GA Essays – Professional Ethics Flashcards
What entity governs the admission to practice law in Georgia?
The Practice of Law
Admission to practice law in GA is governed by the Supreme Court of GA.
What are the requirements for admission to practice law?
The Practice of Law
“SEC” – Requirements include: (1) School - must graduate from an ABA accredited law school; (2) Exam - must pass the bar exam/attorney exam; and (3) Character - Must receive a certification of character and fitness.
Some behavior is prohibited during the application process to practice law; what are the three things applicants are prohibited from doing?
The Practice of Law
(1) An applicant may not knowingly make a false statement in connection with the application.
(2) An applicant may not fail to disclose a fact necessary to correct a misapprehension known to have arisen in the matter.
(3) An applicant may not fail to respond to a lawful demand by an admissions authority in connection with the application (unless the fact is protected by the rules governing confidential communications).
When is a lawyer subject to discipline for the unauthorized practice of law in a jurisdiction where the lawyer is not licensed?
The Practice of Law
In GA, a lawyer is subject to discipline for practicing law in another state where doing so violates the regulation of the legal profession in that state.
- A GA lawyer that is practicing in a state where the lawyer is not licensed to practice may face sanctions under the state where she is not licensed to practice and professional discipline in GA.
- A lawyer licensed to practice in a different state that is not licensed to practice in GA cannot establish an office or other systematic and continuous presence in GA for the purpose of practicing law.
- A lawyer licensed to practice in a different state that is not licensed to practice in GA cannot hold out to the public that the lawyer is admitted to practice in GA.
Exceptions: An out-of-state lawyer can practice when:
* (1) An out-of-state lawyer has received temporary (pro hac vice) admission; OR
* (2) An out-of-state lawyer is associated with a lawyer who actively participates in the matter.
When is a lawyer subject to discipline for assisting non-lawyers in the unauthorized practice of law?
The Practice of Law
- In Georgia, a lawyer cannot assist a person who is not admitted in the state in the unauthorized practice of law.
- In GA, a lawyer who does assist a nonlawyer in the unauthorized practice of law is subject to (1) civil penalties; (2) Criminal Penalties; (3) Professional Discipline.
When does violating the GA Professional Ethics Rules constitute professional misconduct?
The Practice of Law
Rule Violations: It constitutes professional misconduct to violate or attempt to violate any of the GA rules, OR to knowingly assist or induce another to violate the rules.
What do the GA rules say about a lawyer who commits a felony, and what is that lawyer required to do upon conviction?
The Practice of Law
It is professional misconduct for a lawyer to be convicted of a felony. In GA, a lawyer convicted of a felony has an affirmative duty to inform the State Bar of the felony conviction.
What do the GA rules say about a lawyer who commits a misdemeanor, and what is the lawyer required to do upon conviction?
The Practice of Law
It is professional misconduct for a lawyer to be convicted of a misdemeanor involving moral turpitude, when the underlying conduct relates to the lawyer’s fitness to practice law.
In GA, a lawyer convicted of such a misdemeanor has an affirmative duty to inform the State Bar of the conviction.
What do the GA rules say about a lawyer who commits a criminal act?
The Practice of Law
In GA, it is professional misconduct to commit any criminal act (conviction is not necessary) that relates to the lawyer’s fitness to practice law or reflects adversely on the lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer, provided the lawyer has admitted to the act in court.
What are acts of sleaziness that a lawyer is subject to discipline for in GA?
The Practice of Law
Aside from Felony, Misdemeanor of Moral Turpitude, or Criminal Acts
In GA, a lawyer is subject to discipline for:
*Engaging in professional conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation.
*Failing to pay a final judgment for money collected as a lawyer within 10 days after the time appointed in the order.
*Stating or implying an ability to influence improperly a government agency or official.
*Stating an ability to achieve results by means that violate the GA rules.
*Achieving results by means that violate the GA Rules or other law.
