FRAMING OF CHARGES Flashcards
What is the general rule regarding separate charges for distinct offenses?
According to Section 241(1), for every distinct offense a person is accused of, there shall be a separate charge, and each charge shall be tried separately.
Under what conditions can multiple charges be tried together?
Multiple charges can be tried together if the accused person requests it in writing, and the Magistrate believes that the accused is not likely to be prejudiced by such a joint trial.
How many offenses of the same kind can be charged and tried together within a 12-month period?
According to Section 242(1), up to five offenses of the same kind committed within a 12-month period can be charged and tried together.
What determines if offenses are considered “of the same kind” for the purpose of joint trials?
Section 242(2) states that offenses are of the same kind when they are punishable with the same amount of punishment under the same section of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 or any special or local law.
In what scenario can a person be charged with multiple offenses in one trial, even if they are not of the same kind?
According to Section 243(1), if multiple offenses are committed by the same person in one series of acts connected to form the same transaction, they can be charged and tried together in one trial.
How does the law treat attempts to commit an offense in relation to the offense itself?
The law considers an attempt to commit an offense to be “of the same kind” as the offense itself for the purposes of joint trials.
Under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, offences committed within ________ months from the first to the last of such offences can be charged together if they are of the same kind.
Twelve
According to the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, an attempt to commit an offence is deemed to be of the same kind as the actual offence when:
a) The attempt is punishable under the same section
b) The attempt is an offence itself
c) Both a and b
d) None of the above
b
According to the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, if multiple offences are committed by the same person in a series of acts connected together as to form the same transaction, how can they be charged and tried?
a) Separately for each offence
b) At one trial for every such offence
c) At different trials depending on the severity of each offence
d) Only for the most serious offence
b
Under which sections can a person be charged with and tried at one trial for offences of criminal breach of trust or dishonest misappropriation of property along with falsification of accounts?
a) Section 301 and Section 303
b) Section 235(2) and Section 242(1)
c) Section 101 and Section 103
d) Section 211 and Section 213
b
If the acts alleged constitute an offence falling within two or more separate definitions of any law in force, how can the person accused be charged and tried?
a) Only for the offence with the maximum punishment
b) At one trial for each of such offences
c) Separately for each definition
d) Only for the offence with the lesser punishment
Answer: b) At one trial for each of such offences
b
If several acts, when combined, constitute a different offence, how can the person accused be charged and tried according to the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023?
a) Only for the combined offence
b) Only for the most serious act
c) For the offence constituted by such acts when combined and for any offence constituted by any one or more of such acts
d) Separately for each act
c
True or False: A person can only be tried for one offence at a time, even if multiple offences were committed in the same transaction.
f
If a person commits an offence of falsification of accounts to conceal a criminal breach of trust, they can be tried for both offences at one trial.
t
True or False: If several acts that individually constitute offences are combined to form a different offence, the accused can only be charged with the combined offence.
f
True or False: The provisions of this section do not affect Section 12 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
t
Under what circumstances can a person be charged and tried at one trial for offences of criminal breach of trust along with falsification of accounts?
When a person charged with one or more offences of criminal breach of trust or dishonest misappropriation of property, as provided in Section 235(2) or Section 242(1), is accused of committing one or more offences of falsification of accounts to facilitate or conceal the commission of those offences, they may be charged and tried at one trial for every such offence.
What does the provision state about offences that fall under two or more separate legal definitions?
The provision states that if acts alleged constitute an offence falling within two or more separate definitions of any law, the person accused may be charged with and tried at one trial for each of such offences.
Under Section 244(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, if a single act or series of acts raises doubt about which offence it constitutes, how may the accused be charged?
a) With only one offence
b) With all or any of the possible offences
c) Only with the most serious offence
d) With no offence until clarity is achieved
b
If the accused is charged with one offence, but evidence shows they committed a different offence under the provisions of Section 244(1), what can happen according to Section 244(2)?
a) The accused must be acquitted
b) The trial must start over with the correct charge
c) The accused may be convicted of the offence shown by the evidence
d) The accused can only be convicted of the offence they were initially charged with
c
When an accused is charged in the alternative with having committed one of several offences under Section 244(1), how many of these charges may be tried at once?
a) Only one
b) All of them
c) Only two
d) None, they must be tried separately
b
According to Section 244(2), if the accused is shown by evidence to have committed a different offence from the one they were charged with, which of the following is true?
a) The accused cannot be convicted
b) The accused may be convicted of the offence shown by evidence
c) The accused can only be fined
d) The accused must be recharged with the correct offence
b
True or False: Under Section 244(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, if a single act raises doubt about which of several offences it constitutes, the accused can only be charged with the most likely offence.
f
True or False: If an accused is charged with one offence but the evidence shows they committed a different offence, the court can convict the accused of the different offence even if they were not originally charged with it.
t
True or False: Under Section 244, multiple charges for different offences arising from the same act cannot be tried at the same time.
f
What does Section 244(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 allow if it is unclear which offence a single act or series of acts constitutes?
Section 244(1) allows the accused to be charged with all or any of the possible offences, and any number of such charges may be tried at once, or the accused may be charged in the alternative with having committed one of the said offences.
What happens under Section 244(2) if evidence shows that the accused committed a different offence than the one they were charged with?
Under Section 244(2), the accused may be convicted of the offence which the evidence shows they committed, even if they were not originally charged with that specific offence.