Final Exam Flashcards
General Intent
D knows with substantial certainty that consequences will result from his act
Specific Intent
D intends to bring about injury
Transferred Intent
Only applies to:
i. Assault
ii. Battery
iii. False imprisonment
iv. Trespass to land
v. Trespass to chattels
Are minors/incompetents responsible for their intentional torts?
Yes, requisite Intent
Damages for battery
- actual damage not required
- P can recover nominal damages if no actual
- punitive damages apply if D acted with malice
Damages for assault
- actual damages not required
- P can recover nominal
- P can recover punitive
Damages for false imprisonment
- actual damages not required
- nominal available
- punitive if malice
Damages for IIED
- actual damages REQUIRED
- must show sever emotional injury
- nominal does not apply
- punitive is available
Damages for Trespass to land
- entry onto the land
- nominal damages are available
- actual damage not required
Damages for trespass to chattel
- actual damage REQUIRED
- nominal damages do not apply
- dispossession = actual harm
Damages for Conversion
- full fair market value
2. replevin (return of the chattel)
Definition of Consent
willingness in fact for conduct to occur. can be express or implied
When is the defense of consent available?
a. If the P, who has the capacity to consent or by a person empowered to consent for him,
b. expressly or impliedly
c. consented to the particular conduct, or substantially the same conduct
Definition of apparent consent
- If words or conduct are reasonably understood by another to be intended as consent, they constitute apparent consent and are as effective as consent in fact
- That which a reasonable person would infer from P’s conduct
- Consent may be inferred as a matter of custom – if custom is to perform an act them consent inferred
Definition of consent implied by law
- May occur where the action is necessary to save a life (emergency situations) where the person is incapable of consenting
a. May be found to be an emergency by trier of fact
Who cannot consent to tortious conduct?
Mentally incompetent, drunk, and very young children (consent may be allowed if the incompetent person is capable of appreciating the nature, extent, and probable consequences of the conduct )
When is self-defense available?
a. When reasonable grounds to believe that he or she
b. Is being or is about to be attacked
c. May use reasonably proportionate force for protection against potential injury
Can you use deadly force in self-defense?
May NOT use deadly force unless he reasonably believes he is in danger of serious bodily injury; if you reasonably believe you are in danger of death or bodily harm, you can use deadly force
Majority v. Minority on self-defense
- Minority: “retreat to the wall” – has to try to get away from the attack
- Majority (TN): “stand your ground”
Majority v. Minority view defense of others
a. Minority view
i. Actor steps into shoes of the person defending and are privileged ONLY to the extent that the other person actually would be
b. Majority view (TN)
i. Actor is privileged to use force if has a reasonable belief (even though mistaken) that the other person has a right to self-defense
When is the defense of real property available?
a. Actor privileged to use reasonable force,
b. NOT intended or likely to cause death or serious bodily harm,
c. To prevent or terminate another’s intrusion
d. Upon the actors land
e. IF the intrusion is not privileged,
f. The actor reasonably believes that the intrusion can be terminated only by the force used,
g. AND the actor has first requested them to leave and they have refused or the actor believes the request will be useless/harm will be done before it can be made
Defense of Personal Property
A person wrongfully deprived of chattel is privileged to use reasonable force to recover the chattel immediately after its dispossession – only when it can be done without unnecessary violence or beach of peace (HOT PURSUIT)
Public Necessity
a. permits the defendant, acting as the champion of the public, to destroy, damage, or use the real or personal property of another as long as the defendant reasonably believes that doing so is necessary to avert an imminent public disaster
b. complete privilege – pays $0 to P
Private Necessity
a. A defendant is privileged to enter or remain on land in the possession of another IF it is or reasonably appears to be necessary to prevent serious personal harm; when doing so out of private necessity
b. Private necessity is an incomplete or partial privilege bc it allows D to commit the tort but D responsible for any actual damages he causes in doing so
I. No liability for technical tort but must pay for actual damages caused
2 types of causation
- Cause in fact (but for cause)
2. Proximate cause (legal cause)
Learned Hand Formula
B < P x L (burden, possibly, the gravity of harm)
Reasonable Prudent Person (includes professionals)
Generally, SoC determined by a reasonable man under like circumstances (objective standard)
Definition of informed consent doctrine
physician required to adequately inform patient about treatment protocol, available alternatives, and collateral risks; requires full disclosure of all material risks
Dram shop acts
generally establishes civil liability of establishment arising out of sale of alcohol to visibly intoxicated persons or minor who subsequently causes death or injury to a third party as result of alcohol related car crashes and other accidents
Direct evidence
evidence of testimony by a witness about a matter within personal knowledge that does not require drawing an inference