First Semester Flashcards
define trespass to land
right to possess land; does not require physical damage, e.g. “harm”, because actual damage/harm was caused to P’s right to exclude
3 factors to consider when determining punitive damages: degree of reprehensibility, disparity between the harm or portential harm suffered, and the difference between this remedy and penalties imposed in comparable cases
what is the shack standard?
property rights serve human values. they recognized to that end, and are limited by it. property to benefit society as a whole and not the individual owner
what are the exceptions to privileged entries on land over the owner’s objection
- Entry by a remainderman to view waste or make repairs
- Entry to abate a private nuisance
- Entry by a former licensee to remove his possessions
- Entry by a traveler on a public highway that has become impassable to enter neighboring land to continue his journey
- Entry because of private necessity (e.g. docking a boat at a private pier during a storm)
define trespass to chattels
requires actual damage/harm to property; requires “harm”
P still has the right to exclude by self-help with reasonable force to protect possession against even harmless interference
what is the majority view on speech and semi-private property?
property owners can restrict speech to reasonabke times, places, and manner restrictions
what is the minority view on speech and semi-private property?
schmid 3 factor test: normal use of the property; the extend and nature of the public’s invitation to use that property, and the purpose of the expression activity in relation to both its private and public use
what is the difference between lease and license?
lease is a possssory interest in land [exclusive possession], license merely authorizes the licensee to use land in the possssion of another [not exclusive possession]
what is the majority rule for actual physical possession and quiet enjoyment?
English Rule; Landlord is obligated to furnish actual physical possession to the tenant; no rent due until physical possession is obtained; tenant cannot terminate lease because of holdover tenant, provided that the LL removes holdover tenant in reasonable time; Note: it is T’s responsibility to handle squatters after they have taken possession
what is the minority rule for actual physical possession and quiet enjoyment?
American Rule; it is up to the tenant to deal with any trespasser or holdover tenant; LL is not held to a requirement of “actual possession,” only responsibility is to handover keys; Tenant has legal standing to evict & seek damages from holdover tenant or squatter
does the tenant have COA against LL if there is a trespasser?
no assuming as the LL is not negligent in creating or contributing to the situation or the lease is not disturbed by paramount title
paramount title is someone like mortgage holder or lender in foreclosure, then they have breach of COA
define convenant of quiet enjoyment
occurs when the LL substantially interferes with the tenant’s beneficial use or enjoyment of the premise; applies to both residential and commercial properties
a. Breach
i. Actual Eviction – complete or partial (physical exclusion)
ii. CE – no physical exclusion, but substantial interference that prevents tenants enjoyment of premises
iii. General breach of CQE – not rising to level of actual or constructive eviction, but entitles T to damages
b. Requirements:
i. Notice
ii. Reasonable time to cure (R/T/C)
c. Remedies:
i. Terminate the lease
ii. Withhold rent
iii. Damages (e.g. storage units, hotel costs)
define partial actual eviction
encroachment by LL on an appreciable portion of the leased premise
a. Requirements:
i. Notice
ii. R/T/C
b. Remedies:
i. Majority Rule: withhold all rent (complete abatement) for the remainder of the lease term until premises are restored
ii. Minority/Modern Rule: percentage reduction in rent If 10% encroachment, then 10% off rent – proportional
iii. LL can consider lease terminated and vacate
define constructive eviction
occurs when the LL deprives the tenant of the beneficial use or enjoyment of the property so that the action is tantamount to depriving the tenant of physical possession; a reasonable person could not live in the conditions
a. Requirements:
i. Notice
ii. R/T/C – If LL does not cure, tenant must vacate
b. Remedies:
i. Lease terminated, stop paying rent, forced to vacate because of bad conditions
what is the common law for LL’s duties?
No implied covenant concerning quality of premises; all obligations to maintain and repair on tenant, not LL; LL failure to perform did not allow tenant to w/h rent; prior to I/W/H, there was caveat emptor, which the LL had no duty of the lessor after the lessee signed the lease
what is the modern view for implied warranty of habitability?
LL must maintain livable, habitable conditions/vital facilities (e.g. heat, hot water); most courts look at building/housing codes, but tenant doesn’t necessarily need a code violation
LL must maintain “bare living requirements” (e.g. heat and water)
i. Most jurisdictions do not allow I/W/H to be waived (implied at beginning of lease; even where tenant remains in possession of the premise after the alleged breach; distinguishes from breach of CQE)
ii. Tenant not required to vacate premises, must give LL R/T/C
1. If tenant leaves, the COA turns into Constructive Eviction
iii. No breach occurs for small things (e.g. blinds)
what are the remedies for breach of I/W/H?
i. Withhold Rent until problem cured (some courts require rent to be paid to escrow account)
ii. Repair and Deduct (limitation: cannot exceed 1 month’s rent)
iii. Sue for Damages (while remaining in possession)
iv. Terminate the lease and sue for damages
1. Approaches to damages:
a. Fair rental value less fair rental value in unrepaired condition
b. Contract rent less fair rental value in unrepaired condition
c. Percentage diminution approach
*Many states do not recognize IWH for commercial leases, but do recognize IWS
define implies warranty of suitability
LL requirement in commercial leases that the premises are suitable for their intended commercial purpose
i. Majority of Jx: Residential only; does not recognize the I/W/H or I/W/S in commercial leases
ii. Minority (Restatement): recognizes I/W/S
define tenancy for years
fixed or computable period of time that requires certainty of duration; the death of LL or T does not terminate a tenancy for years
i. Fixed = beginning and ending times of lease are on designated calendar dates
ii. Computable = contains a formula for determining the starting/ending date
b. Creation: an express agreement
c. Termination: terminates automatically at the end of the period specified in the agreement; neither party needs to give notice (no notice)
define periodic tenancy
continues for successive periods until terminated; automatically renews until terminated, death of LL or T does not affect duration (e.g. week to week, month to month, and year to year)
b. Creation: express agreement or more typically, inferred from facts
c. Termination: notice is required
define tenancy at will
Characteristics: no designated period of duration, at the will of both parties
Creation: express agreement or more typically, inferred from the circumstances
Termination: terminates at the will of either party, OR at the death of either party, OR when LL tries to convey/T tries to assign
define tenancy at sufferance
holdover tenants after lease expires, just short of a trespasser
a. C/L: LL could bring eviction action or could accept rent & extend lease for another term period
b. Restatement: requires reasonable time to vacate
c. Some states require the LL to give T notice before terminating or eviction
If the LL excepts payment then it becomes a periodic tenancy
what is the common law/traditional rule for LL personal injury?
LL is not liable for personal injury caused by defects in the premises
Negligence – (1) contracted to make repairs and didn’t do it, or (2) knew, or should have known, of the defects (e.g. foreseeability)
what is the modern rule for LL personal injury?
LL has duty to make premises safe; lessors are generally liable for personal injuries suffered on the leased premises
what is the extension of I/W/H to cover safety of a premises?
A LL’s I/W/H obliges him to furnish reasonable safeguards to protect tenants from foreseeable criminal activity
under the common law, what is the LL motive for selecting or removing tenants?
LL had completed freedom to choose tenants
define the fair housing act of 1968
It is unlawful to discriminate in the sale or rental of most housing on the grounds of race, color, religion, sex, familial status or national origin (ex. “children can’t ride bikes on sidewalk” is discrimination against familial status)
2 exceptions: single family home or renting a building
what is the civil rights act of 1860
it protects against discrimination based on race
what is the majority rule for assignment
transfer of all of the tenant’s rights under the lease to the transferee for remainder of lease