FL Crim Pro Flashcards
FL
Juridiction for criminal cases
Supreme Court
1. death penalty cases
2. cases from lower courts initially construing the validity of a state or federal statute
3. treaty/constitutional provision
4. distrcit court decisions conflicting with other discrit court
5. supreme court decisions
6. extrodinary writs
7. certified questions by district court
District Court of Appeal:
1. appeals from circut courts
Circut Court: all cases not triable in county courts
1. misdemeanors with felonies
2. felonies
3. extrodinary writs
4. juvi
County Court:
1. misdemeanors
2. ordinance violation
3. first appearance
FL
When are indigent D’s entitled to counsel in crim proceedings?
- felonies
- misdemeanors/violations punished by incarceration
- juvi cases
- first direct appeal
if not subjec tto incarceration, no right to counsel!!! Judge must confirm in writing that no incarceration only applies in mismemeanors
FL
Waiver of right to counsel
must be knowingly, inteligently, and voluntarily
Waiver must be made on court record or in writing before 2 witnesses.
Never permanent - judge must offered at every stage of the proceedings.
Court can consider:
1. mental condition
2. age
3. education
4. prior court experience
5. type of case
FL
Defense counsel wants to withdrawl
must be approved by court and it must be for good cause.
FL
Minimum standard for attorneys in felony cases
attoreny must complete a course approved by the FL bar covering the legal and ethical grounds of discovery in criminal cases
FL
Minimum standard for attorneys in capital punishment cases
- 5 years in criminal litigation
- tried 9 complex cases
- experience with expert witnesses
- 12 hours of continuing litigation in capital cases
FL
Capias
bench warrant when D fails to appear as required or formal charges have been filed by information or indictment
FL
Notice to appear
officers issue - signed and promise to return to court.
only misdemeanors and violations
FL
When can a failure to appear not be issued:
- accussed fails to sign the notice
- accused’s liberty presents an unreasoanble risk of bodily harm to the accused or others
- no ties to the jurisdiction and substantial risk that theyll violate the notice to appear
- may be wanted for another crime
- previously violated a notice, summons, or release condition in the past
FL
Duties of booking officer
if arresting officer does not want to give notice to appear, booking officer may give it if they feel its valid
FL
Right to pretrial release
All persons in custody are entitled to pre-trial release except:
1. charged with capital or life felony
2. proof of guilt is evident or presumption of guilt is great
FL
Pre-trial conditions
- ROR: released on own recognizance - promise to come back
- Bonds: (1) cash bond (2) sureity bond
- Custody of 3rd party : given to a designated person ot organization to supervise them
- Restrictions: restricts work, association, travel, or place of abode (ex. anklet, only allowed for work hrs)
- Any reasonable condition: must be reasonable with the crime.
any person charged with a dangerous crime (homicide, sexual battery, kidnapping) cant be granted non-monetary pre-trial release during first apperance - maybe judge will allow in other proceeding
FL
Release after failure to appear
D cannot be given ROR
FL
First apperance
first apperance must be within 24 hours of arrest
Can be in person or by audio device
If more than 24 hours the case does not end, but accused gets released.
What happens at first appearance
C: counsel appointed
A: advice is given about the case (mini miranda)
R: release is decided
P: probable cause determination (if all paperwork is ready!!) (remember warrants give PC)
CARP24! Remember - 24 hours after arrest!
FL
Probable cause determination
NO LAWYERS - THIS IS NOT A HEARING!!!!
TO APPLY D MUST STILL BE IN CUSTODY OR UNDER SIGNIFICANT RESTRAINT ON THIER LIBERTY
This is done as a check to the police work - the judge onlu needs probable cause that ANY crime was commited. Doesnt have to be the crime charged.
If D is still in custody: happens within 48 hours of arrest unless prosecutor has good cause, then can extend two 48 hour extensions. MAX 96 HOURS.
If D was released in pre-trial but with restraint: must request it within 21 days of arrest. Magistrate has 7 days to hear it.
If there is no PC found - D gets released/ restraint removed.
