Full Set Flashcards
Equitable relief can only occur when …
a legal ($) remedy would be inadequate or unavailable
Measuring inadequate or unavailable legal remedy
- $ insufficient to fully compensate for irreparable harm
- $ uncertain or highly speculative
- unique subject matter
- D is insolvent
- compensation would require successive lawsuits
- willful or ongoing
characteristics of equitable relief
personal
enforceable
discretionary
coercive
temporary injunctions are __
almost always prohibitory
extraordinary
saving something before it can be heard on the merits
4 required elements P must prove for preliminary injunction
- possession of clearly ascertainable right needing protection
- will likely suffer irreparable harm w/o
- no adequate remedy at law
- likely to successful on merits
balancing test benefit/burden (balance of hardships)
there must also being a hearing for D to be heard
review of preliminary injunctions
will only reverse if against the manifest weight of the evidence
Temporary injunctive relief
used to preserve status quo while court hears evidence whether there should be a preliminary injunction - can be done ex parte
same 4 elements, same discretion, same SoR (manifest weight)
- possession of clearly ascertainable right needing protection
- will likely suffer irreparable harm w/o
- no adequate remedy at law
- likely to successful on merits
bond
the seeking party for a preliminary injunction or a TRO usu has to post bond
D rights in TRO
can appear on 2 days’ notice to move for dissolution of order
permanent injunction elements
no inherent time limit
- possession of clearly ascertainable right needing protection
- will likely suffer irreparable harm w/o
- no adequate remedy at law
immediate or likely future injury
can seek injunctions if injury is LIKELY to occur from activity
definition of likely success on the merits?
P need only show that he has raised a fair question about the existence of his right and that the court should preserve the right until the cause can be decided on the merits
IL framing requirements
- TROs must set forth specific reasons & describe acts with reasonable detail
- reasonable and should go no further than is necessary
scope of those bound
only upon parties, their agents, employees & attorneys & those working with them who receive ACTUAL notice
equitable remedy to trespass of land
available if continuous or ongoing
nuisance
act by D that interferes with P’s use & enjoyment of land
private nuisance
intereferes w/ specific O’s use & enjoyment
public nuisance
interferes with range of people’s use & enjoyment, right in common w/ public at large
inj not typically available unless P shows special, unshared harm
intentional encroachment
usu get inj
unintentional encroachment
usu get $ damages
abuse of process
harassing litigation, can’t enjoin out of state court
business, commercial & IP interests getting inj relief
- interference w/ contracts/business relationships
- unfair competition
- trade libel
- trade secrets
- trademarks
- copyright
- right to publicity
- patents
requirements for specific performance in contracts cases
- valid contract (VERY specific terms)
- inadequacy of legal remedies
- enforcement is fair & feasible
- mutuality of performance
- absence of defenses