Federalism Flashcards
Federal Powers
- maintain military
- declare war
- establish postal system
- set standards for weights and measurements
- protect copyrights and patents
State Powers
- establish local governments
- set up schools
- regulate state commerce
- make marriage regulations
- establish and regulate corporations
Shared Federal and State Powers
- collect taxes
- establish courts
- regulate interstate commerce
- regulate banks
- borrow money
- provide general welfare
- punish criminals
How does the federal system work?
- power of the states is protected by 10th amendment
- all states have an equal level of power
How can amendments to state power be made?
only by a 2/3 majority from all the states
What equal power do all states have?
to set their own tax rates, determine own electoral rules and all have the same degree of decision making power
What are three ways in which federal power has grown?
- supremacy clause
- expanded jurisdiction
- federal grants
What is the supremacy clause?
it establishes that the federal constitution and federal law takes precedence over state constitution and state laws, therefore state governments must follow federal laws
Give an example of the supremacy clause in action
Cooper v Aaron - held that states had to follow Brown v Board of Education because it was a federal decision and federal law is supreme
What is the significance of the supremacy clause?
- allows federal government to stop infringements on rights in the states
- allows federal government to be stronger in response to crisis, therefore increasing publics confidence in government
How is the supremacy clause restricted?
federal government laws do not have supremacy over issues reserved to the states under the 10th amendment
How does the 10th amendment constrain federal power?
the states have retained control over the policy areas reserved to them under the 10th amendment
What two cases can we use to demonstrate how federal power was restricted by the 10th amendment?
United States v Butler
New York v United States
United States v Butler
Agricultural Adjustment Act unconstitutional, Agriculture reserved to the states
New York v. United States
federal requirement for states to assume liability for toxic waste generated within their borders was unconstitutional because it violates 10th amendment
What is meant by an ‘expanded jurisdiction’?
there has been a growth in federal power through broader interpretations of the elastic clause and commerce clause
How has the “Necessary and proper” clause caused a growth in federal power?
- elastic clause being interpreted more broadly
- allows congress to stretch its powers
- concerns that the federal government is acting beyond its powers
- could be seen as corrupt and tyrannical which the FF were keen to avoid
Give an example of when an attempt to exceed the elastic clause was declared unconstitutional
United States v Lopez - held that federal government’s Gun Free School Zones Act was unconstitutional because it exceeded the commerce clause
How does federalism differ under a republican president compared to a democrat president?
republican (like Bush) - traditionally sought to shrink the size and scope of federal government
democrat (like Obama) - sees an increase in federal government activity
How have presidents increased federal power?
through the use of executive agencies
Give examples of executive agencies
- medicare
- obama care
- homeland security
Give examples of Bush expanding federal power
education - No Child Left Behind
economy - 2008 economic crisis
national security - homeland security and defence (response to 9/11)
How did Bush expand federal power during 2008 economic crisis?
Bush intervened by nationalising two mortgage companies and bailing out banks
Gonzales v Raich
determined that Congress did have the power to regulate local activities, such as personal medical marijuana use, through its commerce clause power
Give examples of Obama expanding federal power
economy - economic stimulus package 2009
healthcare - Obamacare and Medicaid
In what policy area did Obama increase federal power the most in?
vastly increased federal power over healthcare - Obamacare and Medicaid