Final Exam Flashcards
What is Phenomenology?
the study of how things seem to the conscious person.
What are the 2 mysteries of consciousness?
- the problem of other minds
- the mind-body problem.
What is the Problem of Other Minds?
the fundamental difficulty we have in perceiving the consciousness of others.
- There is no clear way to distinguish a conscious person from someone who might do and say all the same things as a conscious person from someone who might do and say all the same things as conscious person but who is not conscious.
- Philosophers have called this hypothetical nonconscious person a zombie, in reference to the living-yet-dead creatures of horror films.
- A philosopher’s zombie could talk about experiences (”The lights are so bright!”) and even seem to react to them (wincing and turning away) but might not be having any inner experience at all.
- None of us will ever know for sure that another person is not a zombie.
- Even the consciousness metre used by anaesthesiologists falls short.
- It doesn’t give the anaesthesiologist any special insight into what it is like to be the patient on the operating table; it only predicts whether patients will say they were conscious.
- we lack the ability to directly perceive the consciousness of others.
- The problem of other minds also means there is no way you can tell if another person’s experience of anything is at all like yours.
- Eg. maybe someone is seeing what you see as blue and just calling it red in a consistent way.
What is the Mind-Body Problem?
- the issue of how the mind is related to the brain and body.
- Rene Descartes is famous for proposing, among other things, that the human body is a machine made of physical matter but that the human mind or soul is a separate entity made of a “thinking substance”.
- He suggested that the mind has its effects on the brain and body through the pineal gland, a small structure located near the centre of the brain.
- was not true → is an endocrine gland
- We know now the mind and brain are connected everywhere to each other. → “the mind is what the brain does”.
- But Descartes was right in pointing out the difficulty of reconciling the physical body with the mind.
Most psychologists assume that mental events are intimately tied to what?
- brain events, such that every thought, perception, or feeling is associated with a particular pattern of activation or neurons in the brain.
- Thinking about a particular person, for instance, occurs with a unique array of neural connections and activations.
- If the neurons repeat that pattern, then you must be thinking the same person; conversely, if you think of the person, the brain activity occurs in that pattern.
- One set of studies suggests that the brain’s activities precede the activities of the conscious mind.
- Researchers measured the electrical activity in the brains of volunteers by placing sensors on their scalps as they repeatedly decided when to move their hand.
- Participants were also asked to indicate exactly when they consciously chose to move by reporting the position of a dot moving rapidly around the face of a clock just at the point of the decision.
- As a rule, the brain begins to show electrical activity about half a second before voluntary action (535 milliseconds, to be exact) and about one-third of a second (331 milliseconds) before the person’s conscious decision to move.
- The feeling that you are consciously willing your actions, it seems, may be a result rather than a cause of your brain activity.
- Although your personal intuition is that you think of an action and then do it, these experiments suggest that your brain is getting started before either the thinking or the doing, paving the way for both thought and action.
- eg. the reported time of consciously willing the finger to move follows the brain activity.
Back in 1950, Alan Turing famously proposed that to conclude that a machine can exhibit human-like intelligence, it must be able to what?
be able to act in ways that are indistinguishable from humans.
- His proposed method of demonstrating this, the “Turing test” is by having a person observe a conversation between a person and a computer, such as by reading out their responses to questions posed in that conversation.
- The machine/computer is said to have passed the test if the observers is unable to accurately determine which is the machine/computer and which is the human.
What characterizes consciousness?
Consciousness had 4 basic properties (intentionality, unity, selectivity, and transience); that it occurs on 3 different levels; and that it includes a range of different contents.
How many basic properties does consciousness have and what are they?
had 4 basic properties
- intentionality,
- unity,
- selectivity, and
- transience
it occurs on 3 different levels; and it includes a range of different contents.
What are the 4 basic properties of consciousness?
- Consciousness has intentionality, which is the quality of being directed towards an object. Consciousness is always about something.
- Despite all the lush detail you see in your mind’s eye, the kaleidoscope of sights and sounds and feelings and thoughts, the object of your consciousness at any one moment is focused on just a small part of all of this.
