Formation, Offer, Acceptance, Consideration Flashcards
Determining if a contract is for a good or service
1) Language of K
2) Nature of Supplier’s business
3) Relative value of goods vs service
Even in a sale of goods, the common law will apply unless:
the UCC provides contrary provisions
Three categories of contractual obligations:
1) Express: oral or written agreements
2) Implied in fact: formed by the conduct, not by words
3) Implied in law: one party bestows a benefit on another and it is unjust for the beneficiary to retain it.
Quantum Meruit
Traditionally, a cause of action for the implied in fact contract to recover reasonable value of the benefit
Today: extended to implied in law contracts
When is a signed writing required?
1) Rules pertaining to merchant’s firm offers
2) Statute of Frauds requirement
3) Electronic contracts (electronic signatures are legally sufficient)
Two requirements for something to constitute an offer:
1) Outward manifestation (oral, written or made via conduct); and
2) Signal that acceptance will conclude the deal
Preliminary negotiations:
Generic term for the give and take during bargaining
Invitation for an offer:
Advanced stage. Closing in on a deal, but the party wants the other side to make an offer first.
Ex: “How much do you want to pay for these goods?”
Multiple offerees - Commercial ads:
Ads, catalogs and price lists are not offers but rather invitations for offers.
The exception is for ad language identifying a limited number.
Multiple offerees - Reward Offers:
1) Self-limiting (only paid once)
2) Open field (could be performed by many)
Exception - limiting how many can accept.
Multiple offerees - Auctions:
Auctioneer invites offers and bids are offers unless the auction is deemed “without reserve”
How to terminate power of acceptance - lapse of time:
Lapse of time occurs at the time stated or if not stated, within a reasonable time.
Reasonable time factors:
- subject matter and market conditions
- degree of urgency and means of transmission
Face to face conversation rule: generally lapses at end of conversation unless the offer states otherwise.
Termination of power of acceptance by death or incapacity
By the death or incapacity of either party.
Termination by offeror’s revocation
The American Rule of Free Revocability: an offeror may revoke at any time for any reason so long as:
1) revoked before offer accepted
2) revocation communicated (direct or indirect. Indirect = offeror takes some action inconsistent with intention to go through with the deal and the offeree learns of action through reasonable source).
Revocation of offer made to multiple offerees:
Functional Equivalents Rule:
- offeror revokes by communicating in a functionally equivalent way to the way that offer was made (exception: if better means could be used)
- Legal effect: terminates power of acceptance EVEN IF offeree unaware
Preventing revocation: Option Contracts
Common Law (Dickinson v. Dodds): Could revoke even if offer has been held open.
Today, prevent revocation with
1) Common law option contract:
- Offer; subsidiary promise to keep offer open; and some valid mechanism for enforcing the subsidiary promise
*Sell by date may just be a lapse date and not a promise to keep the offer open
Nuances of option contracts:
Signed writing with a false recital:
1) Majority rule: recital is rebuttable
2) Minority rule: option K will be enforced even if recital is false
3) Promissory estoppel: courts will sometimes enforce if there has been detrimental relaince
Construction contracts - General contractor’s reliance on a subcontractor’s bid:
If the General Contractor relies on a subcontractor’s bid to formulate his own, promissory estoppel applies to protect general contractor from subcontractor revoking
Preventing revocation with a firm offer under the UCC:
UCC 2-205
1) Offer to buy or sell made by merchant
2) Offer made in writing and signed
3) Offer expressly states it will be held open
Becomes irrevocable for the stated time or for a reasonable time.
Has a shelf life of 3 months. If the offer says it is open for 4 months, it is only irrevocable up to 3 months.
Revocation due to offeree’s rejection: terminates power of acceptance:
1) Outright rejection
2) Rejection via counteroffer
3) Rejection via non-conforming acceptance (mirror image rule - mirror the terms of the offer and any variation results in counteroffer and is a rejection)
A counteroffer is:
A rejection of the offer while creating a new offer.
Exception is Mere Inquiry: test the waters of a different price without rejecting)
Revival of offer after rejection or lapse:
By language or conduct restating offer or giving more time to decide
Unilateral vs bilateral contracts:
Unilateral K: I make a promise and seek from you only your performance in exchange. Offeror is bound only when offeree’s performance completed and offeree is not bound.
Bilateral K: I make a promise and seek from you a promise in exchange. Once promises are exchanged, both parties are bound.
Revocation of offer in a unilateral K:
Common Law: Offeror free to revoke up until moment offeree actually completed performance
Modern Law: Once offeree begins performance, offeror cannot revoke because an option contract has been created. (Courts split over this):
- Some courts say offeree is still free to abandon
- Some say acceptance still effective only on completion in accordance with the terms
In a unilateral contract, mere preparation:
does not constitute acceptance
Acceptance under common law:
Acceptance must mirror terms of offer
Must be communicated to offeror either by stipulated means of accepting or if silent, by any reasonable means
Three exceptions to acceptance being communicated:
1) Acceptance by silence
- Offeree takes benefit of offeror’s service w/ opportunity to reject and knows that
- Offeror has given offeree reason to know that acceptance may be communicated by silence
- Based on previous dealings
2) Unilateral K
3) Mailbox Rule
Mailbox Rule:
Common law: Acceptance by mail is effective on dispatch
-Applies only to acceptances
Consequences of the rule:
1) Offeror may not revoke once acceptance has been dispatched
2) Once offeree dispatches, acceptance is binding and offeree may not withdraw acceptance
3) Offeror bound, even if acceptance is lost (so long as properly addressed)
Nuances of Mailbox Rule:
1) Rule applies to any means of transmission that anticipates reasonable delay between dispatch and receipt
2) Mailbox rule is default unless offer says otherwise
3) Simultaneous dispatch of identical offers - not legally relevant, only effective to create through receipt
4) Mailbox Rule & Option K: Majority says mailbox rule doesn’t apply - only effective with receipt.
Mailbox Rule where both rejection and acceptance mailed:
MB Rule doesn’t govern if rejection is mailed first.
- If acceptance reaches offeror first, there is a contract.
- If rejection reaches offeror first - no contract, power of acceptance terminates
UCC - How might seller accept buyer’s offer (including by sending nonconforming goods)?
1) Promise to ship goods in conformity with the offer
2) Prompt or current shipment in conformity with the offer
3) Shipping non-conforming goods
- If an accommodation, just a counteroffer
- Absent accommodation language, it has the effect of both accepting the offer and forming a binding a contract AND breaching that contract (b/c not all the goods were shipped).
A contract is unenforceable unless supported by a promise, which has:
some value and must be exchanged for something else of value, such as counter promise or performance given to promisor by promisee as quid-pro-quo
A gratuitous promise:
is a promise to make a gift and lacks consideration.
Difference between “want of consideration” and “failure of consideration”
Want of consideration: Absence of a bargained-for exchange. Synonyms: lack of consideration; no consideration; not supported by consideration; insufficient consideration
Failure of consideration: Failure to perform (Breach of K)