Family Law Flashcards
Marriage Requirements
A valid marriage requries a license and a ceremony.
- License: is required, but failure to obtain renders marraige voidable, not void.
- Ceremony: A valid ceremony requires an authorized religious official, a stae clerk, or a deputy clerk authorized by the county administrative judge. Required, but a defective ceremony renders marriage voidable, not void.
Marriage Requirements (of spouses)
- Age: Persons aged 16-17 must have consent OR be pregnant; Aged 15 must have consent AND be pregnant.
- Gender: ?
- Consanguinity: cannot marry siblings, parents, grandparents, aunts.
-
Bigamy: a married individual may not marry another. The second marriage is a nullity.
- An individual whose spouse has been absent for seven years may petition the court to declare spouse dead so that s/he may marry again.
Common-Law Marriage
- Maryland does NOT authorize common law marriage.
- Maryland WILL recognize the common law marriage of a jurisdiction which permits it if:
- the jurisdiction authorizes a common law marriage;
- the parties intend to be married;
- they reach agreement;
- they make a public declaration; and
- they continuously cohabit
Annulment vs. Divorce
- Annulment is the legal determination that the marriage did not exist.
- Divorce is a legal determination that the marriage existed, but is terminated.
Void Marriages
A marriage is void, the law does not and did not recognize it. It never happened.
-
Grounds for Void Marraige:
- bigamy
- consanguinity
- expressly void by statute (i.e., age)
-
Void marraiges are subject to direct and collateral attack:
- direct attack–a party to the marriage challenges the marriage in an action for annulment by that spouse against the other. If one spouse is dead, such an action cannot be brought.
- collateral attack–the challenge to the marriage is incidental to another type of action
- no proceeding is necessary to declare a marriage void, but a formal declaration of annulment may be desirable.
Voidable Marriage
- A marriage is voidable for the following reasons:
- No valid license or ceremony
- Age
- Insanity
- Intoxication
- Duress
- Fraud
- A voidable marriage is subject to direct attack only (i.e., actin for annulment).
- Voidable marriages are _valid until declared void. _
Annulment
An annulment is the legal determination that the marriage never existed.
- As part of an annulment action, the court may award alimony, and classify, value, and distribute marital property as it would following a divorce.
- Children of a void or annulled marriage are declared illegitimate.
Divorce
Divorce is the legal determination by the state which puts an end to the marital relationship. There are two types of divorce:
- Absolute: ends the marriage permanently, permits remarriage, and terminates property claims.
- Limited: does not end the marriage, does not permit remarriage, but does provide for support and legalize the separation.
Grounds for Absolute Divorce
There are seven grounds for an absolute divorce. Remember: Seems Almost Every Divorce Involves Interesting Conduct.
- Separation
- Adultery
- Excessively Vicious Conduct
- Desertion
- Insanity
- Incarceration
- Cruelty
Maryland provides for divorce without regard to fault (no-fault divorce). If both parties agree to the divorce, they may obtain a divorce by living separate and apart for one year without cohabitation, without interuption, and without reasonable expectation of reconciliation.
- *
Absolute Divorce: One-Year Separation
A couple may file for absolute divorce after living separate and apart, without cohabitation, for one year without interuption.
- Always discuss desertion along with separation because the two are so similar.
- May not file until 12-month separation is complete.
Absolute Divorce: Adultery
Adultery is voluntary sexual intercourse between a married individual and someone other than that individual’s spouse.
- Justifies immediate filing for divorce
- May be proved by opportunity for adultery (spouse goes into woman’s house at 11 p.m., leaves at 5 a.m.) and disposition or inclination to commit adultery (displays of affection between spouse and paramour).
- There must be proof and corroboration in order to prevent collusion (cannot be granted on testimony of person seeking divorce).
Absolute Divorce: Excessively Vicious Conduct
Excessively vicious conduct requires conduct by a spouse toward the other spouse or minor child which endangers the life, person, or health, making the marraige impossible to maintain.
- Justifies immediate filing for divorce if there is no reasonable expectation of reconciliation.
Absolute Divorce: Desertion
Desertion is an unjustified separation of one spouse from the other with the intent to terminate the marriage.
-
May be actual or constructive
- actual–deserting spouse physically leaves the marraige without justification
- constructive–complaining spouse physically leaves having been driven from marriage by spouse who made continuing the marriage unbearable
- Desertion must continue for 12 months without interuption and there must be no reasonable expectation of reconciliation.
- Desertion must be a deliberate and final act.
- Deliberate unjustified refusal to have sex=desertion.
Absolute Divorce: Insanity
Divorce due to insantiy requires that:
- the insane spouse have been detained in a mental institution, hospital, etc. for at least three years;
- two physicians testify that there is no hope of recovery and the insanity is incurable; and
- one of the parties have been a resident of MD for at least two years before filing
Absolute Divorce: Incarceration
Incarceration is grounds for divorce where the defendant spouse has been sentenced to at least three years and has served at least twelve months.
- Felony or misdemeanor conviction is sufficient.
Absolute Divorce: Cruelty
Divorce on the grounds of cruelty requires conduct that so endangers the physical or mental health or safety of the spouse or minor child, rendering it impracticable to discharge the marital duties.