FL
Adversary preliminary hearing (special probable cause hearing)
LAWYERS WELCOMED HERE & ONLY DOE FELONIES
Applies when:
1. felony defendant
2. still detained by gov
3. no formal charges have been filed within 21 days of arrest
this hearing benefits the D because its like a sneak peak on discovery!
If no PC found, D must get relased.
If PC found, procecutor needs to file charges before 33rd day of arrest. Can extend it **7 more days **for good cause. NO MORE THAN 40 DAYS.
FL
Pre-trial detention
Given to D’s charged with dangerous crimes (homicide, sexual battery, robbery, kidnapping)
In order to give pre-trial detention the state must show:
1. dangerous to community or
2. drug trafficing & likely to flee or
3. threat to judicial process or
4. Likely to flee.
FL
Joinder of criminal offense
offenses may be joined in one indictment or information if based on the same connected act or transaction.
must be linked
FL
Indictment or information may charge 2 or more D’s if:
- each D is charged in each count and
- each D is charged with the same count of conspiracy and some D’s also charged with substantive offense or
- common scheme plan
FL
Consilidation of offenses (delayed joinder)
offenses that could have been joined in one indictment or information may be consolidated for trial
D may move before trial to consolidate charges against them and may move for dismissal or charges unreasoanbly not consolidated.
FL
Severance of offenses
D has the right to sever claims that were improperly joined.
Right to sever before trial: appropriate need
Right to sever during trial: necessary need
FL
Severance where co-defendant talks (Bruton test)
Arises when a defendants statement implicates a co-defendant.
Bruton Test:
1. omit statement completely at a joint trial
2. removing reference to co-defendant (if co-defendant is not prejudice)
3. sever the defendants
FL
Pretrial motions in criminal procedure
Receive a motion:
1. start counting next business day
2. If more than 7 days to respond, weekdays and holidays are included in countdown
3. last day cannot be a weekend/holiday - turns into next business day
4. If fewer than 7 days to respond, count only business days.
5. If notice is by mail - additional 5 days.
Courts can extend time for good cause except for:
1. new trial
2. taking an appeal
3. motion for judgment of aquittal
FL
Motion for speedy trial
States that you are ready for trial within 5 days and that D has investigated the case.
FL
Speedy trials
Natural speedy trials:
Misdemeanors - 90 days w/ arrest/custody
Felony - 175 days of arrest/custody
If D demands: 50 days
If D demands a speedy - judge has 5 days to hold a hearing and 10 days to be tried. - Trial must be concluded within 60 days from filing.
Motion/Notice must be named “Demand for Speedy Trial”
can file as many as you want, as long as good cause
FL
Criminal defendants outside FL jurisdiction
Speedy rules not available to defendant until:
1. D returns to the jurisdiction of the FL courts where the charges are pending
2. written notice of the defendants return is filed with the FL court and prosecutor
FL
Ways to Waive Speedy Trial
- Waive speedy expressly or
- Any delay in the case attributed to the defense
If defendant waives speedy trial – the countdown to speedy is destroyed and must demand.
FL
Violation to Speedy Trial
Nothing happens until defendant files notice of expiration (NOE)
After NOE, court has 5 days to set a hearing – trial must be within 10 days from that hearing but no later than 15 days from NOE. If violated – harmless error.
If case still doesn’t go to trial, defense must file a motion for discharge.
Judge looks at defendant waivers and if none, must dismiss and no criminal liability attaches
FL
Victim’s Right to Speedy Trial (State Request)
The state may file a demand of a speedy trial if:
1) The state has met with its discovery obligations or
2) The court has granted three continuances on the defendants request over state objections or
3) In a felony case not resolved within 125 days after the date that charged were formally charged
If granted, court must schedule calendar call within 5 days and trial must commence within 45 days.
FL
Effect of Mistrial, Order of New Trial, or Appeal
Must be brought to trial within 90 days of whichever occurs first:
1) When a mistrial was declared or
2) When the order was entered granting a new trial or
3) When the court granted an arrest of judgment or
4) When the trial court received the reviewing courts mandate, order, or notice.