- To describe how this works, psychologists refer to three other properties of consciousness: unity, selectivity, and transience.
- Consciousness has unity, which is resistance to division, or the ability to integrate information from all of the body’s senses into one coherent whole.
- as you read this book, your five senses are taking in a great deal of information: your eyes are scanning lots of black squiggles on a page (or screen) while also sensing an enormous array of shapes, colours, depths, and textures in your periphery; your hands are grpping a heavy book (or computer); your butt and feet may sense pressure from gravity pulling you against a chair or floor; and you may be listening to music while smelling the odour of food cooking.
- Although your body is constantly sensing an enormous amount of information from the world around you, your brain — amazingly — integrates all of this information into the experience of one unified consciousness (or two, in the case of the split-brain patients).
- Consciousness has selectivity, the capacity to include some objects but not others.
- While binding the many sensations around you into a coherent whole, your mind must make decisions about which pieces of information to include and which to exclude.
- This property is shown through studies of dichotic listening - a task in which people wearing headphones hear different messages in each ear.
- Research participants were instructed to repeat aloud the words they heard in one ear while a different message was presented to the other ear.
- As a result of focusing on the words they were supposed to repeat, participants noticed little of the second message, often not even realizing that at some point it changed from English to German!
- So consciousness filters out some information.
- At the same time, participants did notice when the voice in the unattended ear changed from a man’s to a woman’s, suggesting that the selectivity of consciousness can also work to tune in other information.
- The conscious system is most inclined to select information of special interest to the listener; for example, in what has come to be known as the cocktail-party phenomenon - a phenomenon in which people tune in one message even while they filter out others nearby.
- In the dichotic listening situation, eg, research participants are especially likely to notice if their own name is spoken into the unattended ear.
- people are more sensitive to their own name than to others’ names, for instance, even during sleep. → this is why, when you are trying to wake sb, it is best to use the person’s name.
4. Consciousness has transience, or the tendency to change. - The mind wanders not just sometimes, but incessantly, from one “right now” to the next “right now” and then on to the next.
- William James described consciousness as a “stream”.
- Prose written in the “stream of consciousness” style illustrates the whirling, chaotic, and constantly changing flow of consciousness.
- Our own stream of consciousness may flow in this way partly bc of the limited capacity of the conscious mind. We humans can hold only so much information in mind at one time, after all, so when we select more information, some of what is currently there must disappear. As a result, our focus of attention keeps changing.
- While binding the many sensations around you into a coherent whole, your mind must make decisions about which pieces of information to include and which to exclude.
What are the levels of consciousness?
- In its minimal form, consciousness is just a connection between the person and the world.
- When you sense the sun coming in through the window you might turn towards the light.
- Such minimal consciousness - is a low-level kind of sensory awareness and responsiveness that occurs when the mind inputs sensations and may output behaviour.
- This kind of sensory awareness and responsiveness could even happen when someone pokes you while you’re asleep and you turn over.
- Something seems to register in your mind, at least in the sense that you experience it, but you may not think at all about having had the experience.
- Consider the feeling of waking up on a spring morning as rays of sun stream across your pillow. Being fully conscious mean that you are also aware that you are having this experience.
- The critical ingredients that accompanies full consciousness is that you know and are able to report your mental state.
- being fully conscious means that you are aware of having a mental state while you are experiencing the mental state itself.
- eg. when you have a hurt leg and mindlessly rub it, for instance, your pain may be minimally conscious. → after all, you seem to be experiencing pain because you have acted and are indeed rubbing your leg. It is only when you realize that it hurts, though, that you become fully conscious of the pain.
- eg. when your drive and realize you don’t remember the past 15 mins of driving → were minimally conscious.
- Full consciousness involves a certain consciousness of oneself; the person notices the self in a particular mental state (”Here I am, reading this sentence.”)
- Self-consciousness is different.
- Sometimes consciousness is entirely flooded with the self. (”Not only am I reading this sentence, but I have a pimple on the end of my nose today that makes me feel like I’m guiding a sleigh.”)
- Self-consciousness focuses on the self to the exclusion of almost everything else.
