Florida Con Law Flashcards
If in an essay, a FL statute has been enacted, what issues should be thought of to address its constitutionality?
- federal preemption
- law related to police power
- pricavy issues
- vague/overbroad
- religion issue (FEC, establishment)
- speech issues
- press issues
- association issues
- right to work issue
- imprisoned for debt
- prohibited law
- access to courts
- due process
- equal protection clause
- contract impairment
- separation of powers
- anti-delegation
- law constitution/pre-reqs
- governor veto
- type of legislative session
What subjects MUST be regulated through general law only?
- elections
- taxation
- rules of evidence
- punishment of crimes
- petite junes
- change of venue
- conditions to bring civ or crim proceeding (BIG)
- lien creation
- divorce
- adoption
- regulation of occupations
- private incorporation or the grant of privilege to a private corporation
Describe the levels of scrutiny for EPC issues in Florida
1 - Strict Scrutiny
- race, religion, national origin, physical disability
- necessary to achieve a compelling government interest and narrowly tailored
- burden on government
2 - intermediate scrutiny
- gender & sexual orientation
- substantially related to an important government interest
- burden on government
3 - Rational Basis
- EVERYTHING ELSE
- rationally related to a legitimate government interest
- burden on plaintiff
Article 1 Section 2
The right to vote applies to who?
Those who qualify as electors. Qualifications include:
1. 18+ years of age
2. permanent resident of FL
3. registered as elector in county
CAN’T be adjudicated mentally incompetent OR felony (can be restored)
What test is used to analyze an establishment clause issue?
LEMON TEST (not followed by feds/MBE) - law is upheld if:
1. has a primarily secular purpose
2. primary effect netiher advances nor inhibits religion
3. law does NOT produce excessive government entanglement w/ religion
How are freedom of speech & press issues analyzed?
Same as fed law/MBE
Explain FL’s right to freedom of Assembly
People retain right to assemble peaceably & to petition for redress of grievances
- regulations governing this right CANNOT give local officials TOO MUCH DISCRETION to prevent peaceful assemblies
What does FL’s “right to work” afford?
No person may be denied a job because of membership or nonmembership in a labor union
- public & private sector employees have the right to bargain collectively
- public employees do NOT have right to STRIKE
Explain FL’s right to bear arms
People have right to bear arms to protect themselves and state
- 3 day waiting period between the purchase of gun & delivery
- counties may impose 3-5 days & criminal background check
What are the types of Due Process?
1 - Procedural Due Process
- no person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law
- notice & hearing required
2 - Substantive Due Process
- taking away a right
- fundamental right? Strict scrutiny
- anything else? rational basis
Article 1 Section 9
What are fundamental rights in Florida?
- access to courts
- right to privacy
- right to work
- freedom of religion
- access to public records & meetings
Also ones recognized by federal gov’t
What are some prohibited laws?
- bills of attainder
- ex post facto laws
- impairments of existing contracts
When is a law impairing contracts prohibited?
- state action
- law afffecting EXISTING contracts
- law substantially impairs contract (does law change intention and legal effect?)
if all 3 are met, law only upheld if:
- serves important & legitimate purpose
- narrowly tailored
When can a person be imprisoned for debt?
ONLY if fraud is proved
- if NOT proved, it is prohibited
What rights do victim’s of crimes have?
10 things
Victims MUST be informed of all these rights:
1. due process
2. reasonable protection from accused
3. prevent disclosure of confidential information
4. notice of public proceedings
5. be heard
6. confer w/ prosecution
7. be informed
8. return of property
9. restitution from convicted offenders for loss
10. promptness
Explain FL’s fundamental right of “Access to Courts”
Justice MUST be administered without sale, denial, or delay
- the legislature cannot abolish an existing common law or statutory cause of action without providing an adequate alternative that is substantially equivalent
Article 1 Section 21 & Kluger v. White
What are some examples of when the right to access to courts is VIOLATED?
- denying a persons right to at least 1 appeal from a final order
- abolishing cause of action
- shifting responsbility for dispute resolution to a nontraditional body (administrative body)
- making it significantly more difficult to prosecute a civil action by creating onerous prerequisites or procedural hurdles
When can the legislature abolish a cause of action?
If the legislature demonstrates:
1. overpowering public necessity for abolishing right (compelling state interest); AND
2. no alternative method available to meet public necessity
Explain the right to privacy?
Every natural person has the right to:
1. be left alone; AND
2. be free from governmental intrustion into that person’s private life
Strict Scrutiny used
What is the states burden when they are intruding on an individuals right to privacy?
Intrusion is:
1. furthering a compelling state interest; AND
2. employing the least intrusive means to do so
What are some examples of privacy rights in FL?
- right to refuse medical treatment
- right of parents to direct upbringing of their kids
What are the four requirements of the Sunshine Law?
- Meetings of the required entities must be open to the public
- reasonable notice of meetings must be given
- minutes of meetings must be taken
- venue must be accessible
When do legislatures have to comply with the Sunshine Law?
When there are 3 or more legislature meetings
When can an exemption be made to the Sunshine Law?
- Law states a necessity justifying exemption; AND
- Law is no broader than necessary to accomplish the goal
Explain the limits on attorney contingency fees in medical malpractice cases?
- no more than 30% of first $250k
- no more than 10% on anything in excess of $250k
The right to work & to bargain collectively are what types of rights?
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS
What is the most well known procedural due process right?
Right to a fair trial
The FL Constitution prohibits excessive punishments, including…
- excessive finds
- cruel or unusual punishment
- forfeiture of estates
- indefinite imprisonment
- unreasonable detention of witnesses