*Knowingly assisting a judge or judicial officer in conduct that is a violation of the applicable Rules of Judicial Conduct or other law.
When is a GA lawyer subject to discipline for another lawyer’s conduct?
The Practice of Law
A lawyer is subject to discipline for another lawyer’s conduct if the lawyer:
* (1) ordered the misconduct;
* (2) ratified the misconduct with knowledge of the specific misconduct;
* (3) is a partner or manager in a law firm who knows of the misconduct of another lawyer over whom the lawyer has direct supervisory authority, at a time when the consequences could be avoided or mitigated but the lawyer fails to take reasonable remedial actions.
When is a GA lawyer subject to discipline for a non-lawyer employee’s conduct?
The Practice of Law
A lawyer with direct supervisory authority over a non-lawyer must make reasonable efforts to ensure non-lawyer’s conduct is compatible with the lawyer’s professional obligations.
What are the duties of a subordinate lawyer to avoid being subject to discipline for misconduct?
The Practice of Law
- When a subordinate lawyer’s duty is clear, the subordinate lawyer must conform to the Rules even if the supervisory lawyer directs otherwise.
- When a subordinate lawyer’s duty is arguable, the subordinate lawyer will not face discipline if the subordinate acts in accordance with the supervisors reasonable resolution of the issue, even if it turns out that the supervisor’s interpretation is incorrect.
Is a GA lawyer subject to discipline only for misconduct that occurs in GA?
The Practice of Law
No. A lawyer admitted in GA is subject to discipline for misconduct that occurs anywhere.
When should a GA lawyer inform the appropriate professional authority that another lawyer has violated the GA rules?
The Practice of Law
In GA, if a lawyer
- knows that another lawyer has violated the GA rules and
- that conduct raises a substantial question as to that lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness or fitness as a lawyer,
- the lawyer who knows of the misconduct should inform the appropriate professional authority
- but is NOT obligated to do so and is not subject to professional discipline for failing to do so.
Note that the Model Rules are stricter than GA
What are the GA rules for sharing fees?
The Practice of Law
Answer includes Division within law firm and Fees with Nonlawyers
- Division of fees within a law firm is permissble.
- A lawyer may not share fees with a nonlawyer and cannot form a partnership or professional corporation with a nonlawyer.
- A nonlawyer cannot hold an ownership interest in a law firm.
- A nonlawyer cannot serve as manager or director of a law firm.
What requirements must a lawyer fulfull in the purchase or sale of a law practice.
The Practice of Law
In the purchase or sale of a law practice, a lawyer must provide written notice to clients doing the following:
* Obtain Consent from the client (which may be presumed if the client does not object within 90 days of receiving notice)
* Acknowledging Existence of the proposed sale
* Informing clients of their Right to retain other counsel
* Including Terms of any proposed changes to the fee arrangement and
* Sale of the firm.
What restrictions on practice (non-compete agreements) are a GA lawyer prohibited from agreeing to?
The Practice of Law
A GA lawyer may not:
* Be a party to an agreement that restricts the ability to practice after leaving a firm, OR
* Agree not to represent others in connection with settling a claim on behalf of a client.
What is the process/procedure for enforcing professional discipline on a lawyer.
The Practice of Law (Cats Go In For Supper)
- Complaint – is typically filed by the client, but sometimes filed by another attorney
- Grievance Counsel - complaint first goes to a grievance counsel, which decides whether to dismiss the complaint or whether to refer it for futher review
- Investigative Panel - decides what preliminary discipline to recommend, and whether to refer the matter for further review.
- Formal Complaint Process - In the formal complaint process, a special master conducts a hearing, considers evidence, and prepares a report for the review panel
- Supreme Court of GA - imposes the final discipline, if any, that will be conferred.
“Cats (Complaint) Go (Grievance Counsel) In (Investigative Panel) For (Formal Complaint Process) Supper (Supreme Court)”
Under what laws (theories) can a lawyer be sued for malpractice?
