Formation Flashcards
Key question in the formation of a K, in the course of the volley:
At what point do the parties have a legally enforceable K?
The manifestation of an offer can be:
oral
written
or
made via conduct
An offer is NOT about
Inward thoughts or subjective intentions - IRRELEVANT unless they are reasonably apparent to the other party.
Ex. a seemingly serious offer to sell a piece of property made secretly in jest will be an actual offer.
Preliminary negotiation
A generic term that applies to the give-and-take that occurs during bargaining. Does NOT constitute an offer
An invitation for an offer
Does not constitute an offer. An advanced state of preliminary negotiation, where the communicating party is closing in on a deal but wants the other party to commit first.
Self-limiting rewards
Reward offers that indicate the task to be rewarded can be performed only once.
Ex. “will pay $100 for finding my lost dog”
Open-field rewards
Reward offers that indicate the task to be performed can be performed by multiple parties (potentially)
Ex. Carbonic Smoke Ball case, where they promised to pay $100 to anyone who used their product and still got the flu.
EXCEPTION: language in the offer that specifies a limitation on how many can accept it.
General rule - auctions
The auctioneers are inviting offers, and the responsive bids are the offers
Exception to the general rule of auctions:
If the auction is held “without reserve”, then the auctioneer is making an offer to sell to the highest bidder.
For an offer to be terminated via revocation, the revocation must:
- occur prior to acceptance
AND - be effectively communicated.
An indirect revocation will terminate the offeree’s power of acceptance so long as:
- the offeror has taken definite action inconsistent with the intention to enter the proposed contract
AND - the offeree acquires reliable information of the offeror’s inconsistent action
Functional equivalents rule
When an offer is made by advertisement in a newspaper or magazine (or some sort of public notification), the power of acceptance is terminated when the notice of revocation is communicated by advertisement or other general notification equivalent to that used for the offer and no better means of communication is reasonable.
So, if you offer via newspaper ad, you can revoke the offer via newspaper ad. A particular offeree loses the POA even if he is completely unaware of the revocation
Can an offeror revoke an offer any time before acceptance, even if they promised to hold it open?
YES. Dickenson v. Dodds. Even if he expressly promised to hold it open, can revoke at any time.
How to prevent revocation of an offer:
- common law option contract
2. firm offer under UCC
Three elements to form an enforceable options contract
- an offer
- a subsidiary promise to keep the option open
- some valid mechanism for securing enforcement of the subsidiary promise (consideration)
General rule - construction contracts
Where a general contractor uses a particular subcontractor’s bid to formulate his own, an implied option contract is created via promissory estoppel; prevents the subcontractor form revoking the bid
UCC “Firm Offer” Rule
A merchant can make a firm offer (irrevocable offer) to either buy or sell goods WITHOUT consideration so long as:
- the offer is made by a merchant
- the offer is made in a writing signed by the merchant,
AND - the offer expressly states by its terms that it will be held open
If these requirements met, offer is irrevocable either for stated period of time in the firm offer, or for a reasonable time if no time is specified.
A merchant (UCC)
Defined in terms of their special knowledge or skill with respect to the practices or goods involved in a transaction.
A person may be considered a merchant even if he only has knowledge of the goods, or knowledge of the practices.
Shelf life of a firm offer
3 MONTHS. Any firm offers that state they will be held open longer than 3 months will become revocable after the first 3 months.
How to establish an irrevocable offer for longer than 3 months?
Create a common law option contract. So need a promise to hold it open, plus some form of consideration.
Mirror image rule
At common law, requires that acceptance must mirror the terms of the offer, and ANY variation results in a counteroffer and rejection of the initial offer.
Mirror image rule in UCC?
NOPE - recognizes a binding contract despite the presence of a nonconforming acceptance in two circumstances:
- shipment of nonconforming goods
- battle of the forms
When is an offeror bound under a unilateral contract?
- Only when the offeree COMPLETES performance in accordance with the terms of the offer
Is an offeree bound by a unilateral contract?
NO. The offeree is NEVER bound to perform bc he has never promised to perform.