, thus sterile
- Broad ‘shield’ chest
- Low set ears and a ‘webbed neck’
- High waist to hip ratio
- Physically immature ( appearance of prepubescent girls )
Psychological characteristics of Turner’s syndrome
- Higher than average reading ability
- But less spatial, visual memory and mathematics
- Socially immature , cannot relate to family and peers
Strength of atypical sex chromosome conditions
- Contribution to nature-nurture debate
- By comparing to chromosome typical individuals, can see psychological and behavioural differences (e.g higher verbal ability to normal girls)
-Supports the view that innate ‘nature’ influences’ have a powerful influence on psychology and behaviour