Final exam review Flashcards
Define divine law
law is the product of God’s will which people incorporated into their own legal codes
Define natural law
certain standards have existed, and will always exist and that law and justice should reflect these long-term standards
- assumed to be universal
Define positive law
Law is as the law makers sat it is
Legal formalism
the judge should follow the law as is written and does not have the authority to change it
Legal realism
courts are the real authors of the law
Feminist jurisprudence
based on the argument that the law upholds political, economic and social inequality for women
- made for men and has a strong gender bias
Critical legal studies
- it’s about value-choices. the law exists to support the interests of people in power
- law and lawmaking are not neutral and can be used as an instrument for injustice and oppression
Virtue jurisprudence
the law exists to promote virtuous behaviour
Marxist jurisprudence
the law is a tool for the ruling parties: the rich and the powerful
- not a tool for change and reform
Sociological jurisprudence
legal decisions should be judged in light of the effects they will have on society
- a court’s decision must be shaped by the social effects it will create
Spirit of the law
- read between the lines
- judges should consider the underlying values and purposes of the law when applying it.
Popular morality
belief that the voice of the community should shape the court’s decision
- justice should reflect the moral of the majority
Critical morality
argues that courts should listen to the more defensible and reasonable view of the community, not necessarily the majority.
What are the three primary sources of law?
- customs and conventions
- religion
- social and political influences
Customs and conventions
customs: general practices and rules generated in ancient society to deal with everyday situations.
- passed on between generations via word of mouth
- some continued to exist despite becoming unnecessary and others became written laws.
conventions: agreements or arrangements that are not necessarily part of a formal contract but binding to the parties involved
- also may mean doing things simply because it is the way they have always been done
- long-standing unwritten rules often considered binding contracts
Religion
primary source of law
“Supremacy of God” is included in the charter but the church has no official position in the Canadian legal system
- inclusion shows religion has helped shape our laws
- Mosaic law: the 10 commandments
- some have stayed, some have become irrelevant like children can’t play in the park on Sunday, illegal to shop in Ontario on Sunday, children recite “lord’s prayer” before every school day.
Social and political influences
- law cannot be separated from social, political, economic and cultural characteristics of a country
- laws reflect the values of citizens - individual rights and freedoms, protection of people and property, and even distribution of wealth
- some might disagree.
- role of women
- 1983- official repeal of the offence of rape
- laws that are too far behind or ahead of societal values are unlikely to be followed.
Secondary sources of law
- constitutions
- statute law
- case law
constitutions
- enacted in 1982
- basic blueprint for governance
- gives government the power to make laws (jurisdiction)
- charter of rights and freedoms is part of the constitution therefore laws must be based around it
statute law
- a law made by people elected at a federal or provincial level
- also includes municipal bylaws
- ex: criminal code, highway traffic act, education act, etc
case law
- recorded decisions of judges on past cases
- involves enacting legal principles from past judgements onto new situations
- rule of precedent (stare decisis)
law as a legal concept
when we label laws as “good” or “bad”, we state whether they conform to terms like “justice”, “equality”, “morality”, and “legitimacy”.
we value laws based on their qualities rather than their purpose
ex: we agree that stopping child abuse is a valuable purpose of the law but most of us would object to giving police unlimited access to our homes to fulfill this purpose.
law as a legal system
law comprises a network of agencies, institutions, and procedures developed to perform a certain function
law as a set of rules
prescribe our rights and freedoms. they should reflect our ideals and values but may appear to restrict freedoms.
Jurisprudence
study of different interpretations and meanings of law
- helps us better understand the law
- allows us to predict future directions of law
- gives us a means of understanding our legal heritage
why do we need laws?
- law is an instrument of society, reflecting the values of society
- a mechanism for resolving disputes
- protects people, rights, and property
- provides order in society
different perspectives for jurisprudence
history, religion, customs, morals, philosophy
Ancient tribal societies
Small bands of hunters who developed a standard of behaviours to deal with every day situations.
- not a lot of rules and passed down by word of mouth
- no strict punishment for fear of being outcast
- common punishment
Egyptians
- religion was very important to these people
- people lived in fear of disobeying their god
- for many centuries priests or religious leaders and the ruler worked independently
- in Egypt around 3000 BC the ruler and religion came together
- the pharaoh was seen as a link between humans and gods
- people had a religious and civic duty to follow the rules
Code of Hammurabi
- Hammurabi was the king of Babylon in 1750 BC
- first account of written laws
- carved into pillars in the centre of the temple so no one could say they didn’t know what the law was
- the laws were very harsh and had strict punishment
- punishment followed principle of retribution (an eye for an eye)
- no distinction between a deliberate and an accidental act
- sometimes the innocent were unfairly punished
- but no one was punished until he was tried and found guilty.
Hebrew or mosaic law
- based on the Ten Commandments that god supposedly presented to Moses on top of mount Sinai amid thunder and lightning
- Moses was to interpret these laws and rule accordingly, people had little say in it
- rules were less harsh than Hammurabi
- distinction between accidental and deliberate acts so the law tried the guilty and protected the innocent
- problem: Moses was both the legislator and the magistrate. People had no say.
Greek law
- first Democracy
- all male citizens were considered free and equal before the law
- could participate in deciding if someone was guilty or innocent
- first jury system
- it was thought a man should be judged by his fellow citizens
- no judge
- jury of about 1000 citizens
- a disc was deposited into a ballot box: solid = innocent and disc with a hole = guilty
- positive: people can hear and decide on cases
- negative: jury didn’t discuss verdicts so could be a biased result since family and friends could volunteer to be on the jury
- women, children and non citizens were not considered equal