Forming Conclusions & Reporting (10-20%) Flashcards
What are the Standards of Reporting?
GCDO (TIP, PIE, GCDO)
- GAAP: auditor states whether FS are in accordance with
- CONSISTENCY: auditor points out what GAAP principles have not been consistently applied in relation to prior period
- DISCLOSURES: if auditor determines disclosures in FS not adequate, auditor needs to say so in audit report
- OPINION: whole point of audit is for auditor to render their opinion - different types of opinions
How does auditor use & report on comparative FS with unaudited statements alongside audited statements?
unaudited statements should be clearly marked
either report on unaudited statements should be re-issued OR audited statements should contain a separate paragraph describing level of responsibility assumed for the unaudited statements
What are the types of opinions an auditor issues with an audit report?
- UNMODIFIED opinion - clean opinion (fairly stated & comply) free of any misrepresentations & in accordance with GAAP - also known as UNQUALIFIED opinion (for PCAOB public filers)
- MODIFIED opinion - something wrong with statements - 3 types:
- qualified
- adverse
- disclaimer of opinion
What is a qualified opinion (modified opinion)?
- presentation - FS misstated (GAAP departure) - no misrepresentation identified
- scope - unable to get sufficient appropriate audit evidence (not pervasive-not affecting multiple areas of FS - still fairly stated)
auditor is expressing reservations about FS
What is an adverse opinion (modified opinion)?
FS are both material & pervasive (affecting most areas of FS - not fairly presented) - does not confirm with GAAP
FS are misleading
What is a disclaimer of opinion (modified opinion)?
- scope - unable to get sufficient appropriate audit evidence & the effects could be both material & pervasive
auditor is unable to give an opinion
What are the key areas of an audit report for non-public companies and public companies?
- title
- addressee/to
- opinion paragraph (2 paragraphs)
- basis for opinion paragraph (1 paragraph)
- emphasis of matter/other matter paragraphs (if applicable)
- managements responsibility paragraph (2 paragraphs)
- auditors responsibility paragraph (3 paragraphs)
- signature of auditor
- auditors address
- date of auditors report
- only difference for public companies - report title, addressee, 3 paragraphs (opinion, basis for opinion, critical audit matters)
- audit conducted in accordance with PCAOB (Public Company Accounting Oversight Board)
What should be within the title, to, signature of auditor, auditors address & date of auditors report?
- title: labeled ‘Independent Auditor’s Report’ or ‘Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm’
- to: addressed to ‘Board of Directors’ of audit client or ‘Shareholders and the Board of Directors’
- signature of auditor: handwritten or printed signature
- auditors address: name the city/state where practitioner practices
- date of auditors report: dated no later than date on which auditor obtained sufficient appropriate evidence to based auditors opinion on FS
x
x
What should be within the Managements Responsibility paragraph of the auditors report?
2 paragraphs:
- heading labeled ‘Managements Responsibility for FS’
- describe managements responsibilities
- explanation that management is responsible for preparation & fair presentation of FS in accordance with applicable framework - includes design, implementation & maintenance of internal control relevant to of FS - that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error
What should be within the Auditors Responsibility paragraph of the auditors report?
3 paragraphs:
- heading labeled ‘Auditors Responsibility for the audit of the FS’
1) state objectives:
- obtain reasonable assurance FS free from material misstatement, issue report including opinion
- state reasonable assurance is high level but not absolute
- state risk of not detecting material misstatement or fraud is higher than error
- state misstatements considered material if, individually or in aggregate expected to influence users
2) in performing audit, responsibilities are to:
- exercise professional judgement and maintain professional skepticism
- identify/assess risks of material misstatement & design/perform procedures responsive to those risks
- obtain understanding of internal control, no opinion expressed on such
- evaluate appropriateness of accounting policies used and reasonableness of significant estimates, evaluate overall presentation of FS
- conclude whether concern for ability to continue as going concern
3) state required to communicate: planned scope, timing, significant audit findings, certain internal control related matters identified
What should be within the Opinion paragraph of the auditors report? What should be within the Basis for Opinion paragraph?
OPINION: (2 paragraphs)
- heading labeled ‘Opinion’
- identify specific FS audited
BASIS FOR OPINION: (1 paragraph)
- heading labeled ‘Basis for Opinion’
- state that audit was conducted in accordance with GAAS (Generally Accepted Auditing Standards) & should identify U.S. as country of origin of those standards
- refers to section of auditor’s report that further describes auditor’s responsibilities under GAAS
- states required to be independent
- states whether auditor believes audit evidence obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide basis for opinion
x
x
What is an ‘Emphasis of Matter’ paragraph?
auditor adds right after the opinion paragraph to point out a matter that is crucial to user being able to understand FS
required when:
- material change in accounting principles
- FS prepared using special purpose framework
- doubts in firms ability to continue as going concern (not req’d)
heading of ‘Emphasis of Matter’ must be used
can also be an ‘Other Matter’ paragraph - will go after the ‘Emphasis of Matter’ paragraph, if there is one - be about something auditor considers relevant, but not crucial to users understanding of FS
How should the auditor form an opinion on effectiveness of ICFR (Internal Control over Financial Reporting) by evaluating evidence obtained that is integrated with audit of FS?
- auditors testing of controls for the ICFR audit
- any additional tests of controls performed to achieve objective related to expression opinion
- misstatements detected during audit
- any identified deficiencies
- review reports issued during year by internal audit function that address controls
- evaluate effect of findings of substantive procedures performed
When evaluating the effect of findings of substantive procedures performed in the audit of FS on the effectiveness of ICFR (Internal Control over Financial Reporting), what should the evaluation include at a minimum?
- risk assessments in connection with selection/application of substantive procedures, especially those related to fraud
- findings with respect to noncompliance with laws/regulations
- findings with respect to related party transactions & complex/unusual transactions
- indications of management bias in making accounting estimates & selecting accounting principles
- nature/extent of misstatements detected by substantive procedures
When evaluating managements report on effectiveness of ICFR (Internal Control over Financial Reporting), what should the auditor make sure is included?
- statement regarding managements responsibility for ICFR
- description of subject matter of audit
- identification of criteria against which ICFR is measured
- managements assertion about ICFR
- description of material weaknesses, if any
- date of which managements assessment about ICFR is made
- if auditor determines any required element is incomplete or improperly presented, auditor should request management to revise report
What are the key areas of an audit report on the audit of ICFR (Internal Control over Financial Reporting)?
- title
- addressee/to
- opinion on FS & ICFR paragraph
- basis for opinions paragraph
- managements responsibility for FS & ICFR paragraph
- auditors responsibility for FS & ICFR paragraph
- definition & inherent limitations of ICFR paragraph
- signature
- city/state
- date
*report can be separate or combined with opinion on FS (if separate - will add an ‘other matter’ paragraph to both reports that references other report
What should be within the title, to, signature of auditor, auditors address & date of auditors report on audit of ICFR (Internal Control over Financial Reporting)?
- title: labeled ‘Independent Auditors Report’ or ‘Report of Independent Registered Audit Firm’
- to: addressed as ‘Board of Directors’ or ‘Shareholders and Board of Directors’
- signature of auditor: no heading, manual or printed signature
- city/state: no heading, city/state where practitioner practices
- date: no heading, date of auditors report
x
x
What should be within the Managements Responsibility for Internal Control over Financial Reporting paragraph of the auditors report on audit of ICFR?
- heading: labeled ‘Managements Responsibility for Internal Control over Financial Reporting’
- statement that management is responsible for designing, implementing & maintaining effective ICFR
- statement that management is responsible for its assessment about effectiveness of ICFR
- reference to managements report on ICFR