The Practice of Law
Malpractice theories include (1) Breach of contract, (2) Intentional Tort; and (3) Negligence.
Whar are the negligence elements in an action for lawyer malpractice?
The Practice of Law
Negligence elements in a malpractice action include:
* (1) Duty - a GA attorney has the duty to exercise competence and diligence of lawyers
* (2) Breach - GA requires a complaint for malpractice to be accompanied by an expert affidavit that states at least one act of negligence that occurred under the facts as alleged in the complaint
* (3) Causation - Plaintiff must show that but for the lawyer’s breach, the injury would not have occurred
* Harm - Plaintiff must show actual damages, and may not bring a malpractice claim while the underlying matter is still pending.
Is a lawyer required to accept the representation of a client?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
A lawyer does not have a duty to accept representation of any client, but a lawyer may avoid a court appointment only when there is good cause:
* The lawyer is not competent
* The representation would result in a conflict of interest with another client or a former client
* Acceptance would be unreasonably burdensome to the lawyer.
When does a GA lawyer have a duty to reject representation of a client?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
A GA lawyer has a duty to reject representation of a client if it would:
* (1) result in violation of the GA rules or other law, OR
* (2) when the lawyer’s physical or mental condition materially impairs the lawyer’s ability to do the work.
When does the attorney-client relationship begin?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
The attorney-client relationship begins when the client reasonably believes the relationship exists.
When is a statement made by a GA lawyer (in an advertisement) misleading?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
A lawyer cannot make false or misleading statements about the lawyer or the services. The GA rules specifically provide that a statement is misleading if it:
* (1) contains a material misrepresentation of fact or law or omits a fact necessary to make the statement considered as a whole not materially misleading;
* (2) is likely to create an unjustified expectation about the results the lawyer can achieve;
* (3) compares the lawyer’s services with other lawyer’s services unless the comparison can be factually substantiated
* (4) Fails to include the name of at least one lawyer responsible for its content;
* (5) Contains any information regarding contingent fees without a conspicuous disclaimer that they are not always permitted and that court costs and other expenses of legal action usually must be paid by the client; OR
* (6) contains the language “no fee unless you win or collect” or any similar phrase without an explanatory disclaimer.
Can a GA lawyer hold herself out as a specialist or say that her practice is limited to a particular field?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
A lawyer can say that his or her practice is limited to a particular field, and can hold himself or herself out as a specialist through experience, specialized training or education, or certification by a recognized and bonafide professional entity.
What information is required to be disclosed on all advertisements directed to potential GA clients?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
An advertisement must include:
* Name, Address, and Phone number of each lawyer or firm paying for the ad;
* That lawyer will Refer the matter to other attorneys (if applicable);
* Use of any Non-lawyer spokesperson, portrayl of lawyer or client by an Actor; or Paid testimonial or endorsement;
* Label of “Advertisement” if it resembles a pleading, notice, or other legal document
Think NAP-R; NAP-L
How many years must a GA lawyer retain a copy of their advertisements?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
A GA lawyer must retain a copy of all advertisements for 2 years from the date of the last dissemination.
For firm names, a firm name must NOT be…
Ethical Issues in Client Development
Misleading
When is a trade name allowed as a firm name?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
A trade name is allowed so long as it:
* (1) does not imply a connection with a government agency or a public or charitable legal services organization;
* (2) includes the name of at least one lawyer practicing under the firm name; and
* (3) otherwise complies with the rules regarding lawyer advertising.
When can the name of a lawyer holding public office not be used in a firm name?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
The name of a lawyer holding public office shall not be used in the name of the firm during any substantial period in which that lawyer is not actively participating in the firm.
What is the general rule for a lawyer regarding soliciting employment from a non-lawyer?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
A lawyer cannot solicit professional employment through direct personal contact or live telephone contact with any nonlawyer.
