Final Exam Flashcards
What were the most famous early childhood maltreatment cases in the U.S.
Wee Care Margaret Kelley Michaels, McMartin Preschool, Kern County, CA
What were the features of early cases
Highly suggestive interviewing techniques, allegations of widespread child abuse with bizarre features like satanic rituals and child sacrifice, people imprisoned based solely on children’s testimony
Traditionalist perspective
Pre-19070. Did not value children and rights. Did not think children could be helpful in court because early research shows they forget a lot and are prone to incorporating fantastical ideas
What caused a shift from the traditionalist to revisionist perspective
Children valued more in society. legislation like CAPTA and mandated reporting passed
Revisionist perspective
Children can be helpful and we should respect their abilities to talk about what happened. They cannot be wrong when it comes to things that happened to their body, so we should always believe them and it is okay to use suggestive techniques, especially because they will be reluctant
What caused the shift fro the revisionist perspective to the current view
- Early high profile cases- are children always accurate if they’re coming up with these fantastic claims with no evidence 2. Literature review by Ceci and Bruck shows that children can be influenced by suggestive interview techniques. Interviewers are responsible for how they talk to to children
Current View
Children can be reliable witnesses, but we cannot overestimate their abilities. Interviewers are responsible for talking to them in a way that gets an accurate and complete disclosure. They need to take the child’s abilities and limitations into account and use a child-centered approach
Believability
In psychology, a measure of accuracy, but not an objective measure in law
Competency
Witness has the ability to observe, remember, communicate, and tell the truth
2 types of competency
basic and truth-lie
What is tied to an increase in honesty
Asking children to promise to tell the truth. Truth-lie comprehension tests do not lead to an increase in honesty
Who determines competency
the judge
Credibility
Subjective juror opinion on whether children’s statements are believable
Reliability
statements are consistently good in quality or performance; should be able to be trusted
Beyond the ken of the jury
expert witness must have information beyond what the average juror would know
Hearsay
a statement made prior to court proceedings that is repeated in court
3 hearsay components
1) statement describing an event 2) statement made prior to court proceedings, where it is repeated 3) statement repeated to prove what person said actually happened
Why is hearsay usually inadmissible
you cannot cross-examine the person that made the hearsay statement in court
3 main exceptions to hearsay rule
excited utterance, medical diagnosis and treatment, and residual hearsay exception
excited utterance exception
describes a startling event; made when child is under emotional stress caused by event. some factors considered: child’s speech pattern, amount of time between event and disclosure, spontaneity of statement
medical diagnosis and treatment exception
statements made to medical professionals about medical history, present symptoms, pain and other sensations, and cause of illness or injury. needs to be made with motive to obtain diagnosis or treatment, with understanding that level of honesty can affect treatment and well-being
residual hearsay exception
Residual hearsay exception: reliable hearsay that doesn’t fit into other hearsay categories. Some factors considered are spontaneity, consistent statements, developmentally unusual sexual knowledge, and idiosyncratic detail.
types of questions
open-ended recall prompts, focused questions, recall-detailed questions, option-posing questions, and suggestive prompts
open-ended prompts
Invitations to talk about an experience. Elicit info from free-recall memory. Ex. Tell me everything that happened
focused questions
prompt children to provide specific detail. Ex. Tell me about his truck
recall-detailed questions
Wh-questions
option-posing questions
provide information for children to accept or reject. Ex. Multiple choice, yes/no
suggestive prompts
suggesting information children have not yet mentioned in the current interview, including explicitly leading questions
key to talking with kids
we don’t guide their terminology
4 types of words that are particularly difficult for children
prepositions, pronouns, temporal words, kinship terms
Elizabeth Loftus TED Talk
Talked about how memory is constructed and reconstructed. Memory changes after suggestion and even false memories of horrific abuse can be suggested
3 basic memory processes
encoding, storage, retrieval
ways to help with language limitations
Use active voice instead of passive voice, avoid negatives and double negatives, one question at a time, simple words, simple phrases, children’s terminology when possible, avoid tag questions, be alert to signals that the child may have difficulty comprehending
Suggestibility
the degree to which children’s encoding, storage, retrieval, and reporting of events can be influenced by a range of social and psychological factors
suggestibility social factors
authority figures, cooperative nature of children, peer pressure, peer conversations and rumors
psychological suggestibility factors
cognitive skills: source monitoring, confabulation, egocentric thinking, reality monitoring, and theory of mind. reconstructive nature of memories leave it open to errors, bias, and false memories. language- pronunciation errors, using words without knowing what they mean in all contexts, trouble with temporal words, pronouns, prepositions, and kinship terms
what is the most important determinant of memory capacity?
age
suggestive interviewing techniques
stereotype induction, selective feedback/reinforcement, repeated questions, suggesting info a child has not provided
Sam Stone Study
stereotype induction (sam is clumsy). kids that got stereotype and suggestive interviewing (shown false evidence) were much more likely to say they saw Sam do bad things
Paco study
selective reinforcement. kids given positive feedback about responses were most likely to say yes that both plausible and bizarre events happened
rumor study
highly detailed rumors will make kids believed they experienced false event. rumors are more damaging when they come from peers, as opposed to overheard adult conversations
T/F: sexual behavior problems are rare
true
T/F: behavioral indicators are enough to diagnose sexual abuse on their own
false
other causes that lead to sexual behavior problems
hereditary factors, substandard parenting, family violence, exposure to media
T/F: some interest in sexual parts or behavior is a normal part of child development
true
T/F: early sexual curiosity is reinforcing because the physical sensations that maintain sexual interest are present early in life
true
T/F: sexually curious behavior drops off after early childhood
false, children just hide it better because they know adults disapprove
Logical fallacies
a mistake in reasoning where base rates are used incorrectly or someone uses one truth to make a generalization about another, but draws a false conclusion
T/F: most CSA perpetrators are boyfriends and husbands. Therefore, most boyfriends and husbands are CSA perpetrators
false
T/F: anxiety rates are very high in abused children. So, in a large sample of anxious children, most of them are probably abused
false
T/F: children with developmental delays or intellectual disabilities are at a higher risk of being abused
true
What should interviewers do before meeting with a kid with ID
gather information about the nature and extent of their disability. get an idea of their strengths and limitations. see what accommodations they might need, like more frequent breaks or a support person
what is a yes bias
a tendency for children with ID to say yes more often to questions
What is a good way to get a general idea of the cognitive abilities of a child with an intellectual disability
determine their mental age. This is done by comparing their IQ score with peers of the same chronological age
T/F: most kids with intellectual disabilities or developmental delays will not get their day in court
true
T/F: children with disabilities cannot be reliable witnesses
false, if questioned in an appropriate way they can provide good info
What is facilitated communication?
A discredited technique that is unfortunately still sometimes used today. A facilitator holds the child’s hand to steady it as they type with one finger or point to letters on a chart
What population is facilitated communication primarily used with
children with autism, but also other nonverbal kids, mainly in schools
Does facilitated communication work? if not, what is really happening?
no. facilitators are subconsciously guiding the child’s hand to type what they are thinking. Essentially putting words in the child’s mouth and communicating complex ideas that they child shows no signs of understanding
How did they disprove facilitated communication?
double blind tests where the facilitator and child were separated by a partition and shown either the same or different pictures. The child always typed what the facilitator saw, not what they saw
What was one reason the efficacy of facilitated communication came into question
a number of children made abuse allegations against family members, with no other evidence. people often believed the allegation made via facilitated communication