- William james (1890) and other theorists have suggested that self-consciousness is yet another distinct level of consciousness in which the person’s attention is drawn to the self as an object.
- Most people report experiencing such self-consciousness when they are embarrassed; when they find themselves the focus of attention in a group; when someone focuses a camera on them; or when they are deeply introspective about their thoughts, feelings, or personal qualities.
- Self-consciousness brings with it a tendency to evaluate yourself and notice your shortcomings.
- Eg. ppl go out of their way to avoid mirrors when they’ve done something they are ashamed of.
- Mirrors also can prevent people from doing something they are ashamed of in the first place.
Can animals be self-conscious?
- Most animals like dogs or cats can’t follow this path to civilization.
- Chimpanzees that have spent time with mirrors sometimes behave in ways that suggest they recognize themselves in a mirror.
- To examine this, researchers painted an odourless red dye over the eyebrow of an anaesthetized chimp and then watched when the chimp was presented with a mirror.
- If the chimp interpreted the mirror image as a representation of some other chimp with an unusual approach to cosmetics, we would expect it just to look at the mirror or perhaps to reach towards it.
- But the chimp reached towards its own eye as it looked into the mirror — not the mirror image — suggesting that it recognized the image as a reflection of itself.
- occurs also with animals such as chimps and orangutans, possibly dolphins, maybe even elephants and magpies recognize their own mirror images.
- One study showed that after training monkeys in how to use a mirror to locate objects in space, they gained the ability to pass the mirror test/
What are the disorders of consciousness?
- Patients in a coma look a bit like they are deeply asleep.
- their eyes are closed, they do not communicate, and they do not respond when someone shouts their name, or pinches their toe. They seem to be completely unaware.
- Patients in a vegetative state alternate between eyes-open and eyes-closed states: There are regular period of time in which they appear to be “awake”.
- Patients may move their limbs and eyes, swallow, smile, cry, grunt, moan, or scream, but — and this is key to the diagnosis — none of these behaviours is produced reliably in response to external stimulation.
- In other words, no evidence exists that patients are aware of themselves or their surroundings, as demonstrated by reliable, purposeful responding to sensory stimulation (such as being touched or hearing their name called)
- Patients in a minimally conscious state can respond reliably, but somewhat inconsistently, to sensory stimulation.
- Locked-in syndrome is a rare condition in which patients have full awareness but cannot demonstrate it, because they cannot move any voluntary muscles.- is not a disorder of consciousness but can be mistaken for one.
- eg. “The Diving Bell and the Butterfly” by journal Jean-Dominique Bauby after he suffered a massive stroke that left him with locked-in syndrome. → was written by hm blinking his left eyelid, which he did for 4 hours a day over 10 months.
- patients with locked in syndrome can sometimes move their eyes voluntarily up and down, and can use this movement to communicate.
How do doctors determine whether a patient is aware?
- Traditionally, to see if a patient is recovering awareness, physicians observe a patient’s behaviour and judge whether the patient is repeatedly able to respond to commands (like “raise your left arm”), or to the sound of their name being spoken.
- If the patient has trouble controlling their body, then this test can be misleading.
- Recently, brain-imaging methods have given researchers and physicians a direct window into brain activity.
- Brain activity, is, after all, the wellspring of behaviour — for the left arm to be raised, there first must be a specific pattern of arm-raising activity in the brain.
- We know that, out of every 100 ppl diagnosed as being in a vegetative state using traditional bedside assessment, between 10 and 40 will turn out to be conscious to some degree when assessed using these more sensitive measures, and about a third of patients diagnosed as minimally conscious may be fully conscious.
What is a more modern approach to testing people’s level of consciousness.
- A more modern approach is the use of experience-sampling or ecological momentary assessment (EMA) techniques, in which people are asked to report their conscious experiences at particular times.
- eg. Equipped with survey apps loaded on to their smartphone participants often are asked to record their current thoughts when prompted (eg. via a push notification) at random times throughout the day.
- Experience-sampling studies show that consciousness is dominated by the immediate environment — what we see, feel, hear, taste, and small.