A GA lawyer is allowed to provide written communications to prospective clients UNLESS…
Ethical Issues in Client Development
Written communications to prospective clients unless:
* The lawyer knows the person does not want to receive communications;
* Communication involves coercion, duress, fraud, overreaching, harassment, intimidation, or undue influence
* Communication relates to personal injury or wrongful death actions (or otherwise relates to an accident or disaster involving the recipient or a relative) within 30 days of the occurrence;
* The lawyer knows or should know that the recipient’s physical, emotional, or mental state is such that he or she cannot exercise reasonale judgment in hiring a lawyer.
* Any written communication to a prospectice client who is not a close friend, a relative, or a former client, must be marked “Advertisement” if it is for the purpose of obtaining professional employment.
What factors are considered to determine whether a lawyer’s fee meets the Reasonable requiremet?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
A lawyer’s fee must be reasonable. Factors to consider include:
* Preclusion from other employment
* Expertise
* Time and labor
* Customary fee in the community
* Amount sought
* Results obtained
* Difficulty of the case
* Skill that is required
Think “PET CARDS”
When are contingent fee arrangements NOT allowed?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
Contingent fee arrangements are not allowed in:
1. Domestic Relations cases in which the fee is contingent on obtaining a divorce OR on recovering an amount of support (e.g., spousal, alimony)
2. The representation of a defendant in a criminal case.
In a contingent fee arrangement, what is required?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
Contingent fee arrangements must be
* (1) in writing and
* (2) must include explanation of the basis for computing the fee, whether and which costs will be deducted from the recovery, and whether such costs will be deducted before or after computation of the contingent fee.
The lawyer must also furnish a written statement explaining the outcomeof the matter;
* if there is a recovery, the statement must explain the amount payable to the client and how it was computated.
Can lawyers in the same firm share fees?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
Lawyers in the same firm may share fees freely.
When can lawyers from different firms share fees?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
When lawyers from different firms share fees, there are three requirements:
* (1) Either the proposed fee split is proportionate to the services rendered by each lawyer or (with client consent) the lawyers assumed joint responsibility for the matter
* (2) The client is advised of the proposed fee split and does not object; and
* the total fee charged must be reasonable
Are referral fees allowed?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
Referral fees are not allowed, except a lawyer can pay charges fom a bar-operated lawyer referral service.
Who does a retainer amount belong to and where must they be placed?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
Retainers belong to the client and must be placed in a client trust account that is separate from all other monies and either pays interest to the client or is structures as an IOLTA (interest on lawyer trust account) operated by state courts or state bar.
Lawyers who commingle funds with business accounts or who borrow or withdraw from a trust account will be subject to discipline.
* When can a lawyer’s funds enter the client trust account and when can a lawyer withdraw funds from the client trust account for deposit in the lawyer’s own account?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
- No funds belonging to a lawyer can be placed in a client trust account except amounts used to pay bank charges.
- A lawyer must withdraw funds from an account once they undisputabely belong to the lawyer; otherwise, disputed funds must remain in the account until resolution.
When is a lawyer required to mitigate any adverse impact on a client?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
Regardless of whether termination is voluntary or required, a lawyer has a duty to mitigate any adverse impact on a client.
A GA lawyer must withdraw from representing a client when:
* (1) Violation of the GA rules would result from the representation;
* (2) Attorney’s health materially impairs the attorney’s ability to represent;
* (3) Client discharged the lawyer, unless ordered by the court to continue representation
Think: “VAC”
When do the GA rules require a lawyer’s permissive withdrawal from a case?
Ethical Issues in Client Development
A GA lawyer may withdraw from representing a client when:
* (1) Criminal or fraudulent course of action insisted on by the client;
* (2) Repugnant or imprudent course of action insisted on by the client;
* (3) Other good cause exists;
* (4) Unreasonable burden to the lawyer (financial or difficulty)
* (5) Client fails to perform an obligation despite reasonable warning from the lawyer
* (6) Harmless to client;
* (7) Services used by client to perpretrate crime or fraud
Think: “CROUCH-S”