FINAL EXAM SHORT ANSWER Flashcards
JUVENILE SEX OFFENDER FACTS
- Youth accounted for 17% of all people accused of sexual violations
- When victims are also youth, 26% are also youth
- 1/4 of people sexual offending against youth, are also youth
- The highest rates: ages 14-16, within that, mostly boys
- When victim under the age of 12, 41% of the people accused are youth as well
- Usually another family member, most often a sibling
- When police actually lay a charge, youth age 12-15 are less likely to be charged than the victim who is a peer rather than a family member
- Same thing when 16-17
- A young person aged 12-13 cannot be tried for sexual interference or sexual toughing or exposure unless in a position of trust/ authority
PREVELENCE IN JSO
if they offend in youth, it will be equally as likely to reoffend in adulthood than to not reoffend in adulthood.
REVIDIVISM IN JSO
- bulk of criminal offences happen in young people
- most grow out of it and don’t reoffend as adults
- BUT for adult offenders, more likely they started when they were young themselves
CHARACTERISTICS IN JSO
- tend to be generalists: aren’t specific to one type of offending; do it all (ENGAGING IN JUST SEX OFFENCES IS RARE)
- 90% of JSO are male
- average age for male offenders is higher than females (male:14)
- most offenders fewer than 5 years older than victim
- many report history of physical/sexual abuse
TWO TYPES OF JUVENILE SEX OFFENDERS
- ADOLESCENCE LIMITED
- Most fall into this category
- Drinking underage, breaking into cars, graffiti
- They grow out of it, by the time early 20’s it stops
- LIMITED TO THAT STAGE OF LIFE
- LIFE COURSE PERSISTENT
- Starts a lot earlier, before adolescence you will see anti social/criminal behaviour
- Usually start before age of 12
- Offender behaviour more serious
- Much more likely to continue offending
Tend to be more likely to have a history of sexual/physical abuse
FEMALE JUVENILE SEX OFFENDERS
- PROPORTION OF FEMALE OFFENDERS DECREASES AS AGE INCREASES
- 1-2% of adults sex offenders are females, 10% juvenile
- 13-18, 10% are women
- Under the age of 12, goes up to 20%
- More likely to be younger females
- PERPETRATORS OFTEN KNOW THEIR VICTIM
- Also, male counterpart not likely at all in juvenile
- PERPETRATORS OFTEN HAVE HISTORY OF ABUSE
- Likely to experience more abuse than male perpetrators
- And by more than one person
- Abuse usually starts before the age of 6
- Often in a situation of female sex offender, recreating the abuse they experienced themselves
WHY JUVENILES SEXUALLY OFFEND
CONTEXT IS IMPORTANT
- Offending or experimentation
- Difficult to determine because:
1. The behaviour could be consensual
2. The young person may be engaging in sexual experimentation
3. The young person maybe be experiencing abuse
Things we need to consider
1. What is the sexual knowledge of that behaviour
2. What is normal sexual behaviour among this age group
ANTECEDENTS TO OFFENDING (what comes first)
- Not causes, but factors that are present when looking at offenders:
- Lack of empathy
- Family dysfunction (most important)
- Excessive use of pornography
- History of abuse
- Substance abuse
CYCLE OF JSO
- Negative self image
- Emotional problems, their own abuse
- Social isolation
- May start to fantasize - They experience a triggering event
- Can be a fight, bad grade, etc
- Causes them to offend and cycle restarts
- Distortions perpetuate the offence
TYPOLOGIES OF JUVENILE SEX OFFENDERS:
PRENTSKY ET AL (2000)
- Distinguishes between those who abuse children, and those who engage in sexual assault
- Child sexual abusers
- Rapists
- Sexually reactive children (has an abuse history so most likely acting out that same pattern)
- Fondlers (offences much less invasive)
- Paraphiliac offenders
- Those who do not fit into the categories (developed in a clinical setting, clinical sample)
- Distinction between:
Conduct disorder: anti social personality disorder but younger than 18
Anti social personality disorder: can only be diagnosed if over the age of 18
MALA IN SE VS MALA PROHIBITUM
MALA IN SE:
(inherently evil about that crime, murder, sexual assault, etc)
MALA PROHIBITUM:
( behaviour that we outlaw, because it conflicts w moral sensibility, current opinion, etc, ex: erotic things, mood altering drugs, etc)
- THE BEG OF PROS ( THE FRASER REPORT, 1985 )
- Prohbited under vagrency laws (no job and therefore unable to provide for family)
- Prositution technically “legal” but most other activities illegal
- (could not communicate for purpose of pros, could not live off the avails: legal for me to sell sex but couldn’t use the money for rent, illegal to keep a body house; living w someone also selling sex, could not stop in a public place for pros)
- Therefore not legal
- 62% of Canadians felt pros was problematic
- CONSTITUTIONAL CHANGES OF PROS (BEDFORD 2013)
- Canada (attorney general) v Bedford (2013)
- Because pros was actually legal, but all other laws aren’t, therefore violated our charter of protection
- Therefore 2013 those laws were struck down
- Protection of communities and exploited persons act (2014)
- Illegal to buy, not illegal to sell (over the age of 18)
- STATUS UNDER NEW LAW OF PROS
- Aim to reduce demand for prostitution
- Pros themselves are victims
- Not a victimless crime
- They are exploited and need protection
- Now okay to solicit for sexual services (BUT CANNOT HAPPEN THROUGH THIRD PARTY, like posting an ad, using another individual)
- BUT need to do it in specific locations; where no children are around, churches, etc
- Argument: by making it illegal to buy, drives pros even further into the shadows making it more dangerous
CHARACTERISTICS OF PROS
- Average age: 28 for females, 35 for males
- Average age of entry for females: 15
- Percent charged between ages of 12-17: 1% (2012)
- Clearance rates for murders of sex workers: 34 (compared to 77-85 for other homicide victims)
3 WAYS TO ENTER PROFESSION OF PROS
- 12-16: exploitation
- Through the “big sister” who recruits someone who is naïve, needs cash
- Not exploiting, just a “here I have a way”
- At first it’s fun, so much cash, etc - The individual decides themselves to engage in sex work
- Pros and cons
- Tend to be older
- Through the “big sister” who recruits someone who is naïve, needs cash
6 TYPES OF PROS (FROM WORST TO BEST)
- STREETWALKERS
- Most at risk for violence and criminalization
- Most researched
- Most often targeted by ppl who don’t agree
- BAR GIRLS
- Sex workers who hang out in bars
- Management usually knows
- MASSAGE PARLOUR PROS
- Happy endings
- Coded language
- HOUSE PROS
- Brothel or a body house
- RAP SESSION BOOTH PROS
- Red light district type
- Might be in a bookstore, sex shop
- ESCORT SERVICE PROS
- Top of hierarchy
- Can make a lot more money
- “this person was hired for dancing”
MALE CHARACTERISTICS OF PROS
KEY DEMOGRAPHICS
- Aboriginal heritage
- Involvement in child protection services
- Education
- Running away
- Getting thrown out
- Sexual and physical violation
- Witnessing aggression while growing
- Involvement with police
SEXUAL ORIENTATION
- Gay for pay
- Straight for pay
- Transgender