Final Flashcards
1st amendment
Burstyn v. Wilson: expression via motion pictures is included within the free speech and expression guarantees
Miller test
1) work appeals to the prurient interest (average person, contemporary community standards)
2) depicts sexual conduct in a patently offensive way; AND
3) lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value
CPPA
overbroad and unconstitutional; only remote connection between speech encouraging impulses and resulting child abuse
Ferber
Miller test does not apply to child pornography; no discussion of artistic/social value
obscenity
words are of such a nature and used in such circumstances as to create clear and present danger that they will bring about substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent
broadcasting indecency
FCC may regulate indecent broadcasts
after-the-fact content-based regulation
allowed bc of broadcasting’s uniquely pervasive presence and accessibility to children
video games and the 1st Am
Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Ass’n: video games qualify for 1st Am protection
exceptions to video game protection
obscenity, incitement, fighting words
video game company liability
no duty to protect against violence; no foreseeability that player would commit act of violence
speech and criminal action
gov can regulate speech brigaded with action (aiding/abetting) to protect public from criminal and civil wrongs
defamation
1) D published written or verbal;
2) false statement;
3) that was defamatory;
4) concerning P;
5) with actual malice (P = public figure) or negligence (P = private figure); AND
6) damages
libel
defamation in a written or other graphic/published form
slander
spoken defamation
product libel
defamation concerning business or its product
publication
one person, other than P & D, sees or hears material AND understands statement to be defamatory
falsity
substantial truth: does proven truth leave different impression of P than impression created by defamatory falsehood?
truth
absolute defense to defamation
opinions
cannot imply false statements of objective fact; protected under 1st Am
opinion factors
- verifiability
- precise language
- context, including cautionary language
- type of writing or speech
defamatory
- harms reputation in community;
- deters people from associating; OR
- exposes to public hatred, contempt, or ridicule
defamation per se
commission of a crime, loathsome disease, professional or sexual misconduct, racism
defamation per se: remedy
P can recover without proof of injury
defamation per quod
requires some context to understand its defamatory meaning
defamation subject
reputation must be capable of being harmed
defamation & fictional characters
would a reader with knowledge of surrounding circumstances reasonably understand the words referred to P?
defamation determination
legal issue: whether statement is capable of damaging reputation?
factual issue: whether it did?
identification
others reasonably understand P is the one referred to
actual malice
knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth
reckless disregard for the truth
D has actual, subjective doubt about truthfulness of statement
negligence
anything under that which an ordinary, reasonable person would do under the same circumstances
public official
1) elected; OR
2) other gov official if:
- substantial responsibility for gov conduct;
- public interest in qualifications beyond that of a normal official; AND
- statement is about job performance
general purpose public figures
those who achieve such pervasive fame or notoriety that they become public figures in all purposes and contexts
limited-purpose public figures
those who thrust themselves into the forefront of particular public controversies to influence the resolution
limited-purpose public figures: factors
1) voluntary participation in controversy?
2) access to appropriate channels for P to rebut claims?
3) P played prominent role?
defamation: general damages
hurt feelings, mental suffering, or anguish
defamation: special damages
loss of employment, lost income, loss of earning capacity (always must be supported by evidence of injury)