- Researchers who use experience-sampling methods to record the emotions people experience during everyday activities have found interesting results.
- One study collected data from over 900 working women by asking them to reflect on the events of the past day and record how they felt while engaging in each activity.
- People score lowest on positive affect when commuting, working, and doing housework. → unfortunately, this is how we spend a large part of our day.
- The American women in this study reported having the most positive affect while being intimate with another person, although they only did this for 12 minutes a day.
- In survey studies, parents often report that they are happiest when spending time with their children; but when asked about actual events of the prior day using these daily experience-sampling methods, being with one’s children ranked just two ticks above housework and well below other activities such as shopping, watching TV, and making more children.
What is one reason we often avoid boredom when doing nothing?
- One reason that we often avoid boredom when doing nothing is that our mind shifts into a period of daydreaming, a state of consciousness in which a seemingly purposeful flow of thoughts comes to mind.
- When thoughts drift along this way, it may seem as if you are just wasting time.
- The brain, however, is active even when it has no specific task at hand.
- The mental work done in daydreaming was examined in an fMRI study of people resting in the scanner (Masone t al., 2007).
- Usually, people in brain-scanning studies don’t have time to daydream much bc they are kept busy with mental tasks; scans cost money and researchers want to get as much data as possible for their bucks.
- But when ppl are not busy, they still show a widespread pattern of activation in many areas of the brain — now known as the default network.
- The study by Mason and colleagues revealed that this network become activated whenever people worked on a mental task that they knew so well that they could daydream while doing it.
- The areas of the default network are known to be involved in thinking about social life, about the self, and about the past and future — all the usual haunts of the daydreaming mind.
What is mental control?
the attempt to change conscious states of mind.
eg. - Thoughts that return again and again, or problem-solving attempts that never seem to succeed, can come to dominate consciousness.
- When this happens, people may exert mental control
- Eg. sb troubled by a recurring worry about the future (”What if I can’t get a decent job when I graduate?”) might choose to try not to think about this because it causes too much anxiety and uncertainty.
- Whenever this thoughts comes to mind, the person engages in thought suppression, the conscious avoidance of a thought.
What is Thought Suppression?
the conscious avoidance of a thought
- Eg. sb troubled by a recurring worry about the future (”What if I can’t get a decent job when I graduate?”) might choose to try not to think about this because it causes too much anxiety and uncertainty.
- Whenever these thoughts comes to mind, the person engages in thought suppression, the conscious avoidance of a thought.
What are the downsides of thought suppression?
- Fyodor Dostoyevsky: “Try to pose for yourself this task: not to think of a polar bear, and you will see that the cursed thing will come to mind every minute.”
- Inspired by this observation, Daniel Wegner and his colleagues (1989) gave people this exact task in the laboratory.
- Participants were asked to try not to think about a white bear for 5 mins while they recorded their thoughts aloud into a tape recorder.
- In addition, they were aksed to ring a bell if the thought of a white bear came to mind.
- On average, they mentioned the white bear or rang the bell (indicating the thought) more than once per minute.
- Result: Thought suppression simply didn’t work and instead produced a flurry of returns of the unwanted thought.
- What’s more, when some researcher participants later were specifically asked to change tasks and deliberately think about a white bear, they became oddly preoccupied with it.
- A graph of their bells rings shows that for these participants, the white bear came to mind far more often that it did for ppl who had only been asked to think about the bear from the outset, with no prior suppression.
- This rebound effect of thought suppression - the tendency of a thought to return to consciousness with greater frequency following suppression, suggests that attempts at mental control may be difficult indeed.
- The act of trying to suppress a thought may itself cause that thought to return to consciousness in a robust way.
What is the Rebound Effect of Thought Suppression?
- the tendency of a thought to return to consciousness with greater frequency following suppression
- What’s more, when some researcher participants later were specifically asked to change tasks and deliberately think about a white bear, they became oddly preoccupied with it.
- A graph of their bells rings shows that for these participants, the white bear came to mind far more often that it did for ppl who had only been asked to think about the bear from the outset, with no prior suppression.
