Florida Criminal Procedure Flashcards
Subject Matter Jurisdiction: Florida Supreme Court
- Final judgments that impose the death penalty
- District courts of appeals rulings—validity of state or federal statute or constitution; rulings in direct conflict with another district court of appeal’s ruling or FL Supreme Court’s ruling
- Questions of great public importance and certified by district court of appeal
- Questions certified by federal court with no controlling FL law
- Writs of prohibition, mandamus, quo warranto, habeas corpus
- Certified trial court orders from district court of appeal that require immediate resolution
Subject Matter Jurisdiction: District Courts of Appeal (DCA)
- Final judgment of trial courts not directly appealable to Supreme Court
- Interlocutory orders as provided by FL Supreme Court’s rules
- Writs of habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto
Subject Matter Jurisdiction: Circuit Court
- All criminal appeals of matters tried in county court, except any orders that declare state statute/constitution invalid
- All actions not vested in county court
- Felonies and misdemeanors arising out of same circumstances as a jointly charged felony
4. Juvenile criminal matters
- Writs of habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto
Subject Matter Jurisdiction: County Court
- All misdemeanors not joined with felony
- All violations of municipal and county ordinances
Written Notice to Appear
May issue if misdemeanor or violation of ordinance •
Exceptions:
- Person fails or refuses to identify himself
- Person fails or refuses to sign notice
- Person has no ties to the community
- Person poses an unreasonable risk of bodily harm to himself or another
- Person previously failed to appear
- Officer suspects person may be wanted in another jurisdiction
Entitled to same information and counsel as an accused at a first appearance
Pre-Trial Release
Must be determined at first appearance
Every person generally entitled to release on reasonable conditions
Except: capital offense or life in prison and proof of guilt evident or presumption great
Bail Modification
Felony charge—at least three hours’ notice and heard in court
Court may revoke bail if PC that a crime was committed while on release
Pre-trial Detention Grounds
—substantial probability that D:
- Violated previous pretrial release conditions
- Threatened, intimidated, or injured a victim, witness, juror, or judicial officer with the intent to obstruct the judicial process
- Charged with trafficking in controlled substances or DUI manslaughter with aggravators
- On probation, parole, or release at time crime committed
- Poses a harm to community
- Violated condition of pretrial release or bond and no other conditions will reasonably protect community from risk of physical harm
Pretrial Detention Procedure
May be filed at first appearance hearing; if not, three days to file
- Standard to grant motion = PC
- State may request anytime before trial; if no exigent circumstances, hearing within later of 5 days from filing motion or taking person into custody
- May be lifted if subsequent event eliminated basis for detention
Indictment
- Returned by grand jury; signed by grand jury foreperson and advising state attorney
- Capital crimes MUST be prosecuted by indictment
- Any other crimes MAY be prosecuted by indictment
Information
filed and signed by state attorney;
may be amended any time amendment will not prejudice the defense
Contents of Charging document
Plain, concise, and definite written statement of essential facts constituting the offense charged, including time and place of offense;
if insufficient, defendant may seek court order demanding a statement of particulars
Defect in form of charging document generally not grounds for dismissal
Alibi
notice to prosecutor 10 days before trial;
prosecutor has 5 days to provide information on rebuttal witnesses to defense
Battered Spouse Syndrome
Written Notice 30 before trial
*Defense*
Incompetence
Incompetent D lacks
- sufficient present ability to consult with counsel in preparing their case with a reasonable degree of rational understanding; or
- a rational and factual understanding of the pending proceedings
- May not commit D until evaluated by at least two experts, unless parties stipulate to a finding of incompetency by one expert
- May order exam by no more than 3 experts; must hold a hearing
- Found not competent: reviewed every 6 months
- Use of experts’ reports and related information used for competency hearing limited to use at that hearing unless used by defendant at another hearing
- After 5 years (felony) or 1 year (misdemeanor): if D is still incompetent and likely to remain so, but ineligible for commitment, dismiss charges without prejudice
Insantity
Written notice 15 days after arraignment or filing of written plea
With good cause, court may allow 10 additional days
- Court must appoint an expert to assist indigent D
- “Not guilty by reason of insanity” verdict by jury: court may commit D, order outpatient treatment, or discharge D
Sequestration
Judge has discretion to sequester jury during trial;
Required in capital cases with death penalty after jurors have retired for consideration of their verdict, and for other cases as long as judge gives appropriate cautionary instructions.
Motion to vacate, set aside, or correct sentence
- Grounds = violation of constitution or laws of FL or US, lack of jurisdiction, sentence exceeded authorized maximum, involuntary plea, otherwise subject to collateral attack
- Procedure = excessive sentence = at any time; others = two years