Final Exam Flashcards
Inherent (Judicial) Power
2 Points
- Ensure Fair and Just Adjudicative Process
2. Maintain Integrity & Viability of Judiciary/System
Pro Bono Representation
Appointment Power & 3 Justifications
Compellable under Inherent Authority
- Lawyers = Officers of the Court
- Legal Monopoly
- Ethical Obligations
Compelled Pro Bono Representation
2 Main Factors & 5 Sub-Factors
Main Factors
- Plaintiff’s Ability to Obtain His Own Counsel
- Marketability (Quality of Case)
Subsidiary Factors
- Factual Complexity
- Ability of Plaintiff to Investigate Facts
- Existence of Conflicting Testimony
- Plaintiff’s Ability to Present His Claims
- Complexity of Legal Issues
Compelled Pro Bono Representation
4 Marketability Requirements
- Market: Lawyers in Area (Type of Case)
- Access to that Market (Prisoner/Incapacitation Issues)
- Availability of Fee Arrangements
- Reason for Lack of Representation/Denial: A) Indigency or B) Merits
Right to Change Counsel
Requires Court Approval (No Absolute Right once Underway)
- Deniable if Prejudicial to Justice
- Duty to See Case to Completion (Kriegsman)
Ruskin v. Rodgers: Last minute substitution of lawyer would cause Delay and be Prejudicial.
Kriegsman v. Kriegsman: Inability to pay is not a sufficient reason to withdraw (welfare divorce).
Discharged Lawyer Fees
Theory of Recovery & Limitations
Quantum Meruit (Limited by Contract)
- California Rule: Favorable Resolution of Case (Win)
- New York Rule: Resolution Unnecessary
Legal Malpractice
Purpose & 4 Theories
Misconduct or Negligence
-Private Right of Action (Injury & Compensatory)
- Intentional Tort
- Breach of Fiduciary Duty
- Breach of Contract
- Unintentional Tort/Negligence
Malpractice: Negligence
Duty of Care: To Whom It’s Owed
3 Party Types
- Clients
- Non-Clients (Prospectives, Reliance Parties)
- Third Party Beneficiaries
Breach of Fiduciary (UPL & Diligence)
3 Part Standard????
Malpractice: Negligence
Standard of Care
Two Standards and Inapplicable Distinction
Specialist vs. Generalist: Dependent on Lawyer’s Representations
No Urban vs. Rural Distinction
Malpractice: Negligence
Causation
2 Types
Actual: But-For or Substantial Factor
Proximate: Foreseeability
Malpractice: Negligence
Damages
- Direct Damages
2. Consequential Damages (Indirect, but Foreseeable)
Malpractice: 4 Defenses
- Attorney Reasonably Believed Action was Required by Law/Ethics
- Comparative Negligence
- Client Insists on Action
- Statute of Limitations
Malpractice: Statute of Limitations
3 Exceptions
Statute Does NOT Run:
- While Lawyer represents client in this or a substantially similar matter
- Until Lawyer Discloses Harm or Client Should know CLEARLY indicates malpractice
- Until Malpractice Significantly Injures client
Malpractice: Settlement Prohibition
Cannot Condition Settlement on Withdrawal of Complaint or Prevent Complaint