Forensic Issues/Physical Injury Flashcards
How does the (proximate) cause of death differ from the mechanism (immediate) cause of death?
- The proximate = the “real” cause of death
- How did they die?/What killed them = Cause of death
- Why did someone die suddenly? = Mechanism of death
- Mechanism of death = Final pathological cause of death
Accurate Death Certificate Schema
- (Immediate) Cause of Death (Mechanism) DUE TO (proximate) Cause of Death
- Need to have the cause of death on the certificate
- Ex. Massive hemorrhage due to gun shot wounds
The Manner of Death is a opinion. What elements may such an opinion encompass besides an autopsy?
- The medical examiner has no duty to families. They work for society not families
- You are most likely to be killed by someone in your family or someone you know
List the manners of death
- Natural (death is not due to foul play)
- Accident
- Suicide
- Homicide
- Undetermined
Is it ever legitimate to formally list a manner of death as “undetermined”?
YES
- Ex. Cardiorespiratory breast is not legitimate cause of death
Why are homicide and murder not synonymous?
- Homicide is putting someone to death
- Murder (can be premeditated)
- Murder is more a legal term whereas homicide is death certificate terms
- Murder can be classified as homicide. Homicide includes all unnatural death caused by humans
Why are there few hospital autopsies?
- If you misdiagnose, it is a law suit
- Pathologists don’t like to do hospital autopsies because it takes a long time, requires a lot of money, and can get sued. Everyone can get sued
- Insurance companies don’t want to pay for it. So it is not a good thing
- Medical examiners can’t be sued in their office because they have sovereign immunity
If a case appears ‘obvious’, why do a forensic autopsy?
What role does ‘the family’ play in decision-making, in terms of when and if a (ME) autopsy is performed?
- Even if the case seems obvious, families might want an autopsy because they are so sure that they know what happened even if it differs from what you think and so the only way you can refute them is by getting a forensic autopsy
- But sometimes families insist they don’t want an autopsy but you have no duty to the family so use your best judgement
Who can legitimately certify death in the US?
- Medical examiner **
- Any licensed physician
- Coroner
- Justice of the Peace
Major forms of Body Cooling and Changes
- Algor Mortis
- Livor Mortis
What is Algor Mortis?
cooling of the body after death and can cool in a uniform rate but depends upon the ambient temperature outside
What is Livor Mortis
After you die, and there is not systemic circulation, red blood cells go to dependent portion of bodies and become fixed. So when you press on body, it is fixed and you know roughly what time it occurs over. Also depends on temp.
List and describe the forms of decomposition
- Putrefactive - died in a setting which is temperate and humid (like Florida). Large volumes of fluid accumulate. Skin begins to slip and has color changes (grey, blue, greenish). Decomposition begins over the cecum (where biggest load of bacteria is. Those organisms invade after death. Green patch)
- Adipcere Formation- body found in water. Lipid layer encasing the body esp in fresh water and less so in salt water
- Mummification - kind of rare in US. Bodies that die in arid places like deserts can dry out and mummify.
Wrong Media Perceptions
- Time of death - hard to specifically say a time of death
- Rapidity of testing - Mass spectroscopy and other testing take a fair amount of time including toxicology testing (for common drugs of abuse)
- Data bases - facial recognition things on TV where you can identify people is not likely
- Justices of the Peace, Coroners, Medical Examiners, Crime Scene Investigators/Police (these ‘terms’ are not generally synonymous/interchangeable).
What is the role of the medical examiner?
- To assign a cause of death (COD)
- To render an opinion as to the manner of death
- Duty is to SOCIETY
The focus of a forensic examination/inquiry is not ? death (other than to rule out/observe discernible signs) or consider circumstances in terms of the probabilty of foul play/unnatural death, or contributions thereof
Natural
What systems are extremely susceptible to radiation injury?
Hematopoietic and lymphoid systems
True capability of forensic specialists to accurately ascertain a time of death
- If body temp is warm and body is not stiff = dead not more than 3 hours
- If body temp is warm and body is stiff = dead 3 to 8 hours
- Body temp is cold and body is stiff = dead 8 to 36 hours
- Body temp is cold and body is not stiff = dead more than 36 hours
Difference between Medical Examiner and Coroner
- Coroners are usually elected and are not required to be physicians. If an autopsy is needed, a coroner will frequently consult with a pathologist or forensic pathologist.
- Medical examiners, in most cases, are appointed and must be physicians.
Forensic Specialists
1. Criminology –Profiling –Fingerprints –Voiceprints –Facial recognition –Handwriting –Other
- Odontologist - dentists
- Anthropologist - involves applying skeletal analysis and techniques in archaeology to solving criminal cases.
- Entomologist - specialist of bugs in decomposition. (Especially lay maggots in eyes. Maggots want to get into the interior of bodies and can do it via gun shot wound).
- Laboratory
- Toxicology
- Histomorphology
- Ballistics
- Hair and fiber
- Patterning studies, i.e. tool/tire marks
- Gunshot residues
- DNA/nuclear, mitochondrial
- Other, clinical laboratory analyses
Difference between law enforcement vs medical examiners
- Law enforcement role can include Ballistics (like knowing which weapon caused the murder). They use blood and body fluids for DNA evidence. They can also be at the scene of the crime
- Medical examiners- licensed physicians that perform autopsies to figure out the cause of death
Role of hospital autopsy
Performed in order to provide scientists with greater information about pathology and also to keep a check on hospital care and ensure doctors are providing the best services they possibly can.
Full Autopsy Technical Approach
???? An autopsy takes the form of six stages: - Y-Incision. - Removal of Organs. - Stomach Contents. - Sample Collection. - Head and Brain examination. - Conclusion.
10 leading causes of death by Age
- Homicide rate is highest - 15-34 (homicide done by women is 1.5% so men are most dangerous)
- Overall gun violence death is going down
What kind of death is SIDS?
Natural death
What kind of death is low bar pneumonia?
Natural death