- This rebound effect of thought suppression , suggests that attempts at mental control may be difficult indeed.
- The act of trying to suppress a thought may itself cause that thought to return to consciousness in a robust way.
How can Processes Outside of Conscious Control Stymie attempts at Conscious Control?
- Trying to consciously achieve one task may produce precisely the opposite outcome!
- These ironic effects seem most likely to occur when the person is distracted or under stress.
- Eg. people who are distracted while they are trying to get into a good mood, for example, tend to become sad and those who are distracted while trying to relax actually tend to become more anxious than those who are not trying to relax.
- Likewise, an attempt not to overshoot a golf putt, undertaken during distraction, often yields the unwanted overshot.
- The theory of ironic processes of mental control proposes that such ironic errors occur because the mental process that monitors errors can itself produce them.
- the irony about the attempt to not think of the white bear, for instance, is that a small portion of the mind is searching for the white bear.
- The ironic monitoring process us not present in consciousness.
- Rather, the ironic monitor is a process of the mind that works outside of consciousness, making us sensitive to all the things we do not want to think, feel, or do so that we can notice and consciously take steps to regain control if these things come back to mind.
- As this unconscious monitoring whirs along in the background, it unfortunately increases the person’s sensitivity to the very thought that is unwanted.
- Ironic processes are mental functions that are needed for effective mental control — they help in the process of banishing a thought from consciousness — but they can sometimes yield the very failure they seem designed to overcome.
What is the Theory of Ironic Processes of Mental Control?
- The theory of ironic processes of mental control proposes that such ironic errors occur because the mental process that monitors errors can itself produce them.
- the irony about the attempt to not think of the white bear, for instance, is that a small portion of the mind is searching for the white bear.
- The ironic monitoring process us not present in consciousness.
- Rather, the ironic monitor is a process of the mind that works outside of consciousness, making us sensitive to all the things we do not want to think, feel, or do so that we can notice and consciously take steps to regain control if these things come back to mind.
- As this unconscious monitoring whirs along in the background, it unfortunately increases the person’s sensitivity to the very thought that is unwanted.
- Ironic processes are mental functions that are needed for effective mental control — they help in the process of banishing a thought from consciousness — but they can sometimes yield the very failure they seem designed to overcome.
- eg. an attempt not to overshoot a golf putt, undertaken during distraction, often yields the unwanted overshot.
eg. Eg. people who are distracted while they are trying to get into a good mood, for example, tend to become sad and those who are distracted while trying to relax actually tend to become more anxious than those who are not trying to relax.
What is the Freudian Unconscious?
- Freud’s psychoanalytic theory viewed conscious thought as the surface of a much deeper mind made up of unconscious processes — but far more than just a collection of hidden processes.
- Feud described a dynamic unconscious - an active system encompassing a lifetime of hidden memories, the person’s deepest instincts and desires, and the person’s inner struggle to control these forces.
- the dynamic unconscious may contain hidden sexual thoughts about one’s parents, for example, or destructive urges aimed at a helpless infant — the kinds of thoughts ppl keep secret from others and may not even acknowledge to themselves.
- According to Freud’s theory, the unconscious is a force to be held in check by sth he called repression - a mental process that removes unacceptable thoughts and memories from consciousness and keeps them in the unconscious.
- Freud believed that without repression, a person might think, do, or say every unconscious impulse or animal urge, no matter how selfish or immoral.
- With repression, these desires are held in the recesses of the dynamic unconscious.
Where did Freud look for the evidence of the unconscious mind?
- Feud looked for evidence of the unconscious mind in speech errors and lapses of consciousness, or what are commonly called Freudian slips.
- Eg. forgetting the name of someone you dislike is a slip that seems to have special meaning.
- Freud believes that errors are not random and instead have some surplus meaning that may appear to have been created by an intelligent unconscious mind, even though the person consciously disavows them.
- suggesting that there is special meaning to any one thing a person says, or that there is a pattern to a series of random events is not the same as scientifically predicting and explaining when and why an event should happen.
- Unfortunately, Freud’s theories about the unconscious have not been supported by scientific research over the past 100 years.