Flash Cards for Bar Courses - Con Law
Advisory Opinions
Decisions that lack (1) an actual dispute between adverse parties or (2) any legally binding effect on parties.
Fed Cts cannot issue advisory opinions
Ripeness
Pre enforcement reviews of law are generally not ripe. P can est ripeness b4 a law is enforced by showing
(1) issue are fit for a judicial decision, and
(2) P would suffer substantial hardship in the absence of review
Mootness
The P needds to be suffering from an ongoing injury
Standing
3 major components : Injury, Causation, and Redressability
Standing to assert for others
If (1) it is difficult for the 3rd party to assert their own rights or (2) a close relationship exsists between the claimant and the 3rd party
Exceptions to Soverign immunity
-Express waiver
-implicit consent/structural waiver
-Actions against Local Gov.
- Suits by other states or the fed govt
-Bankruptcy
-Certain Actions agaist state officers
-Congress removes immunity
Necesary and Proper clause
Congress can exercise powers enumerated in the constitution plus any powers necessary and proper to carry out the enumerated powers as long as it does not violatre another provision of the constitution
Taxing and Spending Power
Congress has the power to tax and spenf to provide for the general welfare. May be for ANY public purpose not prohibited by the constituion. CONGRESS CANNOT DIRECTLY REGULATRE GENERAL WELFARE
Spending Power Conditions
Congress can impose conditions on the grant of money to state or local govt. Conditions must be clealy stated, relate to teh purpsoe of the program and not unduely coerciver and do not violate the constitution
Taxing Power
fed taxes will be upheld of they ear some reasonable relationship to revenue production or to promoting general welfare
Commerce Power
Congress has the power to regulkate all foreign and interstate commerce (also with indian tribes). The regulation must either
-regulate channels (roads, watrerways, telephone lines, internet)
-Regualte instrumentalities (planes, trains, cars)
-Regulate activities that have a substantial effect on interestate commerce
Regulation of “Intrastate” activities under CC
Congress can regulate intrasate activities and it will be upheld if the reg can think of a rational baiss on which congress can condlude that the activity in the aggregae substantial;ly affects interstate commerce. (THE ACTIVITY HAS TO BE COMMERICAL) (ACTIVITY MUST BE ECONOMIC AND NOT NONECONOMIC)
-Private discrimination– if it has a substantial affect on interstate commerce; public discrim is reg under the 14th amedment
Congress’ delegation of power
Can delegate rulemaking or regulatrory authoirty to the executive or judicvial brankc as long as “intelligible standars” are set and the power isn’t something that is uniquely confined to Congress
-Congress CAN NOT appont members of a body with admin or enforcement power
Presidential Implied Powers
-Where Pres. acts with express or implied authority of congress – pres. authotuity is at its MAX and actions are likely valid
-Wherer Pres. acts where Congress is Silent – Ct will conisider the circumstances and any relevant history and the act is UNLIKELY to be upheld if it USURPS the power of anotehr govt branch or prevents anotehr govt bracnh from carrying out its tasks
-If Pres. acts agaist express will of Congress AND congress has authority to act – ACTION IS LIKELY INVALID
Appointment powers
Pres. can appoint with approval of congress BUT congress CANNOT appoint by itself
Veto
Pres has power to veto and congress can overcome with 2/3 vote of each house. Pres has 10 days to veto, if Congress is NOT in session – auto veto; if COngress is IN session– bill becomes law
PRes. Treaty Power
Pres has power to enter into treaties with consent of 2/3 vote of the Senate
Treaties
Treaties > State law
Treats v. Fed law – last in time wins
Treaties < constition
Executive Agreements
Used for the same purposes as treaties buy DO NOT require the consetn of Senate
Exec agreemetns > statelaw
Exec agreemetn < fed law
Presidential Impeachment
Pres can be impeached with a majority vote in the House and REMOVED and CONVICTED with a 2/3 vote in the Senate
State Powers
10th Amend gives states all powers not granted to the fed govt to the states or the ppl
-General Police Powers
14th amendment
Congress may restrict states from discrimnating in violation of equal protection or depriving rights protected by due process
Supremacy Clause
Fed law may supersede or preempot state (or local) laws.
Express Preemption
Fed law expressly say that the statees may not adopt laws concerning the subject matter of teh federal legislation
Implied Preemption
Conflict between state and fed law req – if state law conflicts with fed law that it would be impossible to comply with both, the state law will be preempted
State prevents achieveement of fed objective – if state or local law prevents achievement of fed objective, it will be preempted
Field preemption – fed law may impliedly occupoy the entire fireld thus barring any state or laocal law even if the state or local law is nonconflicting
Privledges and Immunities clause IV Amendment
Art. IV prohibits discrimination by a state agaisnt nonresidents
-Corp and aliens are not protected
-Only important commercial activities and fundamental rights protected
-importatn state interest req. – will be INVALID unless the law is necessary to achide an important govt. pupose and there are NO LESS restrictve means available
Privledges of National Citizenship (14th amend.)
States may not deny their citizens the privledges or immunites of national citizenship. (Corps not protected)
-right to vote
-right to interstaet travel
Dormant CC
even where congress has not acted, the CC restricts state reg. of interstaet commerce; states may not favor local econ interest or unduly burden interstae commerce
- where not discriminatory; state regulation is valid if legitimate state interest is greater than the burden on interstate commerce.
-discrim may be valid if it is NECESSARY to achieve an imporatnat noneconomic state interest and tehre are no reasonable nondiscriminator alternatives available (Burden must NOT otweigh the legitmate local interest)