First Amendment Flashcards
What are the 3 ways a private entity can qualify as a state actor?
- When the private entity performs exclusive public functions (ie company towns)
- When the Gov’t compels the private entity to take particular action; OR
- When the Gov’t acts jointly with the private entity.
What level of scrutiny applies to regulations targeting view point?
Severe Strict Scrutiny
What level of scrutiny applies to regulations targeting content based?
Strict Scrutiny
What level of scrutiny applies to content neutral regulations?
Intermediate Scrutiny
What is necessary to survive strict scrutiny?
The restriction must:
* further a compelling government interest and
* be narrowly tailored
In order for a Time, Place, and Manner restriction to be constitutional, what is required?
The regulation must be
* Appropriately limited and truly intended to regulate only time, place, and manner
* narrowly tailored to serve a significant state interest
* leave open ample alternative channels for communication
What is necessary for a regulation to be content neutral?
The regulation must be both viewpoint neutral and subject matter nuetral.
This applies to all speech regardless of the message.
What is viewpoint neutral?
The Gov’t can’t regulate speech based on the ideology of the message
What is subject-matter neutral?
The gov’t can’t regulate based on the topic of the speech.
When is a law unconstitutionally vague?
When a reasonable person cannot tell what speech is prohibited and what is permitted.
When is a law unconstitutionally overbroad?
When a law regulates substantially more speech than the Constituiton allows to bre regulated, and a person to whom the law constitutionally can be applied can argue that it would be unconstitionally applied to others.
What is the Collateral Bar Rule?
Precludes a person who disobeys a judicially ordered prior restraint from raising arguments about its invalidity as a defense to contempt proceedings.
What is the Unconstitutional Conditions Doctrine?
The gov’t cannot contain a benefit on the requirement that a person forgo a constitutional right.
What is the Brandenburg Test for?
Language that could incite others to violence
Under Brandenburg, what does the speech need to be in order to be deemed unprotected?
- Time: Imminent Harm;
- Probability: A likelihood of producing illegal action; and
- Intent: An intent to cause imminent illegality
What are fighting words?
Speech that is directed at another and is likely to provoke a violent response from a reasonable person.
What case governs Fighting Words?
Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire (1942)
What are the 3 techniques that the Supreme Court uses for overturning Fighting Words convictions?
- Narrowed the scope of the fighting words doctrine by ruling that it applies only to speech directed at another person that is likely to produce a violent response
- Unconstitutionally vague or overbroad
- Finding laws that prohibit some fighting words, such as expressions of hate based on race or gender, to be impermissible content-based restrictions of speech.
What are the 4 types of government regulations for Commercial Speech?
- Laws that outlaw advertising of illegal activities
- The prohibition of false and deceptive advertising
- The gov’t may prohibit true advertising that inherently risks becoming false or deceptive
- Laws that limit commercial advertising to achieve other goals
What case regulates commercial speech?
Central Hudson
What is the Central Hudson test for commercial speech?
- Illegality or misleading representations: Does the speech advertise illegal activities or consitute false or deceptive advertising that is unprotected by 1A?
- Substantial Gov’t Interest: Is the government’s restriction justified by a substantial governmental interest?
- Regulation Direct Advances Interest: Does the law directly advance the government’s interest?
- No more extensive than necessary: Is the regulation of speech no more extensive than necessary to achieve the gov’ts interest? Now, modified to ask if it is narrowly tailored and a reasonable fit between the means and the ends.