FRAUD RISK ASSESSMENT Flashcards
factors that influence how at risk an organisation is to fraud
- The business it is in
- The environment in which it operates
- The effectiveness of the internal controls within the business processes
- The ethics and values of the company and the people within it
Fraud Risk Assessment
a process aimed at proactively identifying and addressing an organisation’s vulnerabilities to internal and external fraud
Objective of a Fraud Risk Assessment
the objective of a fraud risk assessment is to help an organisation identify what makes it most vulnerable to fraud
Why Should Organisations Conduct Fraud Risk Assessments?
Improve Communication and Awareness About Fraud
Identify What Activities Are the Most Vulnerable to Fraud
Know Who Puts the Organisation at the Greatest Risk
Develop Plans to Mitigate Fraud Risk
Develop Techniques to Determine If Fraud Has Occurred in High-Risk Areas
What Makes a Good Fraud Risk Assessment?
A good fraud risk assessment is one that fits within the culture of the organisation, is
sponsored and supported by the right people, encourages everyone to be open in his participation, and is generally embraced throughout the business as an important and valuable process.
Engendered Trust
If the organisation and its employees do not trust the people leading and conducting the
fraud risk assessment, they will not be open and honest about the realities of the business, its culture, and its vulnerability to fraud.
The Ability to Think the Unthinkable
A good fraud risk assessment has to allow for the people leading and conducting
the assessment to be expansive in their consideration and evaluation of fraud risk
A Plan to Keep It Alive and Relevant
The organisation should strive to keep
the process alive and relevant through ongoing dialogue, active management of action plans, and development of procedures to ensure the assessment is maintained on a current basis.
Considerations for Developing an Effective Fraud Risk Assessment
Packaging It Right
One Size Does Not Fit All
Keeping It Simple
The goals of the preparation the Company for a Fraud Risk Assessment should be to:
- Assemble the right team to lead and conduct the fraud risk assessment.
- Determine the best techniques to use in conducting the fraud risk assessment.
- Obtain the sponsor’s agreement on the work to be performed.
- Educate the organisation and openly promote the process.
Techniques to Use to Conduct the Fraud Risk Assessment. Interviews
Interviews can be an effective way to conduct a candid one-on-one conversation
Techniques to Use to Conduct the Fraud Risk Assessment. Focus Groups
Focus groups enable the assessor to observe the interactions of employees as they discuss a question or issue.
Techniques to Use to Conduct the Fraud Risk Assessment. Surveys
Surveys can be anonymous or directly attributable to individuals. Sometimes people will share more openly when they feel protected behind a computer or paper questionnaire.
Techniques to Use to Conduct the Fraud Risk Assessment. Anonymous Feedback Mechanisms
In some organisations, anonymous suggestion boxes or similar mechanisms are used to encourage and solicit frequent employee feedback. Additionally, use
of an anonymous feedback mechanism can also be effective in an environment where people are less likely to be open and honest through other methods and techniques.
Obtain the Sponsor’s Agreement on the Work to be Performed
Before the fraud risk assessment procedures begin, the sponsor and the fraud risk assessment team need to agree on:
• The scope of work that will be performed
• The methods that will be used to conduct the work (e.g., surveys, interviews, focus
groups, anonymous feedback mechanisms)
• The individuals who will participate in the chosen methods
• The content of the chosen methods
• The form of output for the assessment
Educate the Organisation and Openly Promote the Process
The fraud risk assessment process should be visible and communicated throughout the business.
Sample Fraud Risk Assessment Framework #1
- Identify potential inherent fraud risks.
- Assess the likelihood of occurrence of the identified fraud risks.
- Assess the significance to the organisation of the fraud risks.
- Evaluate which people and departments are most likely to commit fraud and identify the methods they are likely to use.
- Identify and map existing preventive and detective controls to the relevant fraud risks.
- Evaluate whether the identified controls are operating effectively and efficiently.
- Identify and evaluate residual fraud risks resulting from ineffective or nonexistent
controls.