Final Flashcards
1
Q
Weapons of Math Destruction
A
- policing “nuisance” crimes is just a matter of being there–not reported to police otherwise
- difference between crimes of poverty and massive financial crimes–but only one type gets policed (criminalization of poverty)
- WMDs favor efficiency, the Constitution favors fairness
- Amazon model for recidivism vs what actually happens
- the actual “broken windows” study was based on community policing
2
Q
Role of Punishment
A
- philosophy of punishment (what ought to be) conflicts with sociology of control (what is really happening)
- by what right do you punish? (Tolstoy)
- gov is supposed to let us go around free of crime
3
Q
Eastern State Penitentiary
A
1829-1970
- embodiment of reformer ideals–had running water and central heating before White House
- wanted to be ideal–go beyond punishment
- middle of Philadelphia, and massive
- each prisoner got private exercise yard and skylight
- no slacking off–if in cell reading Bible or making craft
4
Q
Auburn Prison
A
- also considered penitentiary–but alternative model
- confinement at night, work together during day (in silence)
- effort to break sense of self
- 10 hour workdays and chain gangs
- state funded, but prisoners isolated so only recourse was God
5
Q
Reductivist
A
- utilitarian justification
- good outcomes of punishment:
1) Deterrence
2) Reform & Rehabilitation
3) Incapacitation (can’t commit crimes while locked up)
6
Q
Retributivist
A
- not concerned with future beneficial consequences
- goes back to code of Hammurabi–“eye for an eye”
7
Q
“Just desserts”
A
- in 1950s and 60s, penal system was part of robust welfare state (social engineering)
- we don’t want to over-punish people–proportionality is very important
- CONCERN: people who are marginalized actually get INCREASED punishment–not just at all
8
Q
Current system:
A
Tension-filled synthesis
9
Q
Durkheim
A
Social solidarity (structural functionalist)
- “passion is the soul of punishment”
- moral indignation is ritualized expression of social values
- punishment is an affirmation of shared beliefs through dutiful outrage which constructs a public wrath
10
Q
Nietzsche
A
- “in punishment there is so much that is FESTIVE”
- punishment gratifies cruel tendencies
- “to witness suffering does one good; to inflict it, even more so”
11
Q
Mead
A
- emotional solidarity of aggression (caused by collective hostility toward offender–ex outside White House when SEAL team 6 killed Bin Laden)
- often it is middle-class moral indignation which gets codified
- courtroom degradation ceremony–ritualized destruction–define accused as enemy of all that is good
- disconnect between declaration (media, public, news) and delivery (behind closed doors)
12
Q
Marx
A
(political economy)
- how is the status quo supported by punishment? (ex we don’t police white-collar crimes)
- all about maintenance and reinforcement
- punishment maps onto economic needs of an era (ex prison labor for industry, monetary fines in monetary economies)
- “less eligibility”–prison makes one less eligible to make money for oneself, which is we do time (money/hr)
13
Q
“less eligibility”
A
prison makes one less eligible to make money for oneself, which is we do time (money/hr)
14
Q
Foucault
A
The "Great Incarcerations": - Thieves into prisons - Lunatics into asylums - Conscripts into barracks - Workers into factories - Children into school We have a lack of imagination
15
Q
Class and Incarceration
A
- Class provides resources to overcome convictions–ex OJ Simpson could get an excellent lawyer, cash bail, and fly in a DNA expert
- our criminal justice system (and prisons in particular) are positioned to respond to the crimes of lower-income people
- also education–75% of state prison inmates did NOT graduate high school, and incarcerated people had 40% less income prior to incarceration
16
Q
Race and Incarceration
A
- little difference in violent crime across races
- disadvantaged neighborhoods (female-headed households, low male economic opportunity, poor schools) experience higher crime rate REGARDLESS of race, but see substantial differences in arrest rates
- National Youth Survey: 3:2 offending rates (African-American vs white), but 4:1 arrest rate–access to lawyers, overpricing, etc
- though African-American youth do tend to do violent behavior longer (normally peaks at 17 and half that by 24)
- longer time spent in poverty, higher consequences, because people are getting married, going to college, and getting jobs
- no difference along race once stepping into adult roles, so labor opportunity is CRUCIAL