- Justifies immediate filing for divorce
- No reasonable hope of reconciliation
Limited Divorce
A limited divorce allows the aggrieved spouse the right to live separate and apart and may provide for support.
- Court may require, as condition precedent to granting, that parties participate in efforts to reconcile and to assess these costs.
Grounds for Limited Divorce
There are four grounds for limited divorce:
- Cruelty
- Excessively Vicious Conduct
- Desertion (can file immediately for limited divorce, need not wait 12 months)
- Voluntary Separation
Defenses to Divorce
There are five defenses to divorce:
- Condonation: forgiveness of marital offense (i.e., sex after adultery). Not a complete defense, only a factor.
- Recrimination: is a countercharge by offending spouse that the aggrieved spouse is also guilty of the offending conduct. Not a complete defense, only a factor.
- Connivance: is the consent or permission by the aggrieved spouse to the acts of the offending spouse.
- Collusion: is a conspiracy by parties to a divorce to defraud the court by the misrepresentation that grounds for divorce exist when they do not.
- Provocation: inciting spouse to commit a marital offense
Divorce: Jurisdiction
The Circuit Court has subject matter jurisdiction over divorce in Maryland.
Residency Requirement:
- If grounds for divorce occur in Maryland, at least one party must be domiciled in Maryland (no time limit) for MD court to have jurisdiction. Domiciled = lives and votes in MD with the intent to make MD the residence.
- If grounds for divorce occur outside of Maryland, at least one party must be a resident of Maryland for one year.
Masters Hearings
- A Master, similar to a magistrate, holds hearings and makes recommendations to Circuit Court on uncontested divorces, alimony, child support, and use and possession orders.
Divorce: Venue
A plaintiff-spouse may file a complaint for divorce in the county where the plaintiff resides OR where the defendant resides, is regularly employed, or has a place of business.
Divorce: Complaint & Corroboration
Plaintiff spouse must file a complaint alleging the grounds for divorce that exist at the time of filing.
- Each element of the grounds must be corroborated by a witness.
- Oral testimony is required before a final divorce decree can be entered
Child Custody Generally
Court decides when, where, and with whom a child will spend time and how decisions about the child will be made.
Types of Custody:
- Physical Custody involves physical responsibility for the child and responsibility for day to day decisions.
- Legal Custody involves responsibility for important decisions.
Mediation of Custody & Visitation Disputes
- If custody or visitation is at issue, the court must determine if mediation is appropriate. Mediation is NOT appropriate where there is a genuine issue of physical or sexual abuse of a party or child.
Child Custody: Best Interest of the Child Standard
The overarching consideration in custody determination is the best interest of the child. The best interest of the child is determined considering the following factors:
- the fitness of the parents
- the characther and reputation of the parties
- the desire of the natural parents and agreements between them
- the potential for maintaining natural family relations
- the preference of the child (if child is of sufficient age and capacity to form a rational judgment)
- material opportunities affecting the future life of the child
- the age, health, and sex of the child
- the residences of the parents and opportunity for visitation
- the length of the separation of the parties
- whether there was a prior voluntary abandonment or surrender of custody of the child
Child Custody: Sole or Joint
The court will decide whether custody should be awarded to one parent or both. Court must declare how the physical and legal custody is apportioned.
Factors Relating to the Parents
- desire of both parents to participate in joint custody
- ability of the parents to communicate and agree w/r/t important decisions regarding the child
- parents’ ability to cooperate
- the geographical proximity of the parties
- the fitness of the parents
- demands of parental employment
- financial status of the parents
- impact on state or federal assistance
- the benefit to the parents
Factors Relating to the Family
- the relationship between the child and each parent
Factors Relating to the Child
- the preference of the child
- potential disruption of the child’s social and school life
- the age and number of children
Modification of Custody Order
A court maintains continuing jurisdiction to modify a custody order if there is a material change in circumstances which could adversely impact the child.
Custody Jurisdiction: Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA)
Maryland has adopted the UCCJEA under which out-of-state custody decrees are extended full faith and credit. Maryland will give the decree-rendering state a strong presumption of continuing modification jurisdiction until all or almost all of the state’s connection with the parents and the child is lost.
Child Visitation
Non-custodial parent must be provided reasonable visitation. Reasonableness is determined based on factors such as the geographical proximity of the parents, their employment demands, and the age of the child.
Exception for Abuse or Neglect
- If the court has reasonable grounds (preponderance of the evidence) to believe that a child has been abused or neglected, the court shall deny custody or visitation unless the court specifically finds that there is no likelihood of further abuse or neglect.
Interferencee w/ Visitation
- If court-ordered visitation is unjustifiably interfered with, court may reschedule, modify the order, or asess costs against interfering party.
Third-Party Visitation
- A third party may petition for visitation, but first, must show “exceptional circumstances” that justify overriding the parent’s objection and must be in child’s best interest.
- A third-party must show exceptional circumstances or that parent is unfit.
- There is a presumption that a parent has the right to determine whether a third party should have visitation with a child and this presumption will not be disturbed absent extraordinary circumstances.